In post 1855, borkjerfkin wrote:Well you disagree with my assertion that it is town with the town motivation I have attributed to it and are being really vague in telling me how I'm wrong or how its null or how it actually leans scum or whatever argument you seem to be trying to make.
You are trying to get me to explain to you how your gut-read is wrong? How can I explain how a premise based on gut is wrong other than to explain that a gut-feeling is not a valid argument?
In post 1855, borkjerfkin wrote:So it doesn't look like bmws was genuinely trying to read mala there? Why is it "more of a scum tell than a town tell"
No, I don't think he was trying to read mala there. I think he was trying to look like he was reading mala there, but that is my gut-feeling. You're asking me to explain why my gut-feeling disagrees with your gut-feeling, and I can't explain that to you.
I'm honestly very confused at what you are confused about here.
I thought it was ultimately a null. You thought it was town. I said I thought there was a bigger chance it was scum than town. You asked why I thought it was scum. I explained that I didn't really think it was scum, but that I thought there was a greater chance of it being scum than town. Why? Because my gut tells me there was a greater chance that it was him trying to look town and using twilight as an opportunity to do so than him actually questioning Mala as town.
Long-story-short: Null, but given Scum and Town as only options, Scum.