this post is my main reason for thinking tier is scum. Hearing the accusation against him, his first response is to ask if we can lynch me, He doesnt even attempt to justify why its wrong nor does to do anything to suggest why im scum. His reason for voting me at the point when he suggests it would be a scenario which requires him to be scum also. I know im town, but that doesnt make tier town. anen could be on the money with his post about tier and commenting on anen's meta. but if he is, tier didnt get it from me.
Did you read Tier's later posts that explained both reasons?
this post is my main reason for thinking tier is scum. Hearing the accusation against him, his first response is to ask if we can lynch me, He doesnt even attempt to justify why its wrong nor does to do anything to suggest why im scum. His reason for voting me at the point when he suggests it would be a scenario which requires him to be scum also. I know im town, but that doesnt make tier town. anen could be on the money with his post about tier and commenting on anen's meta. but if he is, tier didnt get it from me.
Did you read Tier's later posts that explained both reasons?
AA9 is town too for post 98, she spoke my thoughts out loud in parts.
this post is my main reason for thinking tier is scum. Hearing the accusation against him, his first response is to ask if we can lynch me, He doesnt even attempt to justify why its wrong nor does to do anything to suggest why im scum. His reason for voting me at the point when he suggests it would be a scenario which requires him to be scum also. I know im town, but that doesnt make tier town. anen could be on the money with his post about tier and commenting on anen's meta. but if he is, tier didnt get it from me.
Did you read Tier's later posts that explained both reasons?
i believe his explanation for the original reason he posted his thoughts. that seems genuine. But i must be missing the explanation where he explains that his first reaction is just to push my lynch over his. Can someone quote that for me becuase i dont see that?
that's the main reason i think tier is scum. his intital reaction to the accusation, not the actual accusation itself
In post 63, TierShift wrote:Alchemist, here is the explanation you wanted.
In this game (http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=83&t=60039), I decided to progress RVS quicker by going along with the obvious gambit, essentially lying up to page 3/4. That turned out very well. I got some reads off it, RVS ended quickly and it was a perfect town win.
I was pretty content with how I played that RVS there and tried to do something as to elicit a reaction from anen. I was under the assumption anen's case would not be followed (as it is pretty ridiculous), so I felt safe to portray myself as 'caught scum', posting throwaway remarks instead of responding, in the hopes of egging anen on and seeing what would happen. From town-him, I'd expect outrage over how I obviously avoided his case. From scum (I don't say scum-him as I don't have meta on that), I'd rather expect a somewhat grumpy response as others laughed at his case (which incidentally is part of the reason I'm townreading you, alchemist).
In the end, it did not turn out this way, as I am being wagoned. I do think my 22 was fruitful, though; I'm reasonably confident in my townread on you and I've found probable scum awkwardly jumping on my wagon. I also feel somewhat happy about the guy with the weed avatar.
As for why I shouldn't be voted for my #22: I could have very, very easily just outright said why I heard anen's scumgame was good. Attracting attention to myself instead has no scum motivation.
Alchemist, will you join me on dodgy? He's quite dodgy.
P-edit: wow that's quite a lot hehe
@Dodgy, he linked this game where he does something similar. He goes along with something he knows is wrong as a sort of reaction test. I think he's saying that's what he tried to do here.
Why didn't you explain your reason for scumreading Tier at first though?
Also I just realized the last part of my 96 was wrong and you actually did deny Anen's accusation about you being scum.
In post 111, dodgy56 wrote:i believe his explanation for the original reason he posted his thoughts. that seems genuine. But i must be missing the explanation where he explains that his first reaction is just to push my lynch over his. Can someone quote that for me becuase i dont see that?
that's the main reason i think tier is scum. his intital reaction to the accusation, not the actual accusation itself
Have you actually been keeping up with this game?
Do you think that I admitted to being scum in that post, but wanting to lynch you over me? How does that make sense?
