Okay here's a run down of reads, per request.
I don't think these things are actually useful to the thread at large, as it appears to me that people usually just look for their own name and then respond, while ignoring the rest, so y'all will get a mostly one-liner situation based off my memory of how I felt about everyone's play.
wgeurts
: scummy posting early on, then it became more leanish town near the end of D1, then null.
Flubbernugget
: town posting throughout, though mostly unhelpful
droog
: I want to say town posting, but paranoia is getting to the better of me; lean town for now.
Alchemist21
: scum candidate, more on that later.
Ankamius
: scum candidate, more on that later.
VictorDeAngelo
: I thought Amy's posts read pretty town; I think Victor's replaced-in posting style is scummy, but the fact that he's running with it while people have stated how much they dislike it reads town, as it looks like Victor isn't actually looking at up-to-date posting while reading through for the first time. Not saying that
only
scum
would
look at up-to-date posting while reading through (for various reasons, including the fact that I kept an eye on what was going on in new posts while reading through, and I know that I am town), but that scum
would not
(likely) just ignore the present-day game while reading through, and scum would probably like to readjust their style to stop doing something several players have said that they really hate.
Aneninen
: I thought his posting was lean town until his soft claim, which I thought was scummy, but that's the only problem I've seen with his play.
Formerfish
: likely town based off of his play (his slot's prior occupant was lurker suspicious, but not all infrequent posters to the point of being replaced are scum), but his frequent cursing raises my hackles - not because cursing is bad (fuck that shit), but because I don't recall him cursing as much in the one previous game I played with him + I played with someone who had a perfectly adequate but not infallible theory that excessive cursing was indicative of possible scum alignment as it was a forced attempt to look more emotionally invested in whatever = paranoia.
TheAdrienC
: lean town; potential for lurker scum, but I'm just not feeling it.
Mathdino
: when I read his posts, I think town; when I read criticisms of him, I think scummy. Don't know what to do with him.
farside22
: null, leaning town; her play - though still very much farside - feels different from her scum game in an Open Game that we just wrapped up, but nothing so far leaps out to me one way or another.
Green Crayons
: lol I replaced a 15 year old; hoooooly shit I remember that age. It sucked.
"This Court has never held that the Constitution forbids the execution of a convicted defendant who has had a full and fair trial but is later able to convince a habeas court that he is 'actually' innocent." In re Davis, 557 U.S. 952, 955 (2009) (Scalia, J., dissenting).
