Mini 1646: Quil's Smalltown (Game over!)

[Antihero]

i'm keeping my vote on viomi with this clear, concise, and cogent reasoning

Spoiler:

lol

[DeasVail]

Wow there wasn't as much as there looked.

I like DV even less than I did before after the awkwardness of 485, and pretty much have him/Flubber/Vi as my main scumreads now. Nothing Vi has said has dissuaded me from wanting him lynched, and Boo is a terrible lynch toDay.

It's on!

[VictorDeAngelo]

Dun dun dun!

[VictorDeAngelo]

Also, you never answered my question.

[DeasVail]

You're the person I feel least uncomfortable with the idea of lynching. That's all there is to it really.

[DeasVail]

That's the reasoning with which I vig people though...

[Antihero]

<insert comment pimping out new scummie for credibility>

[Bookitty]

<insert comment that indicates fear and/or admiration of DeasVail and/or Antihero>
<insert comment that is obviously buddying of Antihero and/or DeasVail>
<insert generic comment intended to look town>

In seriousness, congrats to both you guys. You're awesome.

[Marquis]

deadline is in just over a day and despite what i said earlier i really don't want to settle for a viomi lynch

+ viomi saying weird things that are... disagreeable

- dangerously quick wagon
- viomi saying things that make her no friends
- continuing to say those things, sounds like foot in mouth brutal honesty rather than scum sticking to bad fabrication
- i literally cannot remember a valid reason or explanation for the aronis wagon dissolving the way it did

[Marquis]

also congrats to all you kids with blackboxes. boo in particular bc that's the most important one

[Bookitty]

@Marquis: <3 Congrats to you too!

Yours is definitely the scary one to me.

[BBmolla]

The people in this game are so fucking unreadable jesus fuck

[Marquis]

booooooo! (<-- is a ghost)

The people in this game are so fucking unreadable jesus fuck

start with "marquis is town" and work from there

[Marquis]

there are a lot of people saying aronis is scum or mildly scummy but it's like i'm the only one who actually wants to lynch him

and there isn't even any valid role-based argument against it

why is it not happening. why are we wagoning viomi instead? for having different opinions??

[Quilford]

• 
  
  Vote count 1.18
  
  
  >>> Viomi (6)— Antihero, Jingle, Bookitty, VictorDeAngelo, xRECKONERx, Flubbernugget <<<
  VictorDeAngelo (2)— DeasVail, Aronis
  Bookitty (2)— farside22, Viomi
  Antihero (1)— Shiidaji
  Aronis (1)— Marquis
  
  Not Voting (1)— BBmolla
  
  It takes 7 to lynch or no lynch.
  
  
  Deadline
  
  
  >> Day 1 will be 10 days long. The deadline has once again resumed, with (expired on 2015-02-27 02:46:57) to go. <<
  
  
  Mod notes
  
  
  Remember, you can request an updated Role PM containing your selected role's info any time you like, as detailed in the Setup post.

[Flubbernugget]

why is it not happening. why are we wagoning viomi instead? for having different opinions??

Amished and more concerned with defense than scumhunting.

[Bookitty]

Grib was wagoned for being scummy. Viomi came in and announced that she too thought he was scummy. She ISOed herself (that's the Amished tell) and me only. Then she made a huge case against me that is pretty horribly slanted in Post 389. She hadn't even read the game at that point nor had she apparently done more than ISO those two slots. It felt to me like she came in with an agenda and tried to force everything to fit that agenda with no regard for the truth, context or anything else.

I normally unvote when a replacement comes in, but that pretty well convinced me not to do so.

To me the wagon hasn't felt really quick, but I think that's because I've been arguing with her for what seems like aeons now.

