Well I've already explained my town read on him in D1, but I'll check to see if there is any new content on him. NQT more than anyone tried to address more than just a couple of people, showing to me that he wasn't leaving any stones unturned. I especially liked his push on Domino (granted, him following up with "im in the middle on him" was mehh). We haven't seen much of him Day 2.
In post 631, notquitethere wrote:Hot damn do mafiascum days last long. I'll do a read list when I get back to this a bit later today, but seriously Jazzmin, JohnnyFarrar, Mainez, and ToastyToast should stop wasting everybody's time and cast their votes already.
No. I want to vote Kalimar, but this situation is too similar to the CoolDog lynch atm. Everyone is just sort of deferring to a Kalimar lynch instead of weighing other potential options. We have four days, and everyone should be using them to do just that.
In post 629, Big The Cat wrote: In post 530, ToastyToast wrote:Alright so, idk if any of you have ever seen my scum theory thingy, but I generally see scum as fitting one of 3 categories. More likely than not, there is one of each.
I disagree with this.
It's also like saying, more likely than not one scum is on the D1 mislynch wagon, and one scum is off. Or things of that nature. It's just a shitty way to scumhunt in my opinion, because you limit your options of who scum could be by assuming they are 1 of each in three pools.
Yes I am clearly such a lazy player. Using a theory that works for me as a backbone for making cases and figuring out scum teams is super lazy. Maybe I should just never give a single case, and just spout out names in list form without explanation. Maybe I should just call people stupid if I don't like what they have to say. That's really active--oh wait, that's what BigCat/BROseidon have done this entire game.
Your view of what I'm doing with this is incredibly simplistic.
1) I'm not just throwing people into 3 piles then random.orging it. Once those groups are defined, I push cases to determine which of the three is scummiest. I also take into account situations where it isn't true. If, for example, Kalimar flips scum, I'm not going to suddenly call West9 obvtown. Mafia has no absolutes, only chance. And the
chance
of them being scum together is significantly lower than other potential pairings.
2) The odds of 3 people from one of the groups is miniscule. And you disagreeing with me on this is irrelevant to alignment. I use it every game I'm in.
3)
Groups do not function well with 3 leaders.
The scum teams that function best have a group willing to take a variety of roles. That way, they are never completely pinned down.
4) If your strategy is to just point at people without using some sort of strategy that pinpoints scum, then you might as well just be shooting blind.