Scum was lynched D1. It seems likely that scum can be found in people:
- who were NOT on the scum D1 wagon, and
- who ARE on the main D2 wagon.
Those people are spicer and boon. Looking at spicer's ISO:
863 - two days in, says woody is town
1089 - the next post, 4 days later, says pisskop is town
1098 - quoting Annarchy saying "I actually get a town read out of spicer's 1089," spicer says, "What about it gave you a town read?" Seriously? Why would town ask that?
1099 - buddying with KK and trying to preempt my point above, that there's gonna be scum in the people who weren't on the scum lynch.
1115 - 1192 tunneling grayfox
1193 - more buddying with KK
1272 - 8 days in he finally makes a vote. I'm beginning to take lack of voting as a scumtell, I suppose to keep their names out of VCs since those get used more later in the game.
1275 - I hate this. Dom says he doesn't like the fox vote because "It seems you are voting for something weird not something scummy." spicer then asks, "well what do you not like about it?" He just told you what he doesn't like about it. This is a tactic to give an appearance of having addressed a point without actually addressing it.
1438 - Reads list with grayfox as third scummiest, after imp and dom. A couple problems:
1. Where do the imp and dom scum reads come from? You've mostly been attacking gray and kissing kk's ass so far.
2. There's a good chance this is a 10:3 setup with a vig, which would mean their are 2 scum left. You have 2 people scummier than gray and a week left in phase. You should have changed your vote to one of them, or put pressure on some other way. This reads list comes across as town who realizes he's been tunneling one guy and needs to do something to appear like he's really considering the entire field.
Finally, spicer's predecessor's ISO is horrible.
18 - too eager in RVS
70 - finds the idea of multiple suspects on D1 strange and votes mario for it
73 - backs off - "However, I am not necessarily opposed to having multiple suspects at a time."
134 - more awkward backpedaling
167 - And even more - "You know what, I think you're right. I was trying to justify my vote on MarioManiac4 and I am finding it difficult to explain why I found him suspicious." Wow, I'm surprised this didn't get more attention.