[farside22]

Marquis: Vote Boo, I promise to have a case together tomorrow (even if I have to kick my hubby in the shins and steal the computer away)

I would appriecate any hammer that may happen to at least wait. I'm not going to push too hard on the wait since I could just aim at Boo tonight but I didn't really trust Pine and BB hasn't really said anything exciting thus far. Don't trust Arnois and I feel the interaction between Boo and me in regards to Aronis is just weird for how it got there. I think I've said this about 3 times but I never stopped or told her not to ask questions about Arnois and the whole hem and haw aspect of wanting to lynch but not wanting to lynch.

EPWOP: Looking at the player you replaced and saying their actions is scummy, is not a scum fucking tell.

[Marquis]

viomi is experienced enough to know what the amished tell is. viomi-scum would most likely avoid it. and the amished tell as of late is 1) inaccurate and 2) almost always applies to newer scumplayers on the chance it's correct. it is a null point.

viomi IS scumhunting (even if her angles are unpleasant) and you can't expect someone with a wagon this large to not try and spend a significant amount of time on the defensive

your reasons are self-fulfilling and a cop out. who are your other scumreads.

pedit @ farside i'm not voting one of my largest townreads. nobody else is going to either. try another.

@ boo why would viomi scum target you? you're a general townread voting her slot and the threat of an attack as scum being construed as omgus is too strong. it doesn't make sense for scum to do that, but more sense for town to do so. i know when i'm town the first thing i do is iso my predecessor and see who's voting me. i see town!viomi as more likely to see you're voting her, trying to figure out why, and [for reasons i disagree with] thinking you're scum taking further discussion of it into account

[Marquis]

i'll take a scumteam of aronis/flubber/pineslot for 200

maybe reck/vda. that wagon is ugh

[Marquis]

plan: jake picks vv, lynch jake, vanillaise marquis

plan?

still up for this but with flubber as vv.

also seeing vda replaced jake, he's in third/fourth around the same level as bbmolla/pine with reck in a distant fifth

[Bookitty]

@Marquis:

I'm fine with an Aronis lynch (I'm sure I said that before). It's worth remembering that Antihero takes the role of the first person lynched, so he'd be the Ascetic then. Viomi has pushed for both my lynch and for Antihero's lynch; if we're going to keep her and her extreme-wall angry posting around, I think I would actually prefer to be the lynch myself and to give my role to Antihero than to have him be an investigation-proof role that she would then tunnel on in the way she's demonstrated so far.

@MOD:

If I am lynched, will Antihero be able to use my role tonight? Also, if Aronis is lynched, will Antihero be the Ascetic tonight?

Back to Marquis:

I think Viomi is the scummiest. I don't see a reason why town would come into the game, tunnel on one player from the start, misrep what I said, make up reasons why I said things and generally behave in the ways she has behaved. I don't know why she's come into the game with this agenda (I was not the only vote on Grib when she entered the game, but I was the only one who made a case on him I think -- a case with which she claims to agree) but at this point I honestly don't care.

@Farside:

I have asked you this repeatedly. Why did you think Pine would steal your role if he were scum? You understand that your role only works if you die, right? Why would scum want your role especially? It's completely useless for the SK and only creates a one-for-one trade for scum, so why would you think scum would want it?

If you are town, you have already said you will target me for the kill tonight if you are killed. This is just as bad as Viomi wanting to know what the night actions will be. You've just told scum that if they want to take me out (or take out one of our protective roles, of which we have but two) then all they have to do is target you. Best case scenario, you take out me alone and deprive town of one of its power roles. Worst case, you take out a bodyguard while the SK targets me and we lose three potential town for the price of one. WHY would you say who you would target in this way?

I don't want the protectives to say who they will protect. I don't want the roleblocker to say who he's going to roleblock. I'm sure as hell not telling anyone who I'm targeting and I don't think Reck should either. So why are you so eager to volunteer this information to help scum decide what to do?

[Jingle]

<insert comment pimping out new scummie for credibility>

Nobody listens to people who win Game of the Year, you whore.

[Bookitty]

your reasons are self-fulfilling and a cop out. who are your other scumreads.

You understand why there's no way I'm going to tell you that based on my role, right?

[Marquis]

i was talking to flubber. i know where you stand.