Mini Normal 1711: Flavor not required. D2 deadline: 9/29/15

[Scorpious]

Took the time to really be critical on Cat.. Town there.. I don't think you can fake that much.

If anyone requires specifics feel free to ask,there is a lot of content there.

[Scorpious]

I'm looking into the KTK/Shinobi interactions now. I think one of our scum is in there..

I'd like to see more from Vijay though.. So far he has only mentioned me. I'd like to see his opinions on the others..

[Scorpious]

It doesnt help that english is not my native language. Fuck, wtf im doing I should stop playing mafia.

offtopic--you do quite fine man.. You type better than some native speakers..

[Spiffeh]

Hi I'm here sorry for inactivity.

I'm gonna read up later tonight and post thoughts.

[vijay2vasandani]

I'm looking into the KTK/Shinobi interactions now. I think one of our scum is in there..

I'd like to see more from Vijay though.. So far he has only mentioned me. I'd like to see his opinions on the others..

well you and catboi.

and i think i'm fine so far, those are the ones that stick out to me. i'd much rather stay focused on reads that i have instead of null ones.

[Scorpious]

I'm looking into the KTK/Shinobi interactions now. I think one of our scum is in there..

I'd like to see more from Vijay though.. So far he has only mentioned me. I'd like to see his opinions on the others..

well you and catboi.

and i think i'm fine so far, those are the ones that stick out to me. i'd much rather stay focused on reads that i have instead of null ones.

so,you're plan is to ignore the other six people because you're initially read the two of us as scum? Are you reading anyone as town?

[catboi]

Is RC staying? I'm ok with him staying.. Not the first time I've ever seen a self vote. Don't like it,but I don't think it's replaceable,plus he's an important cog in this game right now.. just my 2 cents

Took the time to really be critical on Cat.. Town there.. I don't think you can fake that much.

If anyone requires specifics feel free to ask,there is a lot of content there.

I'm looking into the KTK/Shinobi interactions now. I think one of our scum is in there..

I'd like to see more from Vijay though.. So far he has only mentioned me. I'd like to see his opinions on the others..

What's your read on RC's slot, currently?

This series of posts bothers me. Townread on me feels simplistic, and can't help but note it was timed after vijay attacked scorp for having an uncertain read of me and I defended him. Third post is just bland/generic.

[RadiantCowbells]

Until I'm officially replaced out I'm going to keep reminding you than Jeandarcarthage needs to be utterly destroyed.

Scorpious might be scum because I called him dumb town and he said "nice".

[Ranmaru]

Votecount 1.8

Shinobi:

catboi, JeanDarc

Scorpious:

Lextrew, vijay2vasandani

Spiffeh
JeanDarc:

Shinobi, RadiantCowbells*

LexTrew
vijay2vasandani
Kyubey The Kid:

Lextrew

RadiantCowbells*:

Spiffeh, Kyubey The Kid

catboi

Not Voting

:
Scorpious

Notes:

I'm choosing to let RadiantCowbells stay (if he wishes to remain), and will consider this more of a warning towards him, hoping he follows rule 2.

*= Currently being replaced
**= V/la

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch
Deadline for Day 1 is Tuesday, September 8th, 11:59 PM EST.

[JeanDarc]

You might want to explain your reads especially given that you are being replaced @RC

@Scorpius what do you find in particular scummy/alarming about Kyubey? He did post quite a lot of fluffy/filler post. He likes to add unnecessary verbiage to his post that makes his posts appear way longer than they could have been. That's the overall impression I got from him so far. I would say a null-read for now

[Kyubey The Kid]

You might want to explain your reads especially given that you are being replaced @RC

@Scorpius what do you find in particular scummy/alarming about Kyubey? He did post quite a lot of fluffy/filler post.

He likes to add unnecessary verbiage to his post that makes his posts appear way longer than they could have been.

That's the overall impression I got from him so far. I would say a null-read for now

This isn't really relevant to the discussion but I'm also not a native English speaker. I'm afraid of not being understood completely, which why I have a bad habit of overexplaining. It's something I'm always looking to correct so thanks for reminding me.

[Shinobi]

Will get to this tonight or tomorrow.

[catboi]

This isn't really relevant to the discussion but I'm also not a native English speaker. I'm afraid of not being understood completely, which why I have a bad habit of overexplaining. It's something I'm always looking to correct so thanks for reminding me.

Would never have guessed this.


Anyway, just a random thought I had today but I don't really like the fact that vijay's lone read of significance is based largely on an associative between unflipped players. People can conjure up wild theories for anything, this doesn't strike me as particularly involved scumhunting.

[Scorpious]

Town: Catboi, Scorpious, RC
Leaning town: KTK, Shinobi
Prob scum: Lextrew

Null on everyone else.

Cheers, GL with my replacement, etc.

Until I'm officially replaced out I'm going to keep reminding you than Jeandarcarthage needs to be utterly destroyed.

