Mini 1695--Diamond is Unbreakable Mafia(To Be Continued..?)

[Rubicon]

i dont remember ever playing with you rubicon?

We've played once or twice. I spent some time analyzing your meta during Titus' WIFOM City game last year, when you were Priest. You tend to either call your partners scummy (with or without voting them) or null or avoid them. So I figured your defense of Salamence was something you believed and were wrong about, instead of an attempt to save a partner.

Here, he's avoiding hiplop simply because of him explaining his role. He didn't ask because of being suspicious of Hiplop (at all), he only asked to know what he did at night.

I'm not suspicious of hiplop at all.

Ask elusive if me not wanting a hammer until I talk to people is a scumtell. My post to Sala was a test.

[Super Massif Bros]

You were also holding your vote from Sala before that, for some reason. Can you explain why? You haven't had that problem any other time before.

[Rubicon]

Same reason. I was treating it as almost-LyLo given how many kills there were on N1 and the possibility of him & pisskop being lovers.

I'm not entirely sure how you think you're alive if you think me & hiplop are both mafia.

[Super Massif Bros]

I have a theory. A GAME THEORY. No really, either scum no killed to salvage the team, or the scum don't have any kills left since there only source of kills died, or I was protected. Anyway I wouldn't trust anything stand related now. I actually expected to die though.

Just a theory though. A GAME THEORY.

[Super Massif Bros]

Yet, me being alive doesn't invalidate your and Hiplop's actions. I still can't believe you are pushing for REM of all people.
Thoughts on Constastine?

[hiplop]

how do you possibly read rem as town

[Super Massif Bros]

Burden of Proof. If you think he's scum, it's on you to bring the evidence.

[Rubicon]

Fair enough SMB, but you're not exactly applying Occam's razor on that one.

Why do you think REM is town? He & farside are basically the only candidates for scum hard-bussing a partner who was caught trying to kill the IC.

PoE town. Absolutely town if there's scum in my pool and piss is town.

Why?

[Rubicon]

(Cask could also be a bus vote, but he was much less enthusiastic about it. Not sure how I read that.)

[Super Massif Bros]

Look at my post above. If you think he's scum, bring the evidence. If you think he bussed, show the quotes/evidence. Simple as that.

[Rubicon]

I want to call Constantine too scummy to be scum, but I think he may just be scum. I'm not sure he'd be this bad as town.

Okay, I'll pull up the quotes that look like bussing.

[Super Massif Bros]

I actually want to see what Hiplop has to say before you do. Since he said that first. How about in order, ya?

[CaskOfAmontillado]

Cask the latter part for Hiplop, ipso facto on you.

hiplop- scum because he's been scummy all game, i tracked him to the IC last night, and his explanation is insane. The only way he's town is if he's catastrophically bad at his role, same as sal yesterday.

constantine- scum for pushing the flavor angle and trying to take the townlead after attempting to save sal.

piss- botched his role badly, but im willing to believe he's town for now. there's a maybe-paranoia theory where sal mind controlled farside for the bomb and piss neighbored him for the extra vote in an attempt to force the scumwin today.

farside- no problem with her play, but the only source of the unexplained bomb so far. I'd like her to explain how her bombs work.

rem- town by PoE. I've seen little things from him that i like as well.

rubicon- i like rubicon for town, actually. the hard defense of hiplop is super weird, and i'm gonna look at SMB's associatives when they're applicable, but i liked his claim.

elusive- town for sharing all of my suspicions. hard push on sal does not look like a bus.

[pisskop]

piss- botched his role badly,

??

[Rubicon]

I actually want to see what Hiplop has to say before you do. Since he said that first. How about in order, ya?

I decided not to quote anything, anyway.

[CaskOfAmontillado]

targeting titus was a terrible idea. made me think you might be scum for a bit.

[Super Massif Bros]

Alright Rubi. Also, Hiplop was lurking quite a bit D1. Just for context. I still want to hear why he suspects REM.

[pisskop]

No, strongarming titus was a terrible idea.

I didnt neighborize her for the xtra vote.

[Rubicon]

Also, Hiplop was lurking quite a bit D1. Just for context.

What does that tell you?

[St Constantine the Hermit]

You got to be kidding me if you don't find Cask and Farside to be incredibly scummy.

If I were scum, I would of personally made sure Rubicon died last night, just so you know.

[pisskop]

w.e. I suppose people without my experience around her would have done it to be sure.

[CaskOfAmontillado]

shooting her was also bad

[St Constantine the Hermit]

BTW Rubicon, it was actually good that you used your doc last night, or SMB would of died. I alluded to the fact that you were the doctor yesterday though.

[CaskOfAmontillado]

You got to be kidding me if you don't find Cask and Farside to be incredibly scummy.

If I were scum, I would of personally made sure Rubicon died last night, just so you know.

how about you say WHY instead of just fucking around being an idiot?

[Rubicon]

BTW Rubicon, it was actually good that you used your doc last night, or SMB would of died. I alluded to the fact that you were the doctor yesterday though.

Yeah, but you probably bought my lie about flavor not matching my role.

Why would SMB have died?