Mini 1798: Greatest Idea (Game Over)

[Fate]

My third card was Conspiracy Theorist, which I took as my role.

Miller is the card I choose for alignment. I claimed miller because Conspiracy theorist is technically a miller (investigates as alien) but in retrospect it probably wasn't necessary since Aliens can't kill me.

Alchemist is not an alien.

Vote: Radical Rat

[Micc]

Votecount 2.03

Radical Rat (4)

: massive, Alchemist21, Radiant Moonlight, Fate

Not Voting (6):

Radical Rat, Katsuki, iraonavp, SirCakez, Ranger, DoctorPepper

With 10 votes in play it takes 6 to lynch.

The deadline for Day 2 is in (expired on 2016-06-27 19:00:00).

[Alchemist21]

Why did you fakeclaim Miller and not Tentacled Townie?

[Fate]

oh

I forgot that role existed <__<

I guess I didn't have much imagination and already had miller as one of my 3 roles /lazy

[Alchemist21]

Spoiler: Obligatory obvious meme that's more or less relevant here

[Alchemist21]

oh

I forgot that role existed <__<

I guess I didn't have much imagination and already had miller as one of my 3 roles /lazy

Understandable .

[Fate]

I don't think anyone would ever actually choose alien as a faction unless forced to, thats why I went after you Alchemist (discarded alien is most likely for some weird triple alien role card)

I really wanted to be a cop lover

[Alchemist21]

Wait, you thought I was an Alien because I discarded an Alien card?

[Fate]

Like I said I don't think anyone would want to choose Alien as their FACTION unless forced to:

For Example:

Mafia Goon
Alien Ultrapowerrole
Mafia Silencer

Now, who would choose Alien (since their power roles are always better than their faction who can't kill) over Mafia- Ultrapowerrole?

Very unlikely.

The only situation I've seen people take Alien is
1. Well its fun to be an alien and its a silly quick f2f game
2. They got three alien cards

So since you discarded an Alien card you were the most likely to be in scenario #2

[Alchemist21]

The simpler explanation is I had no want or need for the Alien alignment or its ability. Why did you think that was less likely than getting 3 alien cards?

[Fate]

I don't see how its hard to follow my thought process here, its pretty clearly lined out.

Its not about probability, its about WHO given their discard fits my criteria for choosing Alien.

Obviously youre not alien so the simpler explanation from your POV is the one that makes sense to you.


But you have to look at it from my POV not knowing your alignment N1

[DoctorPepper]

VOTE: Radical Rat

For the record, I'm still suspicious of RM, but thats another day.
The case against them isn't inactivity. It's inactivity despite what these players are capable of. Especially in a hydra, where you have two people posting

[Alchemist21]

I kinda get it, but there is the possibility of someone getting 2 alien Cards, and throwing out whatever the 3rd card is. There could even be someone who just likes the idea of being an Alien.

In the future I don't think you should make the assumption "X threw out an Alien card therefore they are more likely than anyone else to be an Alien." Anyway, what's done is done.

[Alchemist21]

VOTE: Radical Rat

For the record, I'm still suspicious of RM, but thats another day.
The case against them isn't inactivity. It's inactivity despite what these players are capable of. Especially in a hydra, where you have two people posting

That's still basing it on their inactivity. If inactivity were a scumtell for either of them it would mean something, but it's not.

Spoiler: General Aside

Also in general you shouldn't assume a hydra will be more active than a normal slot. Check the MD threads and you'll see people talking about how some people hydra because they're already limited by time or whatever and their activity falls thinking their partner will pick up the slack, but then both heads do it and the slot as a whole becomes inactive.

[Fate]

see scenario #1

though I don't know any players who would just enjoy being aliens, as I don't know anyone besides Katsuki in this game really

[Radiant Moonlight]

Cakez is not a person of interest. Let scum kill him

Well apparantly scum couldn't even do that much. Lol

Who are the lovers? You're assuming they tried to kill him.

Ranger, Katsuki, and Cakez.

I think they targeted Ranger over Cakez because Ranger caught scum d1.

I don't think they targeted the lovers at all. No solid evidence there. Just Titus theory I am running with.

When Titus gets here I'd like her to explain why they wouldn't target them.

Titus can you answer this?

Scum in the lovers OR desperation ploy to break strong town core.

[Radiant Moonlight]

Dayvig not in lovers suggests scum in lovers.

[Fate]

The fuck is that moonlogic?

Scum can NK any of the three lovers

House had claimed Cop and since something stopped their NK last night obviously they need to take him out while they can

[Alchemist21]

Fate's right about the Dayvig, but I can see Titus' point about why scum might have targeted outside the Lovers to break the Town core.

[Radical Rat]

We actually tried to kill Ranger, before she could get away with whatever thing she has planned for the first roll cards.

My vig went to House though because there was no way we'd get a kill in on a claimed cop, and partially because I was just bitter he got a wagon going on me over something I really should have caught.

[Fate]

why do I get the feeling youre just telling hte truth with all your posts and not trying to troll or mindfuck town

[Radical Rat]

why do I get the feeling youre just telling hte truth with all your posts and not trying to troll or mindfuck town

Because this is Multiball, and my approach to scum in Multiball is to play honestly and hunt for the other scum.

Not that I've had a chance to establish that yet, but that's the plan. I want my reputation to be honorable and trustworthy, even in a game filled with deception and treachery.

[Fate]

how do you know its multiball?

[Alchemist21]

I want my reputation to be honorable and trustworthy, even in a game filled with deception and treachery.

Nobody will think less of you for lying as scum. The better you are at lying as scum the more impressed people will be.

[Radical Rat]

I want my reputation to be honorable and trustworthy, even in a game filled with deception and treachery.

Nobody will think less of you for lying as scum. The better you are at lying as scum the more impressed people will be.

Well obviously I'd lie in a game with only one scum faction. And I have done so.

But there's no need in Multiball( To answer Fate's question, I just assumed SOMEONE would have chosen Non-Mafia scum ).
Pick off the Town with kills, and focus on lynching the other scum.