Scorpious might be scum because I called him dumb town and he said "nice".

not digging this inconsistency. just seems like it's just throwing whatever out there. putting my vote back down. This slot is causing a lot of contention. might be best to just get rid of it anyway. One because I think it's scum..2. to get us out of this limbo stage..


VOTE: RC

[Shinobi]

I'm here.
All I see that needs catching up on is the fact that Jean has yet to answer my questions.
I'd prefer RC elaborates on his reads list.

That's pretty much it for the time being.

[JeanDarc]

@shinobi what question(s) are they if you don't mind putting them together

[Shinobi]

#321

[Kyubey The Kid]

Town: Catboi, Scorpious, RC
Leaning town: KTK, Shinobi
Prob scum: Lextrew

Null on everyone else.

Cheers, GL with my replacement, etc.

Until I'm officially replaced out I'm going to keep reminding you than Jeandarcarthage needs to be utterly destroyed.

Scorpious might be scum because I called him dumb town and he said "nice".

not digging this inconsistency. just seems like it's just throwing whatever out there. putting my vote back down. This slot is causing a lot of contention. might be best to just get rid of it anyway. One because I think it's scum..2. to get us out of this limbo stage..


VOTE: RC

His next post cleared up he meant Jean

[Scorpious]

I wasn't concerned with his mistake regarding them. I more concerned how I went from town to "might be scum" so quickly..

[JeanDarc]

VOTE: vijay
Sounds legit.

VOTE: catboi
k I'm annoyed.

UNVOTE:
I've completely lost interest in this conversation. When you feel like being useful, let me know.

VOTE: RC
I'm happier with my vote here atm.

Pedit: This game isn't really fun so I'm not really putting my back into solving it.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Jean

sad thing is I expect no one's going to read that post given the playerlist

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Jean

good lord lynch this

I just explained this read.
How is this not genuine scumhunting and what reads as "genuine" to you?

I can dig a switch back to RC.
VOTE: RC

#94 looks like something total noob town would ask

#179 continues that. Not amazing questions,but they look like they are coming from a genuine spot.

They look like questions coming from someone new to the game. Not someone that is trying to fabricate things.

there isn't much to go on,but that's my reasoning.plus a little gut..

I don't really think that "seeming genuine" is enough.
VOTE: Jean

Above is wishy-washy voting. Also strongly OMGUS'y
Also - analyzing the players who are voting you =! scumhunting. Priority of town player should be narrowing down their reads and focusing on a strong scumread by scumhunting rather than trying to "please everyone" or convince the people who have suspicion on you. By being defensive, it only draws more attention to yourself which can act as a distraction that scums can exploit.

[JeanDarc]

I wasn't concerned with his mistake regarding them. I more concerned how I went from town to "might be scum" so quickly..

I saw your readlist and you listed Spiffeh and my slot as town. RC is being replaced so we have time until what the new player in the same slot has to say. What would you say your next-in-line fos is?

I could put RC's slot at L-1 but I think my vote is better served by staying on Shinobi until he can somehow towntell (at least in my view).

[RadiantCowbells]

I'm not going to risk getting repunished by offering a sig bet, but I'm pretty damn sure it's Jeandarc and Scorpious at this point.

[Shinobi]

VOTE: vijay
Sounds legit.

VOTE: catboi
k I'm annoyed.

UNVOTE:
I've completely lost interest in this conversation. When you feel like being useful, let me know.

VOTE: RC
I'm happier with my vote here atm.

Pedit: This game isn't really fun so I'm not really putting my back into solving it.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Jean

sad thing is I expect no one's going to read that post given the playerlist

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Jean

good lord lynch this

I just explained this read.
How is this not genuine scumhunting and what reads as "genuine" to you?

I can dig a switch back to RC.
VOTE: RC

#94 looks like something total noob town would ask

#179 continues that. Not amazing questions,but they look like they are coming from a genuine spot.

They look like questions coming from someone new to the game. Not someone that is trying to fabricate things.

there isn't much to go on,but that's my reasoning.plus a little gut..

I don't really think that "seeming genuine" is enough.
VOTE: Jean

Above is wishy-washy voting. Also strongly OMGUS'y
Also - analyzing the players who are voting you =! scumhunting. Priority of town player should be narrowing down their reads and focusing on a strong scumread by scumhunting rather than trying to "please everyone" or convince the people who have suspicion on you. By being defensive, it only draws more attention to yourself which can act as a distraction that scums can exploit.

I fail to see what is wishy washy in what you've quoted.
Also, I don't understand your bit about being defensive. Do you think that scum wouldn't vote someone?

[Spiffeh]

@Mod: Replace me

I'm very sorry but some things came up that are forcing me to minimize my commitments here and this game deserves someone who will put in an adequate amount of effort. I apologize for the inconvenience.

Final thoughts: RC is definitely town, Jean is my largest scumread. Vijay after him.

[RadiantCowbells]

Then, Spiffeh, why don't you vote him to help me gather momentum for that lynch before you head out?