Mini Normal 1711: Flavor not required. D2 deadline: 9/29/15

[Scorpious]

UNVOTE: Catboi

[Kyubey The Kid]

While I'm not saying Catboi is 100% scum, the fact that he's been the one getting people reactive isn't very pro-town. Spreading confusion and distrust is something that would only be advantageous for scum. Of course, maybe thats just how he plays and we really shouldn't be looking too deep into it, but it certainly looks shady.

[Scorpious]

While I'm not saying Catboi is 100% scum, the fact that he's been the one getting people reactive isn't very pro-town. Spreading confusion and distrust is something that would only be advantageous for scum. Of course, maybe thats just how he plays and we really shouldn't be looking too deep into it, but it certainly looks shady.

Are you an alt?

[Kyubey The Kid]

Im new to this site so.. probably not?

[Scorpious]

Im new to this site so.. probably not?

ok,I assume you have other mafia experience then, correct? yes or no is fine..

[Kyubey The Kid]

Im new to this site so.. probably not?

ok,I assume you have other mafia experience then, correct? yes or no is fine..

Oh yeah I've played tons of times IRL

[Scorpious]

Im new to this site so.. probably not?

ok,I assume you have other mafia experience then, correct? yes or no is fine..

Oh yeah I've played tons of times IRL

I can't believe this started as a parlour game,many faces have probably been smashed as a result..

cool,thanks..

[Shinobi]

Not really doing anything on page 2 is a scumtell?

Great argument, that.

Please try to explain how this applies to me, and not every single player in the game.

As for not explaining my vote,

when do scum actually vote someone without explanation?

Again, what's the actual scumtell here?

Lol. You've named off some things, but none of that poses an actual connection to, you know, scum motivation.

You're ducking these. Hard.

And talking about scum motivation is everything given you can't seem to come up with a decent explanation for

why anything I've done makes me scum

despite seemingly having a strong conviction. I'm looking for a clue as to whether you actually believe anything you're saying.

Where's the scum motivation in being useless?
Seriously?

Stop harping on semantics and tell me who is mafia.

[Shinobi]

If you really want an explanation as to why I picked you over everyone else, it's because you were around and posting but not moving the game forward.
It's really simple.

ANYHOEZELS:

also,

I honestly think Cat is just trying to get a reaction from you.Seems like you,wants to get shit goin,but he' going about it in a different way. Way too early to form anything of substance. I'm personally not a fan of that style,but whatever.

I have nothing on Radiant. Nothing there yet. I guess I.myself am somewhat curious what "Scum line" is..

While I wish you wouldn't step on my toes, you're obvtown, so that's nice.

VOTE: cowbells
until he explains his reads

This is town. Silly, but town.

Why, to either of these reads?

[Shinobi]

UNVOTE: Catboi

What warranted this, exactly?
Where else would you vote at this point in time?

[Shinobi]

While I'm not saying Catboi is 100% scum, the fact that he's been the one getting people reactive isn't very pro-town.

Spreading confusion and distrust

is something that would only be advantageous for scum. Of course, maybe thats just how he plays and we really shouldn't be looking too deep into it, but it certainly looks shady.

How exactly is he doing the bolded?
What's wrong with getting people "reactive?"

[Scorpious]

UNVOTE: Catboi

What warranted this, exactly?
Where else would you vote at this point in time?

it was a joke vote, I think its safe to say RVS is over..

I'm still waiting for more content to decide where to go.. More than enough time

[Shinobi]

UNVOTE: Catboi

What warranted this, exactly?
Where else would you vote at this point in time?

it was a joke vote, I think its safe to say RVS is over..

I'm still waiting for more content to decide where to go.. More than enough time

Help me work things out, then?
Stuff happened in the last few pages, surely something caught your eye.

[Scorpious]

Honestly, I don't share that sentiment. There has been a little banter,but I'm not desperate to make anything out of nothing..

What interests you specifically? Bounce it off me. I'll give you my opinion

[Shinobi]

Honestly, I don't share that sentiment. There has been a little banter,but I'm not desperate to make anything out of nothing..

