Aneninen's ISO is nothing too spectacular, there's a little content but not terribly much. He gives a lot of posts like post
107 which contain short, blunt thoughts. Although they do lack further explanation and such, they seem genuine and some of them I've had myself and that earns town-points as you would hope town are drawing similar conclusions. His readslist in
138 is okay and the reasons and decent at most. His later play is a little more worrying, although being on the BW wagon fairly early he never really pushed it or explained why. That could be seen as scum-coasting and letting someone else (me) do the dirty-work and get all the blame if BW flips. The fact he flipped his read from null-town to null-scum on me is also noteworthy, especially as it changed just as people were starting to doubt my alignment. Could be seen as carefully setting up his options. His other reads in post
264 are once again decent, though I would really like him to explain them all in more detail. His interest in setup-speculation is also something I've also noticed, and should be noted for later. I'm not quiet sure where to lean with this slot, if he doesn't start pushing people and providing explanations for his actions soon I may consider pushing him.
Shotty also isn't anything exciting. He has a lot of posts where he comments on various things but never really follows up or acts on them. He's discussed me and what seemed like me coaching as well as some other stuff however he lacks visable reads as well as any scum-hunting. I don't know where he currently stands on matters involving the current gamestate, and as such it's hard to form a read on him. Just like with Anen this kind of coasting could be scum-motivated, however I'm not convinced. His loose cannonball at Aneninen out of the blue seems more like something town would do however, albeit it's a weak indicator. Really I'd like to get some reads from this slot along with some explanations, if he doesn't improve I'll start pushing him too.
Even though I keep telling myself it could be easily done as scum the fact Clumsy is a newer player really makes me like post
11 for some reason. It just feels like a town post despite me rationally not being able to justify it being so. He seems to be showing a natural line-of-thought and seem to be able to follow his thoughts' development. His early post
131 already show signs of him trying to figure out the game which is a good indicator. I originally didn't like post
148 because of the way he went "you're scum reading me for x, so why not this guy?" which I see coming from scum a lot more than from town. A further look when not skimming on a mobile device however showed that it wasn't as bad as I thought it was, there's reasonable analysis there and the reads are decent. He was never on BW either, really the only scum-thing I could possibly pin on him right now is his lack of explanation for voting me. That could be seen as opportunism however I'll await an explanation before deciding if that's so. For now he can be town.
His first post
9 looks a bit odd and awkward however isn't too alignment indicative as people are claiming. What's more condemning is his personal-bubble he only reacts to; all his posts until
300 are reactions to things concerning him. He lacks any reads outside of this bubble and isn't discussing things either. The way he coasted on his BW read looks really shady as it was an RVS vote, which he never later justifies with further explanation. He also has a scum-read on Texcat which he explains in post
120, the reasoning there is weak and honestly just wrong. I want reads from him on other players as well as further explanation as to why he scum-read BW and is scum-reading Texcat.
Not sure how to read this slot as I've played with KT before and she was just as erratic and illogical as now. I however don't like the way she both voted rising wagons on BW and Texcat without any explanation (worth acknowledging). It could be seen as opportunism however with KT being the way she is I hesitate to finalise that judgement.
Despite all the hassle texcat placing Alex at L-3 and unvoting remains non-alignment indicative and it will remain so all game, possibly with the exception of some scum-flips. His post
73 is a little concerning as it's more in scum's interests to organise what the town does during the night, however it seems like she was thinking whether we should discuss it at all when you read the end of post
88. If anything that would be a town-motivated point-of-view. Some people think her reaction to Kuroi in post
88 is scummy, I disagree. They raise the point "what has Alex to do with this" for starters, he was the one getting wagoned and it was notable that kuroi was freaking out about the wagon more than the guy getting wagoned was. I also fail to see any passive aggressiveness
as I'm a robot
so if someone could point that out that would be swell. Her post
106 is a little strange and I would like her to elaborate her first line of reasoning as I don't understand it. As goes for the vote on persivul, why did she vote him? Her vote on BW is also rather concerning as she gave literally no reason for voting him. Post
307 however contains valid reasoning against Persivul, so her posts aren't completely void of scum-hunting. Really I want a full set of reads from her soon, I also feel like we shouldn't lynch her today as the amount of people that joined her wagon without explanation and the speed it arose don't sit well with me. Preferably I'd keep her around a bit longer as I get the feeling that she's the type of player who won't be able to hide their alignment for long. Leaning scum here for lack of pushes and explanation on reads, and what seems to be opportunism. I know however that she tend to look scummy as town a lot and gets lynched a lot for it, hence my hesitance to lynch her today.
Masquerade is an odd one, his first posts consist of small thought with a comment here and there yet they lack much depth. Though I've found an inconsistency: in post
82 he town reads Blacle yet in post
211 he states he "no longer scum reads him" (albeit for faulty reasons but hey). The issue here however is that it would be a lot more in scum's favour and interest to spur on the BW wagon, I don't see a newer player sapping a wagon for town-credit either thus it's all rather confusing. If mas could explain what was going on here that would be great. The jump on texcat is a little slimy and I want him to explain his main reasons for doing so. If he's town he should be explaining this stuff anyway an if he's scum some pressure will do him good.
I think Kuroi's early tunnel on Texcat came from town. Really scum had no reason to focus so much on someone so early and draw a lot of attention. The way he heavily defends his stance and interacts with others on the matter also sits well with me, it means he isn't just spewing crumpets and is putting thought into the game. His reads have been genuine and his thought process has been natural, I can see where he's heading and why he thinks what he states. I could elaborate further but I think it's pretty clear kuroi is town.
I'll be blunt, I think Persivul is scum. He hasn't done any scum-hunting nor does he interact with people. He's coasting big time, the intent to hammer and his recent jump onto texcat look awful as he explains neither. Once. Nada. "Bad vibes and I like the wagon" is not a good reason to be lynching someone, I don't understand how a logical player like him can accept someone's lynch without providing his two-cents. I know persivul's town and scum game, as town he's a lot more pro-active. As scum he coasts and makes the best of what he gets. Guess which we're seeing this game?
Town unless counter-claimed.
Maxous seems to have been trying to figure out the game from the get-go. Posts like his post
99 show he's thinking about stuff and trying to figure things out. I may disagree with him but that doesn't mean he's scum. I also really like his post
160, it's an example of a post you'll see a lot more from town than scum. The "are you a moron" mentality is more likely to come from town, as scum would prefer to just push the player instead. I'm getting bored writing these up and I'm hungry so I'll leave it as this.
I think this guy is town, I can explain why if you demand however I want to get something to eat but I need this post finished so I'm not writing an essay for SC. Sorry man, you're just not worthy
