In post 93, Wisdom wrote:Elbirn you look different than last game. You had reasonable reads there, and you sticked to them despite what others said (for example you insisted I am town). I like neither your shallow tunnel on kyndy nor the way you stopped pushing her just because I didn't agree with you.
Just ISO'D wisdom. He likes to recap what happens but gives no real reads. He did this last game I played with him, and he was scum. He is way more worried about semantics, and petty points, than actually scum hunting.
Getting a townish feel from Vedith and Firebringer for attitudes. Maybe leaning town on kyndy, but I need to check into her games to see if she has reason to know just how bad early VT claims are coming from town to decide.
Kyndy, can you elaborate on your scum-Vedith read?
Getting a nervous vibe from shaddowez for some reason. Kind of a hands off feel that's resorting a lot to theory over specificities to fill posts.
Grayfoxxxx, you ever play with town-Wisdom? Unless he's utterly changed in the last year-plus, his town playstyle overlaps quite a bit with his scum play. Possibly even more jumpy. Although his game opening was pretty much what I'd expect from town-Wisdom, heh.
P-edit: will quote post that felt weird in just a minute.
In post 129, Wisdom wrote:127: Wisdom is scum because of his playstyle
try harder
In post 119, Wisdom wrote:no. His comment on Fire had nothing to do with voting Elbirn. He was just giving his own thoughts on Fire because it was the discussion at that point. He was not comparing them, neither favoring one instead of the other.
In post 116, Wisdom wrote:As for the first line, shaddoweh essentially proves how bad his push on kyndy was. He presented kyndy's RVS as wagoning yet had nothing to say about Gray doing the same thing.
In post 114, Wisdom wrote:His comment about fire was in response to the discussion that started with this:
and is irrelevant, so I don't get why you're mentioning it?
In post 99, Wisdom wrote:You asked if I could see her 6 votes thing as scum panic. I obviously don't and I have talked about it already, so it was pointless
It's a little early for reads, but I think Shadowzz, Vedith, or Grayfoxxxx. Sheeping and not many posts are my main reasons at this point in the game. Of course, that's kind hypocritical of me to say that since that's exactly what I did.
All of these, you just restate what happens. The rest of your ISO is pretty much one liners, and votes with empty reasons. I think post 93 was kind of substantial, yu should post like that more often.
In post 82, Elbirn wrote:Also tell me why confidence is scummy plz
It's not necessarily confidence per se, but it's how it's being portrayed. The way you're doing it here reminds me of two separate games I've had where people that acted similarly were scum. I'm not saying that's evidence of you being scum, but its definitely skewing my view that way.
This is what pinged for me. Citing other people in this way sounds vague and less relevant that one might think at first glance. Combined with an RVS that felt nervous and I'd like to see what's going on here.
133 is asking you to prove your baseless accusation. Not a recap.
129 is ponting out how your accusation sucks. Not a recap.
119, 116, 114 is me trying to show Vedith how he has completely misinterpreted what Shadoweh posted. Not recaps.
99 is explaining why Vedith's question was pointless. Not a recap.
70 is pointing out that kyndy is not voting any of her scumreads. Not a recap.
21 is quite obviously not a recap, it's an accusation.
In post 137, Wisdom wrote:Gray has no idea what my scum play looks like, considering the game he's referring to was a greater idea variant (therefore multiball)
ANOTHER post where wisdom just states a fact, but this time he tried to correlate it to his defense.
"I was scum in that game, but you have no idea what I'm like as scum" Tf?
We were in a game, and you were scum. Don't know what else to add. "No idea" sounds kinda desperate.
In post 136, The Betting Pool wrote:Grayfoxxxx, you ever play with town-Wisdom? Unless he's utterly changed in the last year-plus, his town playstyle overlaps quite a bit with his scum play. Possibly even more jumpy. Although his game opening was pretty much what I'd expect from town-Wisdom, heh.
P-edit: will quote post that felt weird in just a minute.
--PA
Never played a town game with him, I'll take this into consideration.
In post 139, The Betting Pool wrote:This is what pinged for me. Citing other people in this way sounds vague and less relevant that one might think at first glance. Combined with an RVS that felt nervous and I'd like to see what's going on here.
I don't see anything wrong with that. He explained what felt off to him about Elbirn's confidence.
In post 137, Wisdom wrote:Gray has no idea what my scum play looks like, considering the game he's referring to was a greater idea variant (therefore multiball)
ANOTHER post where wisdom just states a fact, but this time he tried to correlate it to his defense.
"I was scum in that game, but you have no idea what I'm like as scum" Tf?
We were in a game, and you were scum. Don't know what else to add. "No idea" sounds kinda desperate.
you still don't know how I look like as scum, sorry
133 is asking you to prove your baseless accusation. Not a recap.
129 is ponting out how your accusation sucks. Not a recap.
119, 116, 114 is me trying to show Vedith how he has completely misinterpreted what Shadoweh posted. Not recaps.
99 is explaining why Vedith's question was pointless. Not a recap.
70 is pointing out that kyndy is not voting any of her scumreads. Not a recap.
21 is quite obviously not a recap, it's an accusation.
buh bye
Dude, its obv from past games you give words new definitions. You argued about the word "doubt" with me, even after I copied and pasted the definition. You were scum that game. And now you are doing the same thing.
In post 137, Wisdom wrote:Gray has no idea what my scum play looks like, considering the game he's referring to was a greater idea variant (therefore multiball)
ANOTHER post where wisdom just states a fact, but this time he tried to correlate it to his defense.
"I was scum in that game, but you have no idea what I'm like as scum" Tf?
We were in a game, and you were scum. Don't know what else to add. "No idea" sounds kinda desperate.
you still don't know how I look like as scum, sorry
Thanks, give me a minute to read all the reasons you are providing.
