In post 206, Frozen Angel wrote:prohawk posted a bunch of scummy posts. I made an attack on him. he started sorting out the lynches by his words. his inconsistansies about me and the fact he had no comment about my posts about his posts is the scummy thing here
I feel like ProHawk will dispute this summary. I could be tempted onto ProHawk though, I guess. I like the second part of your argument though, almost as though he was pretending you weren't there.
I like All In for town. Kaboose has done nothing for me except for the fact that he's on the same wagon as me, so I'm biased in his favor at the moment.
---
Kahlan 216 wrote:In the first one you had more of an if implied but the second post its clear you say you WANT to lynch in the small pool because FJ is in the small pool and that they are a freebie. How does that not look like you want to lynch them?
This makes sense to me. I get where Radiant's coming from, but I also get this interpretation.
I think I'm being too pacifist this game... I don't know. Usually I'm a bit more bloodthirsty. Maybe because everyone's acting so civil this game. This is a good thing!
---
Kahlan 228 wrote:For the love of pete! I DIDNT vote for RC ever.. I was simply stating what I found scummy about his actions. If I thought he was actual scum at this point I would have voted for him.
So I thought reads were what you post in your post about other players? Like what you read about them or how you see them? Am I wrong?
No, you're right, and this is townie. I'll stick my neck out for you, K. I've got a pretty solid town read on you. What's hanging the game up is that no other wagon is really naturally forming. Both the ones on Radiant and SMRP are stagnating for different reasons.
---
All In 230 wrote:Coyote, who's east side scum?
SMRP is my best guess. I named a couple of reasons earlier, but, to expand further, he's only posting when called out and his comments seem arbitrary and aimless. What I mean by this is that he doesn't seem to be looking for a scumhunting target so much as he's just throwing out random comments. See:
196,
122.
Lastly, he hasn't asked one question all game. That's a big red flag for me that has proven to be a fairly reliable indicator of alignment in the past. Town is naturally wanting to get clarification, figure out what other people are doing, ask 'what if' scenarios, etc (e.g. "What do you mean by post X?", "Who do you think is scum right now?", "What if X flips town?").