I feel kind of rude disagreeing with mollie in the thread q.q but I think Anti is town. BBT is maybe scum. Absinthe is falling closer to null. ETL is probabbbly town? Rasko can stay as gut townlean for now. lalala needs to do more and is still south of null. The man pinged me as town in his reaction to my pushback. And you haven't done enough for me to get a grasp on you as of yet.
-Cheet.
I'm honestly kind of confused on BBT because he didn't bite on fighting me. I think he could have gotten away with generating a lot of fake content as scum by doing that. At the same time I don't know if it really makes sense for him to shy away from a fight as town either. :s
-Cheet.
In post 252, Wednesday_ wrote:
iirc anti and mollie called her town correct? I'm willing to call her town too.
Why?
In post 264, Wednesday_ wrote:
Technically you are correct as unvotes are processed with voting someone else. So my wording should not be unvote be switching votes. My post mentions mollie voting anti so it is not that ambiguous what unvote I am speaking of.
Mollie is clearly the superior player this game and is largely liked. If you guys are scum she should do most of the talking.
Go ahead and get less patient your play suggests I can take you on.
Walk me through that absinthe scum read. I'm also surprised to see no NB in this list, any reason for that?
In post 274, No Brainer wrote:Or mollie was on this account which wasn't logged into chat, thus making this my only spot I could contact her at the time.
Do you feel real good after stretching like that?
I do love a good stretch. I mean, was it super urgent that you needed to speak to Mollie right that second? Probably not.
In post 274, No Brainer wrote:I feel like you're just scum. I literally talked this out with you and explained what mollie and I were taking issue with and now you're just being reductive as if that conversation never happened. :/
You really did ask why I wasn't voting both my scum reads though.
Meta this. Meta that. Meta Everything. Meta is not a good scum-hunting tool. PEOPLE CAN MANIPULATE THEIR META. Stop it. Stop. It. Now.
between Post 223 and Post 228 i was flicking my eyes at the thread when i saw the post bbt talked about:
In post 146, Raskolnikov wrote:Didn't like how you voted No Brainer with the statement "This is scum". Voting him is fine to get explanation and fuel the 1v1, but you just wrote him off.
Since then, you vote TheMan for having a convoluted or unnatural sounding read which I agree with. But you don't like ETL's push even though you understand why he's doing it and even agree with one of his points, because he's pushing your townread? Why you giving Absinthe such a strong townread at this point? And no brainer disagreeing with you, you just dislike him for defending Anti/ETL. Aren't you defending Absinthe the same way?
first inspection, it looks a lot like a case.
In post 146, Raskolnikov wrote:But you don't like ETL's push even though you understand why he's doing it and even agree with one of his points, because he's pushing your townread?
that sounds familiar...
oh yeah:
In post 103, No Brainer wrote:Also you dislike ETL's push on her but you agreed with one of her points?
Heh?
Isn't it a little dissonant for you to be saying now that you think her entire push was bad when a page or two ago you were essentially appeasing her?
-Cheet
it's not a case
cases (esp. from newbtown) usually either have an explicit or REALLY REALLY obvious smoking gun. what rasko has here is a loose collection of points that lead to "so what?" conclusions or are recycled from the recent discussion. it's all this... stuff... dumped in a post just by rote that ~might~ be scummy maybe depending on your interpretation, but the interpretation just isn't provided b/c he doesn't connect the dots. there's nothing tying all the facts together, no "AHA CAUGHT YOU, YOU HYPOCRITICAL SCUMFUCK"
all the cues that i expect from newbtown giving a case are absent and it leaves this weird void of "why the fuck should i care if bbt did any of these things?" simplest explanation: he's scum and he's just regurgitating stuff hoping it LOOKS enough like a case to make people think he's scumhunting.
VOTE: rasko
The distance between insanity and genius is measured only by success.
In post 275, No Brainer wrote:You cared so much about pushing us as scum in the first few pages.
And it completely dropped off.
We start throwing pressure at you and you back off, only to come back later and just make empty noise at us.
There's also no attempt to try and make a wagon on us, and no attempt to pick at other wagons to try and build a wagon.
Why the change?
-Cheet.
I mean, I don't think I cared all that much, it was just something that caught my attention. I'm sorry that I have to leave the thread to work/sleep/shit but you know, life etc. What is the point behind your last two sentences (not the why the change sentence)?
OK, I'm caught up. I like Anti's post on Rasko and he can be town. I also like Absinthe and I think I like Wednesday, not as sure on that one yet. TheMan could maybe be town as well.
The rest are varying degrees of scummy.
Meta this. Meta that. Meta Everything. Meta is not a good scum-hunting tool. PEOPLE CAN MANIPULATE THEIR META. Stop it. Stop. It. Now.
well, i know i'm going to hear something about rasko being "too easy" or something to that effect and there's a million reasons why that's bullshit, the primary one being that an RNG doesn't give two shits if something is "easy" or not.
so... yeah that's going to be a fun conversation.
The distance between insanity and genius is measured only by success.
Actually, I just noticed I never really sent out a message that the game had started. So I won't count Wednesday's prod, because it's possible she hasn't even noticed the game had started. Apologies for the inconvenience.
In post 249, Wednesday_ wrote:Intimidated that they were catching up bad move. Had the time to vote me worse move. Has the chutzpah to put me down as null instead of lurking scum scum move.
In post 307, Antihero wrote:well, i know i'm going to hear something about rasko being "too easy" or something to that effect and there's a million reasons why that's bullshit, the primary one being that an RNG doesn't give two shits if something is "easy" or not.
so... yeah that's going to be a fun conversation.
Would your impression of that post change if you thought he wasn't a newb to mafia? I have no idea if he is or not. I wanted to look at old games but he doesn't have any completed ones.
not too terribly much, but he signed up for a newbie game here so i'm working from the assumption that he's not really someone's sooper dooper top secret alt (LK;FJ;LKSADJF;LKSAJ;LKASDJFLK;AJDS F ALTS SOMEONE PULL THE FIRE ALARM)
The distance between insanity and genius is measured only by success.
In post 314, absinthe wrote:
Would your impression of that post change if you thought he wasn't a newb to mafia? I have no idea if he is or not. I wanted to look at old games but he doesn't have any completed ones.
NB is town. Anti is town. I think lala is town. BBT might actually be town.
raskal entrance was ?? meh. don't like it. still ok with my absinthe vote i think. planning to look closer at themanwhowhatever when i have more time tomorrow morning.
with you on all those
except for one thing
i seemed to have missed this.
Anti
this too when you have time for me, but I wont wait too long you know.
at the time, nb was null to me. read's outdated and now town.
The distance between insanity and genius is measured only by success.
In post 316, Antihero wrote:not too terribly much, but he signed up for a newbie game here so i'm working from the assumption that he's not really someone's sooper dooper top secret alt (LK;FJ;LKSADJF;LKSAJ;LKASDJFLK;AJDS F ALTS SOMEONE PULL THE FIRE ALARM)
Alt is someone who plays here under another account? I was thinking about experience on another site or face to face. "Not too terribly much" answers the question, though.