1. KainTepes is the first to start the RVS wagons of D1.
2. In
5, RC votes Boon. --
I know I replaced RC, but I'm commenting on everything I see. Now, I have a pretty good idea of why RC voted Boon then: "supposedly", Boon completely messed RC up in Mini 1755, and RC has been angry ever since.
3. Kein uses all caps in
3 and
16. -
Apparently, he doesn't understand that yelling should be reserved for extreme cases. So far, not liking this slot.
4. Kein claims to "played 1000 games on TOS" in
19. -
Keep this in mind for later. Also, what in the world does TOS stand for, last time I checked, it stood for Terms of Service.
5.
39 just kills me. Kein thinks everyone is trying to lynch him. -
For one who claims to have played a 1000 games of FM, he seems rather noobish. I mean, even if mechanics were different elsewhere, why in the world do you think everyone is trying to lynch you barely 24 hrs(?) into the day? At the least, I can make this assumption: Kein is not reading: if he read how long we have til deadline and the fact that no one has even provided any real evidence for their votes yet, he would realize that no one is trying to lynch him, yet. Also, lynching a person then giving defense, then choosing inno/guilty seems rather inefficient. Wouldn't you at least wait a bit before ending the day (presuming the day ends after that).
6. In
125, Iran thinks MM's case was too forceful. -
Don't like the vibe of this post. Seems like scum trying to get towncred off Kein. -
Null-Scum-Indicative
7. FA calls Lapsa out in
147 -
Kinda want to agree with him here. I haven't really seen much from Lapsa to this point, and posting VC, while a useful service, is not going to get you townread. -
Scum-Indicative for Lapsa
8. In
151 by Lapsa, he claims Perf is trying to buddy Soap. -
I don't see it that way. Looks more like scum keen on trying to get a Perf mislynch in. -
Scum-Indicative
9. I agree with
175 by FA -- Lapsa hasn't been aggressive at all. -
For a guy who literally scumread me the entire game until D4 in Mini 1755, I'm gonna err on the side of caution and say this is -
Null-Scum Indicative for Boon
10. Katsuki and his all caps + "THIS BOONSKIIES" crap is annoying the heck out of me. He gives a practically naked vote on Performer in
180 -
Explain to me why you suddenly vote Perf. here. -
Null-Scun-Indicative
11. Katsuki claims
144 and
146 are scum posts in
193 -
I can see 146 to some extent, but 144 looks perfectly natural to me; def. nothing scummy looking about it. I think you're part of the scumteam. -
Null-Scum Indicative
12. Soap states "their all cult" in
196 -
First of all, where did the idea of cult come from? Secondly, this game is a normal game. Cult is specifically blacklisted. As far as motive goes though, I think this was a joke type post, so
Null-Indicative
13.
226 by Garm seems well thought out. -
I disagree with the Perf. point, but you actually seem to have come up with reasonable evidence to back your vote --
Town-Indicative
14. Lapsa decides to fencesit Perf. on
227 -
Normally, wouldn't strike me as scummy. But, combined with Lapsa's behavior so far, I kinda do. Seems the motive is not confusion/weak reads, but rather, scum trying to conform and who knows Perf. is town, so is trying to distance himself from the wagon. -
Very Scum-Indicative
15. In
240 by RC, RC claims he'll keep his vote parked until one of 'em dies. -
This is normal RC behavior.
16.
It's official, Kein is an obvious Village Idiot. I am quite serious -- while not urgent right now -- he better be lynched before LyLo or we might as well say town has lost if he's town. @Kein --> Srry, but
251 just strikes me as beyond the noob level ---> It strikes me as the VI level. I think you need to read the wiki a lot more and def. play a newbie game. We all make mistakes and do stupid stuff, but this... this is just unnerving...... Don't take it personally.....
17. In
260 by Iran, Iran finds Garn scummy for making posts that feel "forced and scummy". He goes on to question Gamr's strong townread of Kein, saying it is poorly backed up & overall, attempt to get towncred by buddying. -
I completely disagree. Quite the opposite of forced, Garn's posts have seen thought out and logical this game, even if I don't always concur with them. Furthermore, your argument about Kein and buddying is rather invalid. While Kein could be very clever scum, it's way more likely he's noobtown or even VI town. He is engaged and trying to solve the game; while he can be obnoxious with his caps at times, I no longer get scum vibes from his posts. Kein is the kind of person who'll prob. last to LyLo cuz of his inexperience at mafiascum. While he seems a bit of a VI as I stated earlier, we are in no rush to "policy" lynch him yet (so we have better shots at LyLo); I could be wrong --> We may see his potential later. Anyway, back on topic, there are quite a few good reasons to think Kein istown by this point, so it seems it's you who is trying to mislead players. -
Very Scum Indicative
18. In response to
261 -
It's RC
19. Lapsa had a problem with RC's dayvigging. -
Don't you know anything about RC? This is standard RC fakeclaiming, but in an RVS form which is why it's a dayvig. See no problems here; maybe opportunistic? -
Null-Indicative
20. Mario is doing a lot of lurking, is that prt of his meta? I have a feeling it is. Anyway, in
275, Mario says he's against the Perf wagon and against all the wagons in general. He also says he'll just crit. wagons til he or someone else finds something scummy. -
This post strikes me in a way, but I'm not sure if I think town or I think scum with this post. I think I'll go with town -- he's right, most of the wagons, esp. the Perf wagon have been pretty poorly supported. -
Null-Town-Indicative
21. Not Mafia does a quote wall vote of Lemon in
277 -
Not quite sure what the issue. I can see it has to do with the Kein scumread, but could you elaborate?
;
Addendum --> You subsequently voted Lemon a total of 3 times without a vote in between --> why?
22. Lapsa naked votes Not Mafia in
292 -
Does it have to do with the Lemon voting? I really hate naked votes, though I use them occasionally.
23. Lemon presents a case against Lapsa in
295 -
I much concur with this case -- Bonus points for Lemon! -- seriously though, makes me scumread Lapsa even more.