Star Trek Deep Space Nine Season 1 Mafia(game over!)

[Klingoncelt]

Sinsun why u think I make a far out claim as scum?
My claim is simple I'm a conditional tracker. The guy I'm in the show is a perfect fit.
They think he is a spy.
I'm also friends with bashir.

And CBd claimed that, so unless they were given bashir as fake claim and put his name in my role so I vouch for him, I don't think how dumb you are to think I'll link myself to my wolf buddy.

As Kling how good I did to distance myself from her and other scum in that game she post

VOTE: peregrine
Narm is getting a free pass for now

It's very likely that Scum will target you tonight.

Give me some clarification. You keep saying that you're friends with Bashir. CDB as yet hasn't addressed that claim at all. Are you two Best Friends? Neighbors? What?

Why are you going after PerV and moving off Narn?

Kling, me and cDb aren't role related.
I'm goin on a hunch that they mention him in my role so I know he's town.
Then again I think he's done shit and I might be wrong. I don't want him to die though we will see

No. Dr. Bashir and Garek were both working on DS9, but they weren't closely aligned. Bashir was too busy having a crush on Jadzia Dax. Garek was trying to keep a low profile and stay on everyone's good side.

If Bashir was mentioned in your PM then there's a specific reason for it, related to the game.

He wouldn't be mentioned in a Tracker's PM.






(Star Trek trivia, Dr. Bashir and Kira Nerys were married in real life.)

[Klingoncelt]

Off - topic here, but are occasional blue sparks normal from the keyboard when typing? I think I have a problem.

[Thor665]

No. Dr. Bashir and Garek were both working on DS9, but they weren't closely aligned. Bashir was too busy having a crush on Jadzia Dax. Garek was trying to keep a low profile and stay on everyone's good side.

They were always the buddy pair during Season 1 though because Bashir wanted to derp around playing spy.
The Bashit/Miles combo didn't pop up till later on as I recall.
I would easily expect a flavor mention - my PM had a flavor writeup.

We are down to 8 days till deadline.
So we're actually going to manage to deadline derp lynch CDB...whee.
Why not just lynch him now then, if we're all so apathetic, let's speed things up.

[Thor665]

Also, I will explicitly state that I don't care what (if anything, or ever) CDB might manage to add to the game at this point.
Rope, rope and a drop.

[Suzune]

This game frustrates me because we barely talk about anything.

[Klingoncelt]

This game frustrates me because we barely talk about anything.

It's a big holiday weekend, don't expect much from anyone before Monday.

The CDB flip and RIP's track should give us something to talk about.

[RIP]

Yes but once I'm conf town I feel like CBd will be too. I don't see why killing him now will do any good

[Riabi]

Yes I won't. I made it clear.
I don't have any extra info for my reads, they are just that.

No information... 112 pages, and you have NOTHING????!!!

Yes but once I'm conf town ...

That phrase, I don't think it means what you think it means...

Can someone please tell me what sense it makes to be lynching CBD when he's not done anything scummy? Why do we want to kill someone who is/was an easy frame job if they've not done anything to be worried about? That whole wagon worries the hell out of me. Especially considering how little opposition there is to it. Scum is clearly running this game, it seems like they might want this lynch as well. We no longer have the luxury of lyncyhing "for information" now we need to actually lynch scum, or we're going to find ourselves in a world of hurt really fast.

[RIP]

Riabi, so u quote my post to tell me u agree with me?
Cuz I'm the one defending him but u make it seem like I'm bad?

[Thor665]

Yes but once I'm conf town I feel like CBd will be too. I don't see why killing him now will do any good

How does you being town make CDB town?

Can someone please tell me what sense it makes to be lynching CBD when he's not done anything scummy?

I don't know about other people, but I have claimed that CDB *has* done scummy stuff.
Also, even if you think he has done nothing scummy at all - then you shouldn't be debating that, you should be pushing someone you think has done something scummy.

Why do we want to kill someone who is/was an easy frame job if they've not done anything to be worried about?

Even presuming he has done nothing to worry about - the reason he is an easy frame job is *exactly* the reason to kill him. SOmeone isn't an easy frame job because they look like town last I checked - which means you agree that he doesn't look town, and at that stage that's already halfway to being a valid lynch option.

That whole wagon worries the hell out of me. Especially considering how little opposition there is to it.

