In post 621, Firebringer wrote:Something Smart has a strong read on Titus, is that really weird?
Yes, it is.
In post 603, Something_Smart wrote:I was townreading her in the beginning. Now she's kind of at null-leaning-town-unclear.
In post 625, Something_Smart wrote:Read the thread before making comments like that.
In post 611, Cerberus v666 wrote:I don't have a firm grasp on Titus this game. Not even a weak graap, honestly. I've played with her enough to expect to have some sort of lean one way or the other generally, but I don't this game. Her behavior differs from all my previous games with her, I think, in that she's been quite passive after that initial declaration regarding her suspicion of SS etc, but passivity is not in line with my experiences with her as either alignment. This is the second time I've seen her with a vanilla role (I generally only play theme/role madness games) though, and the other time she was hydraing with a hyperactive poster, so it's possible this is just what she does when she can't do any further scheming or planning for her play early game. She's tunneling, which is normal for her, and that's about all I can say for certain.
Basically, this is me doing this:¯\_(ツ)_/¯ with regards to her for the time being. Titus is, imo, almost always a terrible early game lynch, so I'm opposed to lynching her in general without a good reason (which viva has failed to provide), but she's not someone I'd defend based on her play..
I can walk people through my town read of Titus and cakes Tonight for doubters.
@viva I only skimmed to this point and I thought you seemed townie from wwhat I skimmed, but your reads/logic is off. just like Titus' (and maybe mine)
But ill discuss more in a bit when I have more time.
In post 635, Cerberus v666 wrote:Viva: because I know for a fact she's both lynch bait at times AND very strong late game. Oh and I'm confident she'll be able to be read with more certainty later in the game. You're right that if she's scum we should lynch her, but I don't see anything particularly scummy in her play. The Yonom thing is rhe closest to being scummy, amd Yonom said stuff in the middle which could have very easily changed her mind on them.
Also, you're misunderstanding whoever it was you quoted in that shitty context removed quote. He said YOUR reads are off, and so are Titus', but maybe his are too.
To be perfectly clear here: I lynch people because they're being scummy, and their actions have scum motivations, NOT because they're not being "town" enough for me. Not obvtown!=scum. Especially on D1. Later on we can PoE things and use some logic, but right now? Nope. Not good enough.
whyIn post 639, SirCakez wrote:If SS does flip town somehow then I would obviously reevaluate my reads. My reads right now are based on SS being scum.
In post 641, TheCow wrote:whyIn post 639, SirCakez wrote:If SS does flip town somehow then I would obviously reevaluate my reads. My reads right now are based on SS being scum.
In post 643, Extrapolated Eagle wrote:In post 641, TheCow wrote:whyIn post 639, SirCakez wrote:If SS does flip town somehow then I would obviously reevaluate my reads. My reads right now are based on SS being scum.
The only read I would be less certain of should ss flip town is Titus, and that's to a small extent. Oh, and Razh too.
In post 642, SirCakez wrote:Because Titus, EE, AI and Rhazh/Fire all have associative with SS. Some are townreading and some are scum reading so his flip will be invaluable to sorting those reads further.
In post 646, Viva La Gloria wrote:Titus, see all the people declaring SS some variation of confirmed scum and then lining up mislynches to follow him?
See all the people soft defending you and preventing me from pushing on you while leaving you open as a later lynch?
Are you seriously saying that's not bothering you and making you reconsider at all?
In post 638, Extrapolated Eagle wrote:@viva I don't think my logic is off. Perhaps some of my reads but for now I'm certain SS is scum. My Titus town read revolves around the fact that SS is scum and since I am certain beyond reasonable doubt that SS is scum, I must also quell all doubts that Titus is scum with him.
In addition you can add to this that Titus is confbiasing hard on fb and still thinks hes scum simply because there is a relationship between him and ss even though they are pretty obviously not scum together, IMO.
She has no need to really scum hunt, either. In fact, I would argue that since we caught scum already further hunting is likely to result in distraction and pushing elsewhere and even a town lynch day 1 and confusion on day 2.
