I'm really curious as to why Nos was NK'd. Did they crumb? Otherwise kinda nonstrategic. I'm not gonna bother with wifom with this (i.e nos voted lowell).
@Huntress, care to share your re-reads of other people?
In post 1145, Titus wrote:I am thinking Max is scum here based on wagon jumping. The clumsy wagon remained static while people jumped off Max. If Clumsy is scum, there are hard core bussers there.
@Titus, your early day 2 vote, was this still what warranted it?
There's rarely something to glean from a NK on night 1, especially with such a long d1. I'd suggest we stop wasting brainspace on it but hey you do you
Phone posting. Low effort, big fun.
"In my heart, Johnny will always be scum" - Not_Mafia
In post 1303, Roshar wrote:I'm really curious as to why Nos was NK'd. Did they crumb? Otherwise kinda nonstrategic. I'm not gonna bother with wifom with this (i.e nos voted lowell).
I'm not entirely following this. You say you're curious, but you're not going to worry about the nos voting lowell part. Is there some other insight you think is worth gleaming from her death?
I'm not gonna worry about the Nos voting lowell part because I think it's really stupid to think Lowell NK'd Nos b/c of their vote. Then there's wifom. That gives us nothing. So, not gonna bother.
In post 1286, Maxous wrote:
I would still say huntress is scummy, she seemed pretty content to let the mislynch go through without getting her hands dirty so to speak.
In post 1286, Maxous wrote:I would still say huntress is scummy, she seemed pretty content to let the mislynch go through without getting her hands dirty so to speak.
Strikes me as one of those 'damned if you do damned if you don't' situations, because I can just as easily imagine you saying something like 'she used deadline as an excuse to vote for that mislynch' had she voted
I get this but it's a bit hypothetical to influence anything.
In post 1303, Roshar wrote:I'm really curious as to why Nos was NK'd. Did they crumb? Otherwise kinda nonstrategic. I'm not gonna bother with wifom with this (i.e nos voted lowell).
@Huntress, care to share your re-reads of other people?
In post 1145, Titus wrote:I am thinking Max is scum here based on wagon jumping. The clumsy wagon remained static while people jumped off Max. If Clumsy is scum, there are hard core bussers there.
@Titus, your early day 2 vote, was this still what warranted it?
Yes, like I told Johnny, I need to speak wit Maxous to sort him further. It's a good starting point.
I'm sorry about my absence in this game. I'm going to try to get back to this thread more often. Regarding the reasons for voting Max that Froot pointed me towards (1276), the only one that strikes me as possibly scummy is #1.
My lynchpool right now is {mhsmith, huntress, shaddow, Lowell}, and I'm feeling like voting that last one atm.
she was pretty slow to give a stance on the competing wagons.
but yeah, fine it's not the strongest point in the world.
Last edited by Ircher on Tue Apr 26, 2016 2:24 pm, edited 1 time in total.
"
And before anyone bitches about me highlighting PoD's 437 when I replaced in and called everyone on my wagon communists, I remind you that communism is not alignment-indicative
Just back in the office--have about 10 minutes today, will get to the bulk tomorrow.
@1287 - I don't have the read list offhand. I haven't really been paying attention D2 so I couldn't do it justice with new players anyway. As for jumping on seemingly all the wagons? well, yeah, I like wagons. Particularly D1. I'm not of the opinion that voting early and often is a bad play, and there are a lot of people I'd be willing to lynch.
Also, all votes on my are opportunistic as hell. There's the scum trying to score an easy mislynch type, and there's the townie "well, I don't know wtf is happening but at least if I vote Lowell I'll be able to hem and haw afterwards about how unhelpful he was and I won't take the blame." Make sure if you're voting me you're the first type-- I'll take care of them.
In post 1319, Lowell wrote:Also, all votes on my are opportunistic as hell. There's the scum trying to score an easy mislynch type, and there's the townie "well, I don't know wtf is happening but at least if I vote Lowell I'll be able to hem and haw afterwards about how unhelpful he was and I won't take the blame." Make sure if you're voting me you're the first type-- I'll take care of them.
Well, one way to make sure people can't hem and haw about how unhelpful you are is to be helpful.
I'll point out in case anyone missed it that D2 is going to be shorter than D1. We have just under 6 days left.
@Johnny: When you complained about Froot, Titus, Fack, and Max in 1292, was any of what you pointed out alignment indicative, or were you just annoyed by them?
@Fack: Is the Johnny vote because of the "threatening"? And is it really worse in your eyes than what you saw Titus doing?
@Mhsmith: Regarding players still in the game, the only read of yours that I recall is a little bit of suspicion towards Rosh, so is that your main scumread (or do you have other scumreads)? Also, how do you feel about Max?
In post 1321, a plain farmer wrote:@Johnny: When you complained about Froot, Titus, Fack, and Max in 1292, was any of what you pointed out alignment indicative, or were you just annoyed by them?
In order: fruit I was just annoyed by, Titus take some getting used to, but I'm fine with her for now, the fact is either being scummy or stubbornly obtuse, I'm not sure which is worse. Max's the most skinny person mentioned in that post, but the point being made there are not why I find him scummy it's just me trying to figure him out
Phone posting. Low effort, big fun.
"In my heart, Johnny will always be scum" - Not_Mafia