I will agree that it is a wagon with little opposition that is proving really hard to push through.

Scum is clearly running this game, it seems like they might want this lynch as well.

Then why didn't it happen yesterday when we got him to L-1 with double hammer intent?

We no longer have the luxury of lyncyhing "for information" now we need to actually lynch scum, or we're going to find ourselves in a world of hurt really fast.

Agreed.
Though every lynch is "for information".
That said - every vote should also be on someone you think is potential scum.
I believe that to be true about CDB - look at his last five posts or so and explain to me why you think any of it looks like town. I don't think you can. If he is town, he is playing in an anti-town and pro-scum manner by dramatically avoiding giving input. If he is scum he is working an acceptable defense by playing the lurk card, and is assuredly trying to minimize his interactions at this stage.

I don't see anywhere in your posting here any opinion about a superior lynch option though.
Maybe I missed it?
If you're so opposed to CDB you need to offer an alternative, not simply empty defense (an I do find this defense very empty - it's a defense that could be applied to anyone "oh, what is the use of lynching someone who may be framable? And scum probably want it, because there is no counter...even though a counter can be a town or scum effort - and there were multiple counters to it yesterday" It's meaningless, and (on a personal note) annoying, because it's not even addressing my raised issues with the slot.

[Thor665]

Not Voting

(5): Channel Delibird, ArcAngel9,

Riabi

, PeregrineV, Narninian

I mean, seriously now - what are you doing?

[Thor665]

Though, honestly, what the hell is Pere doing also.

@Pere - weren't you for this lynch?

I kinda want to lynch Pere just for being a lurksack now - I don't think I've ever seen him do that before.

[Narninian]

Vote: ChannelDelibird

apparently my vote wasn't being counted.

[Thor665]

That puts us at L-3 on CDB.
Beware the rage of this unrestrained war wagon of speed so fast it's unnerving[/sarcasm]

[Thor665]

RIP[2]: Davesez, Riabi

Mod actually has Riabi up twice, so maybe he's actually advancing this case.
I'm not sure what the case is, but I'm sure it's better than the one on CDB. I may have to go look.

[Thor665]

Post 2597 looks pretty damning to me. It does look like RIP lied. He's definitely my strongest scum read so far.

I actually don't dislike this case.
But, meh, the CDB one is just as good in my opinion.
Maybe we'll lynch RIP tomorrow.

[Thor665]

Though, thinking about it, beyond "he's derping it up to cloud things" I'm not sure I actually see the scum motive to the lie.

So I guess I'd support lynching him for signal/noise ratio issues, but will clarify that though I think there is a possible lie, I'm not sure what the scum goal was. So...?

[RIP]

I lied about something alright.
Not one but the illusion is almost over. I need one more day. Game is over.

[Klingoncelt]

I lied about something alright.
Not one but the illusion is almost over. I need one more day. Game is over.

Fuck, was that a Scumclaim??!!

[Klingoncelt]

Though, honestly, what the hell is Pere doing also.

@Pere - weren't you for this lynch?

I kinda want to lynch Pere just for being a lurksack now - I don't think I've ever seen him do that before.

PereV seems to have siteflaked 4 days ago. I hope he's okay....

[Titus]

I think that

VOTE: Nero Cain is an excellent compromise wagon.

[Sinsun1]

I lied about something alright.
Not one but the illusion is almost over. I need one more day. Game is over.

UNVOTE: CDB
VOTE: RIP

As far as I am concerned, that's a hard scum-claim. Anyone not voting RIP by deadline is up on tomorrow's chopping block. No excuses. You don't hard claim like this as scum unless you're sure majority of active players are scum and the lynch wouldn't go through.

So I am stating it now, if your next post isn't a vote RIP post, you're tomorrow's lynch target as you are confirming you're on a team with him.

[Riabi]

@ Thor, that vote count is obviously wrong, as it has me on it twice. I'm voting for RIP, I've been voting for RIP, and I'll continue voting for RIP. He's scum, and now that it appears he just admitted it, you should vote him too.

[Klingoncelt]

Damn, I was really hoping he was Town.

VOTE: RIP

[Suzune]

I lied about something alright.
Not one but the illusion is almost over. I need one more day. Game is over.

I mean if we are at the claiming we lied part right here. You might as well share your secrets.