What interests you specifically? Bounce it off me. I'll give you my opinion

I don't really see it as "making something out of nothing."
You have

nothing

you want to talk about specifically?

[Kyubey The Kid]

Honestly, I don't share that sentiment. There has been a little banter,but I'm not desperate to make anything out of nothing..

What interests you specifically? Bounce it off me. I'll give you my opinion

I don't really see it as "making something out of nothing."
You have

nothing

you want to talk about specifically?

Well, all we've had recently is just people feeling themselves out. There's literally no basis for any accusations at this point in the game since we haven't got any hard evidence that we can interpret. If the best argument we can make uses "gut feeling" as its base, then we really should refrain from getting too serious this early in the game.

[Spiffeh]

Kyubey what do you propose we do to progress the game then?

[Scorpious]

What are your thoughts on the game state Spliff?

[JeanDarc]

@Kyubey, @Shinobi, and @Scorpious

The votes during RVS are never truly "random." If some people rolled a die/RNG'd for their vote, you may call it that but we will never know (and rolling a die within a forum post is not allowed, AFAIK). Whether it's pro-town or not, a vote is still a vote and the early votes in first pages of the game should never be brushed off as "well, those were just RVS votes."

On that note,
UNVOTE:

Looks like people are growing apathetic over this dull transition so let's see if we can somehow engage them back into discussions. Perhaps someone could ask a question.

[JeanDarc]

@everyone
Random/Optional question to answer:
What is your overall experience with Mafia games (in/out of this site)? What is your favourite thing about Mafia (and why)?

[Kyubey The Kid]

@Kyubey, @Shinobi, and @Scorpious

The votes during RVS are never truly "random." If some people rolled a die/RNG'd for their vote, you may call it that but we will never know (and rolling a die within a forum post is not allowed, AFAIK). Whether it's pro-town or not, a vote is still a vote and the early votes in first pages of the game should never be brushed off as "well, those were just RVS votes."

On that note,
UNVOTE:

Looks like people are growing apathetic over this dull transition so let's see if we can somehow engage them back into discussions. Perhaps someone could ask a question.

I totally agree with everything you said; I just wanted to voice my concern that people were starting to fight amongst themselves instead if trying to get to know everyone and what type of personality they have. If people get worked up from the beginning, near the end of the game they'll probably be too clouded by their preconceptions to be able to make an unbiased decision. This only hurts town since the scum don't really care about anyone's identity and have the psychological leverage through their unity. The only way to even the playing field is to have everyone on the same page as soon as possible.

That being said, I just want to point out that Catboi suddenly stop talking as soon as the attention was off him.

Imma change my vote to him.

VOTE: Catboi

[LexTrew]

Shinobi strikes me as town. His frustation seems genuine and I can certainly understand it.

Cow, can you expand on why are you scumleaning on Shinobi? I think I have an idea but I would like to hear it from you.

I have no reason to scumread catboi right now tbh.

vijay anything to comment?

[RadiantCowbells]

This lobby though.

[catboi]

That being said, I just want to point out that Catboi suddenly stop talking as soon as the attention was off him.

Insanely enough, I'm busy during the day and hadn't gotten a chance to post tonight until now. You ought to familiarize yourself with the pace here, it's not going to move as quick as you expect.



Got sick unexpectedly, going to try to do a more comprehensive post but if I get too tired it'll have to wait until the morning

[Ranmaru]

Votecount 1.4

Shinobi:

catboi, RadiantCowbells

Scorpious:

Lextrew

Spiffeh
JeanDarc:

vijay2vasandani

LexTrew
vijay2vasandani:
Kyubey The Kid
RadiantCowbells:
catboi:

Shinobi, Spiffeh, Kyubey The Kid

Not Voting

:
Scorpious, Jean Darc

*= Currently being replaced
**= V/la

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch
Deadline for Day 1 is Tuesday, September 8th, 11:59 PM EST.