In post 2332, clearance only wrote: In post 2302, Xkfyu wrote:I'm almost certain that Dwlee is town. Either that, or it was a phenominal fake scum claim, because a Refiller doesn't make sense to me as a scum role.
Why's that?
Assume the Refiller doesn't know anything about anyone's roles, other than there are a bunch of X-Shots in the game.
The whole point of having so many X-Shots scattered everywhere is for the Refiller to have to choose who they want to refill, based on incomplete information. A Town Refiller would have to not only figure out where the PRs are, but also which ones are town (he doesn't want to refill a scum PR), and who actually is in need of a refill.
If the Refiller is Mafia, then there is no incomplete information, and the ideal play, far more often than not, is probably just to refill one of his buddies.
It just doesn't make any sense to me as a scum role. Or it, at least, makes far more sense as a town role than a scum role.