Mini 1695--Diamond is Unbreakable Mafia(To Be Continued..?)

[elusive]

@NATIRASHA ^ ^ ^ ^ ^

OH GOD is Constantine an alt of RIP?

[RapidEyeMovement]

Rubicon, can you tell me who you targeted with your redirecting powers?

[Rubicon]

I like how bold and original your reads are. A+

[Rubicon]

elusive, I wouldn't have poked the sleeping dragon by calling you scum unless I actually was worried that you were.

[RapidEyeMovement]

I've said my reads before most people. I'm just reiterating.

Actually, with the only killing roles so far being mafia and a strongarm, (and day bomb), as scum what could you doctor? The strongarm? Oh crap nope. The day bomb? Oh crap not a night protection. Your team? Well maybe if someone took control of scum and used their ability, oh wait, that person was scum too.

I believe hiplop. I don't believe Rubicon.

[hiplop]

my intestines are starting to hurt


ahhhhh

*violently explodes*

[Rubicon]

I've said my reads before most people. I'm just reiterating.

Actually, with the only killing roles so far being mafia and a strongarm, (and day bomb), as scum what could you doctor? The strongarm? Oh crap nope. The day bomb? Oh crap not a night protection. Your team? Well maybe if someone took control of scum and used their ability, oh wait, that person was scum too.

I could stop the scum kill, Sala's vig, and far's bomb at least. How useful an ability it would be to mafia depends on which side gets those roles.

[Rubicon]

You should probably read the flavor for my Stand before arguing that there's no doctor.

And if you're town, maybe be a bigger part of the conversation? You're the only player in the game with fewer posts than the moderator. St Constantine has been in the game for a week and has 50 more posts than you.

[Super Massif Bros]

Rubicon, why did you protect me n2 and not n1? Who did you target n1?

[Super Massif Bros]

Forget the second question. Why did you use your action n2?

[Rubicon]

I didn't think scum would see you as a big enough threat to shoot on N1. People were throwing a lot of shit at you at that point and not taking you seriously. Once you drove the lynch on Sala and were confirmed to lose your BP, I figured they would want you gone.

[RapidEyeMovement]

Ehh. I still almost see a doctor as a useless role in this game if one shot. I'm also talking about this game. Sala wouldn't hit scum with his N2 so that'd be useless. The bomb avoidance which if Farside never claimed, scum would never know, and it's still a long shot that as scum doctor would work in that bomb scenario.

I don't see a scum doctor having any meaning in this game. All stands seem to have the ability that can be beneficial to either side by itself.

[Rubicon]

Okay but Natirasha wouldn't have known who was going to get which killing power when designing my role. It's potentially useful to either side, depending on who gets them.

But if you're talking about this game, the doctor is town and there are a handful of one-shot protective abilities spread throughout the town (me, hiplop, SMB, elusive...) which have so far countered two scum kills.

[Rubicon]

What do you think of Cask's cop stand, REM?

[pisskop]

Question: how likely is it that scum would claim cop?

[pisskop]

We have seen all the stands are by default 1-shot; but I dont think we've seen stands that 'could be used as town or scum'. I think thats crap logic, and I think its bad you're pushing that.

[pisskop]

So I think that, given the obcession with Sala and the Lovers setup, Cask should be looked at sternly. He conveniently 'missed' my previous comments on it and his grill looked pretty shit.

[pisskop]

Essentially I think scum planned it prior, and Cask 'addressing' it ala 1577 and his grill of me around there is something I've given moderate thought to.

[Rubicon]

We have seen all the stands are by default 1-shot; but I dont think we've seen stands that 'could be used as town or scum'. I think thats crap logic, and I think its bad you're pushing that.

Well...we have. Pretty much all of them so far.

[Rubicon]

I agree that Cask is scummy for reasons that have nothing to do with his Stand, though.

Did we ever figure out how Salamence shot SMB? His voodoo claim was really creative if he made it up.

[pisskop]

Well, I mentioned voodoo frist, before that I think he called it a bomb. Because hes a chronic liar.

[pisskop]

not true. Elusive did.

[elusive]

OMG NATIRASHA< THE SUSPENSE IS KILLING ME

[Super Massif Bros]

Still think Constastine/Rubicon. I'll drop the 3p Elusive stance, others gave good points on that.

I also agree with cask, if we have 1-2 scum already, massclaim away. Don't just rely on roles though, also look at dayplay guys.

Also the case against Cask is shit. Try harder.

[pisskop]

No reason to. Im psure Constantine isnt scum. If he is he really needs to get some more conmposure.