Open 606: Near-Vanilla 40k TOWN WINS

[A Simple Plan]

Prodge. I'll get to stuff in the morning. I've been unable to focus at all today and my life has gone to shit.

[Vedith]

@The Worst - I saw your comment but didn't feel a need to respond. You didn't change my opinion on you, and you focused on the word information which was a weak response. Anything said on here is information, maybe just not there and then.

[Firebringer]

So what lynch right now would give us most info? I mean day one lynches generally don't give you much info imo.

I feel like Vedith is town this game.

[Vampirate]

So your concern is scum might use that against me? I guess?

I don't sheep lightly. I'm one of the most stubborn players on this site. I am known that way because I require a great deal of proof. People sheep all the time, sometimes with naked votes (not even declaring sheepage). You'll have to get used to that. We all can't be first on a wagon.

Sorry Titus but you are contradicting yourself here.

You sheeped yimmy's case on Hermit rather quickly. I would suspect a player of your caliber to ask more questions and dig than "Yep, players X case is very solid on player Y, Vote player Y".

[Vampirate]

Ok been readin'. Vampirate is a null for me for now, didn't like his first few posts at first (that meta seemed pointless to me), but since then he's shown the intent to expand his reads and knowledge, which is good.

I'm going to reiterate, what I was reading on ASP there was possible scum trying to fit in. His "Can we please stop this conversation before someone gets banned" read like an overreaction to me and not in line with how things were naturally progressing.

I don't understand what you mean by '(that meta seemed pointless to me)'.

[Titus]

@Vampirate, Not sheeping easily means I do look to see if the logic is sound. Sometimes, sound logic is self- evident. That's why no one is really discussing the substance of Timmy's case. It is rock solid.

Out for the day, people know where I will vote.

[Firebringer]

I have no idea where you will vote.

[Firebringer]

Ohhh Yimmy?
Not sure about them. I mean, not against that lynch.

[St Constantine the Hermit]

I'm going to reiterate, what I was reading on ASP there was possible scum trying to fit in. His "Can we please stop this conversation before someone gets banned" read like an overreaction to me and not in line with how things were naturally progressing.

I've said this half a dozen times, but there wasn't a case on me to begin with post #259. Yimmy asked me why I would be willing to policy lynch Ika and that was it

[St Constantine the Hermit]

Sorry, wrong quote

You sheeped yimmy's case on Hermit rather quickly. I would suspect a player of your caliber to ask more questions and dig than "Yep, players X case is very solid on player Y, Vote player Y".

[Vedith]

I think that you should all follow my vote. It will not disappoint you.

[Yimmy]

Just because I made it a question doesn't mean I didn't think it was scummy.

[St Constantine the Hermit]

Even so, Titus's praise for your case seems misplaced when it consisted of one inference in the form of a question.

[Yimmy]

And then 2 other things also

[4nxi3ty]

me, JellyRolls, Hermit, TheWorst, vampirate, vedith have all expressed suspiscion of ASP in some way

(granted vedith sorta changed his mind due to "Why would scum not vote someone else in the lead" logic [sidenote-why: because ASP was already locked into a hermit vote due to previous posts] But vedith still states he'd vote ASP rather than no lynch.)

With so much suspiscion going ASP's way the wagon really should not have stalled if it was a mislynch (scum would've have pushed that through by now, especially since there's an easy excuse of deadline approaching to join it)

ASP wagon stalled because A)town has spread out in different directions and B)scum have been unwilling to bus.

[St Constantine the Hermit]

VOTE: ASP

Fair enough

[4nxi3ty]

oh and random voted ASP too

[Vampirate]

UNVOTE:
VOTE: St Constantine the Hermit

Case incoming.

[4nxi3ty]

so much nope
-_-

[St Constantine the Hermit]

Counterwagon...

Vampirate, now is not the time to be stupid.

[TheWorst]

I wish I knew what the votes were, I'm up for a vote for ASP at this point since it doesn't look like Enigma's getting replaced in time.
Though I am interested in seeing what he has to say.

Also it seems like the mod hasn't been here in two days, maybe he should get prodded?
Jokes aside,

@Mod

the replacement post should be bumped and vote count updated... once he gets back, that is.

@Vedith

That was one sentence of my response, not the focus point. Also, this will probably just get into semantics, but FMPOV I give out my perspective/analysis/opinion, so yes of course everything can and will become information, I don't necessarily consider it just straight up information. Information straight-up imo is something scum or an investigative role has.

@Vampirate

By meta I mean the whole thing about the ongoing games talk and the worry around it, I don't think you can gather anything from that except null tells, but that's just me I suppose.
Also your Hermit case better be good, because right now I'm not seeing it.

[Firebringer]

Waiting on that case for hermit.

For time being:
VOTE: Yimmy

This is for not being useful! Also possibly being scum.

[St Constantine the Hermit]

Jus' stahp!

[duppin]

me, JellyRolls, Hermit, TheWorst, vampirate, vedith have all expressed suspiscion of ASP in some way

Do you think all of them are town?

[4nxi3ty]

more or less
I might be wrong about 1 of my reads, but I highly doubt it atm

most of those players spread out and switched to others which would be extremely weird for scum to do since they already had a hypothetical easy mislynch to stick with