NY 188: Delicious Mafia II (Post-game chatter)

[Aeronaut]

Defraction mafia.

OMG YUS

[SilverWolf]

Welcome Fro99er!!

[SilverWolf]

Because I do not know if she is Scum, and I'd rather search through her scum games because there may be slight hints in there that could be used here, to better discern if she's scum or not.

This looks like selective meta hunting.

I would think to get a complete picture, you would want to see town games as well.

[Skybird]

Welcome Frogger! You'd better be town here!

[SilverWolf]

Things I don't understand:
1. A whole lot of people expressed suspicion of Wolfie.

Wolfie

, why did you decide that TSO was the scum out of the bunch?

It was mostly his behavior around the pressure on me and my replace request. It felt like a scum push to me on an easy target that already had a lot of pressure and a way to set up a scumread before the replacement could even get into the game. He was also selective in what he picked out to scumread me for-this point has been nullified after he explained it better. Some of it is gut, paranoia, and meta as well. I've explained it in more detail in some of my posts after I came back to the game.

[Wake1]

Because I do not know if she is Scum, and I'd rather search through her scum games because there may be slight hints in there that could be used here, to better discern if she's scum or not.

This looks like selective meta hunting.

I would think to get a complete picture, you would want to see town games as well.

And I could ask for all PTs, too, but time for me is very limited.

[Spiffeh]

@Wake @Creede
This was what my post 537 was about:

Although TSO is looking kinda suspicious, I really don't think he should be lynched over other people (like nos). For now I'll unvote, but I'm not too sure about voting for TSO.

UNVOTE: nosferatu

It was a half joke but it still reads as bad to me. Like how does your hesitation in voting for TSO translate to you unvoting Nosferatu? You even state that you think Nos is a better lynch. It doesn't feel right that you'd unvote Nos immediately after making that post.

[Spiffeh]

VOTE: Annadog40

Jeez how many scum are in this game how is no one voting her right now?

Just ISO her. She has zero actual contribution and her posts consist almost entirely of asking questions that don't matter and covering her ass on the "Wolfie" fiasco. Clearly she's reading because she has responded to allegations against HER but can't be bothered to post anything of substance about the game.

She was on the Nos wagon which makes me think he's town now but we'll see how he plays going forward.

[Spiffeh]

Why are people so hard on Grayfoxxxx, Nosferatu (I'm a little guilty there I guess), and Creede but are letting Anna skate by on arguably much worse posts?

[Annadog40]

She was on the Nos wagon which makes me think he's town now but we'll see how he plays going forward.

So you are reading Nos based on the fact that I am on their wagon? I'm still on the Nos wagon so the past tense is misleading.

[Annadog40]

Why are people so hard on Grayfoxxxx, Nosferatu (I'm a little guilty there I guess), and Creede but are letting Anna skate by on

arguably

much worse posts?

There you go

[Spiffeh]

So you are reading Nos based on the fact that I am on their wagon? I'm still on the Nos wagon so the past tense is misleading.

Sorry my tense is wrong? "Misleading" is a bit of a stretch. Good try though, pinpointing the smallest inaccuracy and not responding to my valid argument. I figured I'd give an update on how I felt about Nos since I was voting for him previously.

Why are people so hard on Grayfoxxxx, Nosferatu (I'm a little guilty there I guess), and Creede but are letting Anna skate by on

arguably

much worse posts?

There you go

Oh so you apparently have the opinion that their posting is worse than yours but you only highlight this in an attempt to discredit an argument against you? Why do you only share this thought when you're in the hot seat? Anyway it's no longer arguable. You're a lot scummier.

GUYS I GOT ONE LET'S LYNCH HER

[Shinobi]

VOTE: Annadog40

Jeez how many scum are in this game how is no one voting her right now?

Just ISO her. She has zero actual contribution and her posts consist almost entirely of asking questions that don't matter and covering her ass on the "Wolfie" fiasco. Clearly she's reading because she has responded to allegations against HER but can't be bothered to post anything of substance about the game.

She was on the Nos wagon which makes me think he's town now but we'll see how he plays going forward.

Already noted her.
/shrug
I'm voting gray though.

[Spiffeh]

Could someone summarize the case against Grayfox? I just feel like that would be the easiest lynch for scum to push at the moment.

[Annadog40]

[quote="In post 657, Spiffeh"

Just ISO her. She has zero actual contribution and her posts consist almost entirely of asking questions that don't matter and covering her ass on the "Wolfie" fiasco. Clearly she's reading because she has responded to allegations against HER but can't be bothered to post anything of substance about the game.
[/quote]

The real question is, is this scummy?

[SilverWolf]

I think I just figured something out.

UNVOTE:

I am going to re-ISO some people I don't have reads on and vote again tomorrow. I need to re-read a few things.

[SilverWolf]

I would vote for grayfoxxxx right now but he's not here and I don't know how much good it would do unless we are ready to lynch him. He's very inactive unfortunately.

[Spiffeh]

Annadog who are your top three scumreads and why?

Yes it's scummy lol

[Shinobi]

Could someone summarize the case against Grayfox? I just feel like that would be the easiest lynch for scum to push at the moment.

Because he's playing terribly and he isn't terrible.
iirc he's actually pretty proactive and valuable as town.

[Shinobi]

Just ISO her. She has zero actual contribution and her posts consist almost entirely of asking questions that don't matter and covering her ass on the "Wolfie" fiasco. Clearly she's reading because she has responded to allegations against HER but can't be bothered to post anything of substance about the game.

The real question is, is this scummy?

Yes.

[Shinobi]

Anna your badness at quoting has dripped over and made me bad.
How dare you.

[Aeronaut]

Always remember that I fixed that quote when you send your scummy nomination

[Wake1]

I would vote for grayfoxxxx right now but he's not here and I don't know how much good it would do unless we are ready to lynch him. He's very inactive unfortunately.

...

Hm....

...

Can't tell for sure...

Hm....

[Shinobi]

Always remember that I fixed that quote when you send your scummy nomination

<3

[texcat]

Always remember that I fixed that quote when you send your scummy nomination

<3

And yet one more thing that I don't understand.