Mini 1806 : DotA Mafia [Round 1 - SD] (Game Over ?!)

[Frozen Angel]

Vote Count 2.1

Radical Rat (1) : Ircher

Not Voting (7) : Shiro , Fire Assassin , Yume , Radical Rat , thenewearth , Dunnstral , Masquerade

With 8 players alive it takes 5 votes to lynch.

Day 2 ends in (expired on 2016-07-19 12:00:00)

[Radical Rat]

Off topic, but I absolutely love seeing Frozen's page-top reservations

[Shiro]

If I knew who the Survivor was, and I did, my Mafia would never had made that kill. So the only conclusion is: I'm not Mafia.

Unless you wanted us to precisely think tgat :p

[Dunnstral]

Though I got a wrong read as scum at least that's 1 down

Wha-

Did you just claim as-

Nope nothing weird here

[Ircher]

First, let me just say: Totally called it.

That aside, look through my ISO, and all my preaching about letting the Survivor live, and tell me I either killed, or allowed a kill, on them.
If that isn't enough, consider all that everyone else has said about Mafia not killing the Survivor.

If I knew who the Survivor was, and I did, my Mafia would never had made that kill. So the only conclusion is: I'm not Mafia.

No, you survivor-claimed several times.

[Radical Rat]

First, let me just say: Totally called it.

That aside, look through my ISO, and all my preaching about letting the Survivor live, and tell me I either killed, or allowed a kill, on them.
If that isn't enough, consider all that everyone else has said about Mafia not killing the Survivor.

If I knew who the Survivor was, and I did, my Mafia would never had made that kill. So the only conclusion is: I'm not Mafia.

No, you survivor-claimed several times.

Show me.
Because I absolutely did not, and I can even pull up the exact quote where I said I thought Vedith was the Survivor.

[Radical Rat]

If I knew who the Survivor was, and I did, my Mafia would never had made that kill. So the only conclusion is: I'm not Mafia.

Unless you wanted us to precisely think tgat :p

Unless the real mafia wanted you to precisely think THAT.

That kind of logic just goes in circles.

[Dunnstral]

Hey guys

Just because vedith was survivor, doesn't mean night kill analysis doesn't apply to him

[Radical Rat]

As for these votes on me, I'm seeing a lot of people saying they think I'm scum, a few saying Survivor, but not a whole lot of reasoning.
Fire Assassin is the only one I've seen giving any substance to their suspicions, but they haven't settled on a read yet.

May I ask what I've done that makes me look bad? Regardless of what my alignment may or may not be, I'd like to know so I can better my play in the future.


Vedith is currently my top pick for Survivor, based on his joking/sarcastic attitude here. I feel like he's here to have a good time( As we all should be, but I digress ), and not necessarily pushing any one side to win.

I don't think Vedith is mafia though. I've thought things through and think they're more likely to be Survivor.
Besides, I'm being voted under suspicion of being Survivor, so naturally I'd be looking for the real Survivor.

I believe there is one scum, maybe even both, in Snarky/Yume. Shiro, Maybe, but I feel like she'd be trying to push a lynch if she were scum.

And yeah, I was afraid the alignment comment would come out looking weird. Essentially, I don't believe that saying I'm Town is going to sway anyone, so I'd rather make my appeals from the point of view of my wagon to avoid just being ignored as though I were Scum.

That was not claiming survivor. I said earlier that I thought Vedith was Survivor, and that but was my explanation for not Brain Sapping him.

That's three separate posts where I explicitly state that I think Vedith is survivor.

Now show me where I said I was Survivor.

[Dunnstral]

Technically, I did hit L-1, and I said I would claim. I worry this will get me NKed, but if I get lynched that won't matter anyway.

I'm Town Bane, with current abilities Enfeeble and Brain Sap, both of which allow me to mess with the votes. Enfeeble will let me remove someone's voting ability, and Brain Sap will let me redirect votes off of me.

I don't think anyone on my wagon is lynch-worthy (

Lynching Survivor is a dick move imo

, and I feel like actual Scum is either Yume, Snarky, or both ), and while removing a vote is tempting, I'd rather the votes on me be moved somewhere useful.

So why were you talking about someone else being a survivor so much?

[Ircher]

Technically, I did hit L-1, and I said I would claim. I worry this will get me NKed, but if I get lynched that won't matter anyway.

I'm Town Bane, with current abilities Enfeeble and Brain Sap, both of which allow me to mess with the votes. Enfeeble will let me remove someone's voting ability, and Brain Sap will let me redirect votes off of me.

I don't think anyone on my wagon is lynch-worthy (

Lynching Survivor is a dick move imo

, and I feel like actual Scum is either Yume, Snarky, or both ), and while removing a vote is tempting, I'd rather the votes on me be moved somewhere useful.

So why were you talking about someone else being a survivor so much?

[Radical Rat]

That was not claiming survivor. I said earlier that I thought Vedith was Survivor, and that but was my explanation for not Brain Sapping him.

That was already asked, and here you go.

[Ircher]

New subject: Who all visited Fire last night?

[Radical Rat]

There's another problem with all of this.

If I

were

faking Survivor, why would I out myself by killing the real Survivor? It just doesn't make sense

[Radical Rat]

New subject: Who all visited Fire last night?

Which Fire?

[Ircher]

Fire Assassin......

[Dunnstral]

I did not visit Fire Assassin

[thenewearth]

Isn't this literally rolefishing right now?

[Ircher]

Isn't this literally rolefishing right now?

No.

[Dunnstral]

How often have you seen scum straight up role-fish like that?

I've seen it once only

[Ircher]

Oh, and if it wasn't obvious, I definitely visited Fire last night.

[Dunnstral]

VOTE: Fire assassin

[thenewearth]

Oh, and if it wasn't obvious, I definitely visited Fire last night.

well I can buy that

[Radical Rat]

VOTE: Fire assassin

Explain.
Just because Ircher visited him?

[Dunnstral]

No I just got a sudden premonition that fire is mafia, you should sheep me