Battlestar Galactica Mafia - Game over!

[curiouskarmadog]

1. If Ooba was trying to reach out to someone with multiple one-shot powers to tell them that they were the sleeper, Val is the only possible one he could have meant because no one else had reported such powers. Maybe the scum know the role of the sleeper too, but we have no way of knowing that.

oookay. I got this line of thinking now.

for some reason, I am under the impression the scum team do not know who the sleeper is (either). do we know for a fact they do? or do they typically in this type of (bastard) role?

[curiouskarmadog]

Poro why do you think the sleeper already knows they are indeed the sleeper?

I don't, I think ooba potentially reached out to them.

So what made you think that Val was the sleeper? Or that Val KNEW she was the sleeper?

are these not valid questions? clearly I am not getting something here.

[AngryPidgeon]

Why are we screening Prozac? 'Cause he has a tinfoil theory that Val is the sleeper and you guys think he's actually manipulative scum?

Ya I'm skimming right now. Today is my first day at new job.

I don't get the screen wagon on Porochaz though. Hes certainly at least being superficially protown. Enough so that I'm inclined to trust my gut town read on him. Not sure why people think hes a good screen over me, sangres, or LLD.

[AngryPidgeon]

CKD is asking all these questions that would be obvious if he would just read the thread.

[Bookitty]

One player will switch sides. Exactly one player will be told at the start of the game that they are human only to later discover, through circumstances yet to be revealed, that they are in fact the Cylon Sleeper Agent with a scum win con. The Cylon Sleeper Agent would flip as such on death even if they had not yet discovered their own true nature.

The sleeper implicitly DOES NOT KNOW that they are the sleeper. What the scum know or don't know is anyone's guess. If Ooba-scum knows who the sleeper is, he might want to alert them to that fact so they don't waste shots. Alternatively, it might be a gambit. We just don't know.

[AngryPidgeon]

Or maybe comprehending Poro's desire to screen VR is really that hard to understand, idk.

[curiouskarmadog]

CKD is asking all these questions that would be obvious if he would just read the thread.

I am caught up...give me an example.

[AngryPidgeon]

1.

If Ooba was trying to reach out to someone with multiple one-shot powers to tell them that they were the sleeper, Val is the only possible one he could have meant

because no one else had reported such powers. Maybe the scum know the role of the sleeper too, but we have no way of knowing that.

The bolded is just mind numbingly wrong.

Like, no? If scum know who the sleeper agent is and know shit about their role, then he could be referring to MOST PEOPLE who haven't claimed yet. What the fuck.

Can we stop talking about Ooba and VR? Hes managed to create PAGES of horseshit in which we argue good policy and CKD asks us to spoonfeed him an explanation of the process at every single step of the way, only delayed a few pages. Jesus. Can we just make a halfway decent screen and quicklynch confirmed trolling scum? The sooner we never talk about the WIFOM behind confirmed scum's posts the sooner I can get back to directing my bitter disappointment towards RIP posts.

P-edit: Like right where I'm reading right now you literally just asked Poro why he thought/knew VR was the sleeper when he already explained that she is probably a JOAT and Ooba was talking about a JOAT.

[AngryPidgeon]

Nero, you will townread me sometime

Actually you did in X-men mafia so I can't QQ about how you always scumread me. TBF though, I roll scum in like 50% of the games you are in with me.

[Nero Cain]

*shrugz* just others seem townier than you. There's only 2 team scum left (probs) so 3 or my "scum reads" are wrong.

[curiouskarmadog]

I like to be spoon fed. Makes me feel all warm inside. I think i get it now.

I guess I found it hard to swallow that Prozac wanted to screen Val, based on a message from ooba. I felt like I was missing something else.

[Porochaz]

Why are we screening Prozac? 'Cause he has a tinfoil theory that Val is the sleeper and you guys think he's actually manipulative scum?

Ya I'm skimming right now. Today is my first day at new job.

I don't get the screen wagon on Porochaz though. Hes certainly at least being superficially protown. Enough so that I'm inclined to trust my gut town read on him. Not sure why people think hes a good screen over me, sangres, or LLD.

Im a better choice than LLD. That much I can agree with.

[Brian Skies]

Unvote: Ooba

Still scum. I just want to get the screen done first.

Screen: LLD

Can we get this going? She's not giving us much of anything to read her off of and she's been sitting on a self-screen vote for most of this game. I feel pretty inclined to call her bluff right now.

I can't remember who mentioned it earlier, but I did like the good cop bad cop theory regarding Boo earlier. I'm not really suspicious of Boo for that as much as I am with her "I'm not sure if Cylons=scum" and her seeming so focused on calling Bro scum for his flavor. I'm just not feeling as good about her right now as I think I should be and don't think she's a terrible option to explore.

As much as I want to say the Poro wagon is a good wagon, I had the same reaction to Ooba's reach-out and I would probably have pointed it out if he hadn't. I just feel there are better options and we can always revisit it, say, Day 4 when an alignment change would be a little more obvious or telling. We already know Sleeper-VR might be a thing, so why waste a screen there?

[curiouskarmadog]

Unscreen Prozac

Screen LLD

also if there is a flash bookitty screen. I would join it.

I agree with the above.

also, I just dont see Prozac(Scum) trying to direct the screen just get rid of the JOAT?

[curiouskarmadog]

also if I ever think i need to be humbled, I know where to go.

[Porochaz]

Lulz Im sure you guys are in collaboration just to frustrate me.

[Porochaz]

also if I ever think i need to be humbled, I know where to go.

?

[curiouskarmadog]

mafia...think i am too sensitive for it. LOL.

[curiouskarmadog]

LOL.

<---tears on the inside...so many tears and self doubt.

[Nero Cain]

I just rather lynch LLD then waste our last screen on a scum slot.

[Brian Skies]

How do you feel about screening Boo?

[Nero Cain]

better but I'm pretty meh on her. I'd love me a WL screen.

AP why are you saying that you'd make a good screen?

[RIP]

It's that a hammer on poro screen?
Let's get that figured out before someone hammers OOBA my mistake.

[NotAnAxehole]

I will go more into detail later, but

Screen: Porochaz

Since everyone is refusing to discuss the point I brought up about screen strategy, I've decided this is the best route. We should screen our highest sleeper suspects and on a tie, screen the one we prefer to have alive.

At this point, all I can say is, I think porochaz has a fair chance of being the sleeper (as I previously indicated). If he isn't the sleeper, he is on the top of my list to not lynch. Since eventually it will come down to screen or lynch on these players, he is my top screen.

I think LLD is tomorrow's obvious lynch, waste of a screen.

I also think angrypidgeon could be scum... Nothing concrete yet, just gut feeling. It has to be him or the guy who isn't in the game.

[Nero Cain]

Would be kinda lame if peace were scum