WiFom City: Don't Trust Titus - GAME OVER

[St Constantine the Hermit]

10 unique players have posted, and none have claimed to be either the judge or have recieved Singers role PM. Just so its clear, if no one claims Signers role PM, she is going to be policy lynched. The only reason someone would withhold that information is if Singer is scum, and another scum player recieved the role PM.

Also, the judge seriously needs to claim if he or she is town. Yeah I get it. If you claim judge you are going to get insulted and everyone is going to be pissed at you, but believe me, we need to know who the judge is and it is in our best interests.

[St Constantine the Hermit]

Also quoth said that it may be imperative for him to claim something...

[St Constantine the Hermit]

... perhaps he is a judge and overturned honeybees lynch?

[farside22]

Who was jailkeeped by Singer last night?

I jk singer last night.
Did she claim to be a jk?
Sorry I didn't read everything last night.

[pisskop]

Im suprised Sala isnt trying to ram a grat wagon back together.

I dont see the necessity of a mafia judge, just a player who had a different read on grat. I really wish judges were only xshot to avoid saving sillyheads who got lynched, but meh.

Would not be even a little suprised of cop evuivalent visited grat last night

[St Constantine the Hermit]

Who was jailkeeped by Singer last night?

I jk singer last night.
Did she claim to be a jk?
Sorry I didn't read everything last night.

Farside, why didn't you claim sooner?

Three jailkeepers in this set up is confirmation that either you or Singer is scum. Unless of course Singer lied about her role, which I will be unable to discover since no one has claimed to have recieved the fucking role PM.

[St Constantine the Hermit]

That's 12 players with singer and me withstanding. If two more unique players post without claiming to have recieved Singers role PM, then I am going to assume that Singer is scum and one of her scumbuddies got it. Unless I was roleblocked last night.

[St Constantine the Hermit]

Also the judge needs to claim right now!

[St Constantine the Hermit]

My current theory is that the judge is town for two reasons.

A scum judge would be extremely overpowered, and also judge is one of the possible roles for town miscellaneous.

[pisskop]

stop with baseless spec

Would a scumjudge be worth 3 town jailers? what if this is really some role madness level stuff o.0

too much nonsense spec. stahp it. Lets put the judge aside for now

[Salamence20]

Who was jailkeeped by Singer last night?

I jk singer last night.
Did she claim to be a jk?
Sorry I didn't read everything last night.

Finally after two games of waiting the tides have turned.

Im going to take you down Farside. Inknow that slot is scum and its going to eat rope at my hands after I deal with confscum (Honey) and SK/Stupid (Singer) and Judge (Bulba/Plotfrog)

[Salamence20]

My current theory is that the judge is town for two reasons.

A scum judge would be extremely overpowered, and also judge is one of the possible roles for town miscellaneous.

Stop being stupid.

[Salamence20]

Im suprised Sala isnt trying to ram a grat wagon back together.

I dont see the necessity of a mafia judge, just a player who had a different read on grat. I really wish judges were only xshot to avoid saving sillyheads who got lynched, but meh.

Would not be even a little suprised of cop evuivalent visited grat last night

I AM NOW VOTE

[St Constantine the Hermit]

Maybe you guys don't understand. A scum judges isn't likely, and that is a definitive fact.

There is a combined 37% chance that of 4 possible people, at least 1 rolled a townie from either the miscellaneous slot or the town anything

There is only an 8% chance that at least one of two scum anything rolled judge.

[St Constantine the Hermit]

If you want to be stupid and say that a scum judge is confirmed, go ahead, but the math doesn't lie. There are 25 possible scum anything roles, 1 of which is judge. With 2 scum anything, that leaves an 8% chance of a scum judge.

Therefore I encourage the judge to claim, because I am not going to let the judge be lynched on extremely unlikely propabilities.

[pisskop]

trdl

[singersigner]

Who was jailkeeped by Singer last night?

THAT IS A GREAT QUESTION BECAUSE NO ONE SHOWED UP IN THE QT THIS TIME.

It's possible Farside's trumped mine. Why didn't you say anything in the QT, Farside?

[St Constantine the Hermit]

@Pisskop

I don't know what TDRL means

Anyways, we have a problem because we can't just relynch honeybee, because if the judge who is very likely town doesn't reveal himself, we are going to be stuck with another no lynch.

[singersigner]

Also ffs this game. What the fuck is even the point in putting a clusterfuck of roles in the game if none of them make sense and we have to default to finding scum the old fashioned way anyway?

Whatever, I only need to know one thing from Farside.

[St Constantine the Hermit]

My problem with this set-up is the town-anything and scum-anything slots

The set-up is very fun by itself, but it has the potential to completely lose all its balance by having a randomized anything role. Also people can just cliam whatever the hell they want, and it is hard to disprove it given how the consistent roles ensure WIFOM, and there is no denying that someone could have recieved any role on a very slight probability.

[St Constantine the Hermit]

We are also lynching you today singer if your role PM fails to present itself, unless for some reason the same person who roleblocked Quoth also roleblocked me last night, but that also probably means you are scum.

[singersigner]

If I was jailed no one would get a result.

So dumb...

[St Constantine the Hermit]

[Metal Sonic]

From what I know, the definition of Jailed means that the player is roleblocked and protected from Kills ONLY.

[St Constantine the Hermit]

Why would farside jail you when I was going to role cop?

Also farside claimed to not know you were a jailkeeper when she sent in the night action. That is kind of reckless.