In post 1018, Aquanim wrote:@Elk
: Yesterday you said that Knell would be your greatest scumread if Madonna flipped town. What is your read on him now and why?
Knell is one of my stronger scumreads (probably #3 at the moment behind Trick and NM). Both his and Hemp's day 1 play made me fairly suspicious, most of which I've already explained in my notes copypaste post. The argument based on the Madonna flip being town was more that Madonna flipping scum would have led to associative cases, whereas Madonna flipping town means that I'm talking without associations to Madonna. Knell had one of the stronger cases without associations, hence that comment.
That said, after my more recent rereads and after his Day 2 play, I'd say that Knell has been playing more pro-town than I had previously given him credit for. I would also say that the way he tried to defuse/reset the argument between you and Thor was pro-town, but possibly "cheap towncred".
@Thor
: I know you found the argument with Aqua frustrating and unproductive; the real question is, was Aqua persisting in the argument out of a scummy desire to hold back town, or was this argument made with town-intentions?