Death Note Mafia (Game Over!)

[Mewtaph]

Is that post directed at me? I'm slightly confused

[Wisdom]

Maria, you played with town-iraona here. Was he different there?

[JasonWazza]

Because his mostly just an easy mislynch, and if everyone at least goes and does a proper meta read, they can look for things that give proper reads then this bullcrap of lynching someone for their playstyle.

So what are -YOUR- observations of his play so far then? You've played with him before, and you're telling people off that are scumreading him for his playstyle. Have you managed to gleam something that you think makes you lean more towards town than scum?

There are plenty of people in this game that have been scumread for their playstyle, where it could be quite likely that is just how they play. However both of you have decided to jump in to, very specifically, try and avoid the mislynch of him. It does pique my interest as to why that is.

I think his town, hence why i am defending him, until i get a feeling otherwise i'm happy to stop shitty call outs on him.

As for the other people being scum read on style, that is why my list was relatively small, because i actually need to delve into some games of the people here.

But i'm not about to defend style on someone i'm not town reading.

[Vecna]

Fair enough

[Mewtaph]

Jason: On that note what did you think of 425?

[Mewtaph]

iraon: I don't see how me talking about emotion makes any post less scummier but townreads are always nice

[Mewtaph]

change that to *something other than a scumread.

[Gamma Emerald]

when have i sheeped you

never. I'm talking about the players that joined me when I was voting you. Also the second "him" in that post referred to Cakes.

i dont understand the context. what do you think was beetlejuicy?

There is an activity thing there at the bottom that tells you who is on and I saw Gamma on while me and Ank had a little back and forth and I had expected him to post but he didn't. Then when he was asked a direct question he responded to it ASAP. Just gave me an odd vibe.

I was already feeling odd about him b/c I had mentioned not liking one of his posts and asked for more sheep votes on Ooba and Ank immediately attacks me. Chainsaw much?

About the beetlejuice: Didn't feel like I needed to respond to that conversation before then.

[I Am Innocent]

Lol noone is townreading me, i have like 4 votes on me iirc.

I've gotten town vibes from your posting.

[JasonWazza]

Jason: On that note what did you think of 425?

I mean honestly i don't feel there is much to be gained from the whole Iraon stuff, so i would rather direct the conversation elsewhere.

P-EDIT: IaI what part of his posting is town?

[I Am Innocent]

Got goosebumps reading the flavour so hyped

All hope leads to despair.
I DON'T CARE IF IT'S NOT RIGHT
====
Anyway:
VOTE: Nero Cain
Shotgun Kyoko
He has an animated Jesus in his avatar.

VOTE: Gamma

Leave the DR quotes to us thank you

~M

Damn I can't think of any good DR quotes to respond to this with

Also, I'm gonna do a

lot

of setup spec.
We seem to have Light Yagami as our Serial Killer or a sort of Mafia figurehead. If the first, maybe L's group is the Mafia? More to come, maybe.

I was thinking maybe scum team consisting of people in (Light, Ryuk, Misa, Rem, lawyer dude whose name i've forgotten)

MOD NOTE

Hello, everyone. For roleplay purposes, you can refer to me, the mod, as Ryuk. (I like to create immersion.)
Now if you don't mind, I'm going to listen to some music on my... Apple product.

10/10 mod

Having read up to page 9, don't like IAI. What Hark did was objectively scummy, but more likely just came from being new, and IAI should no better than to go after that

Honestly Cakez gets scumread every game by several players (including me). His early game as town and scum tend to both be fairly scummy.

Four posts, little content, one mention of a scum read, yet doesn't vote that scum read.

RM claims I'm too good to not realize hark was joking vs. scumslip/covering up (still not 100% sure it was a joke),
Yet he misses the key point. Why would great scum playing IAI need to even use that reasoning to hop on a town hark wagon, when hark was all over the place even before that. In other words scum IAI would be stupid to jump on town hark for what he would know was not a scum slip because in fact hark was town in this situation.

[I Am Innocent]

Crap forgot the vote.

Gave you over 48 hours to vote me...methinks scum RM threw out his IAI suspicion along with everyone else's so if or when a wagon starts up he could point back to that post as an oh yeah see I've been suspecting him all this time.

Hint hint RM, town players usually vote their scum reads right away...

unvote ank
Vote RM

[I Am Innocent]

Jason: On that note what did you think of 425?

I mean honestly i don't feel there is much to be gained from the whole Iraon stuff, so i would rather direct the conversation elsewhere.

P-EDIT: IaI what part of his posting is town?

For one the post you quoted when you voted him.

Unless you think mewtaph is scum partners with iraon, I don't see scum normally aware of another players vote on a town read D1 in a 21 player game. Scum usually don't pay this kind of attention.

[Wisdom]

ew the stretches are real

[Gamma Emerald]

Crap forgot the vote.

Gave you over 48 hours to vote me...methinks scum RM threw out his IAI suspicion along with everyone else's so if or when a wagon starts up he could point back to that post as an oh yeah see I've been suspecting him all this time.

Hint hint RM, town players usually vote their scum reads right away...

unvote ank
Vote RM

Not always the case with me. I have trouble keeping my vote up with my suspicions.

[I Am Innocent]

Btw im always a big proponent of wasting/using an early (D1/2) lynch to hang a lurker. They're boring for the game and theres usually at least 1-2 scum in these games going with the lurker approach. Just putting it out there early that if one of those wagons does take off Ill probably get on board of them. Not really feeling like dissolving this into a discussion of the pro's and cons of such a lynch since its a boring discussion though.

In a 21 player game where it is easy to lurk and blend in early I too am okay with an early lynch on a lurker.

9 of 21 players with 10 or less posts to this point is weak sauce

[I Am Innocent]

Crap forgot the vote.

Gave you over 48 hours to vote me...methinks scum RM threw out his IAI suspicion along with everyone else's so if or when a wagon starts up he could point back to that post as an oh yeah see I've been suspecting him all this time.

Hint hint RM, town players usually vote their scum reads right away...

unvote ank
Vote RM

Not always the case with me. I have trouble keeping my vote up with my suspicions.

Yeah but if you only had 1 suspicion to date, would you not vote it?

[I Am Innocent]

ew the stretches are real

What are u squawking about?

[Wisdom]

First you're stretching about how random should know everything about how you play as scum
Then you're stretching about how every townie has to vote their suspicion as if there aren't people who don't vote
Then being aware of votes somehow is a towntell

all of your posts this page are awful

[JasonWazza]

Yeah i have to agree, i mean, it's not like it takes much effort for anyone to check who i was voting, either by ISOing me, or just checking a VC.

[I Am Innocent]

First you're stretching about how random should know everything about how you play as scum

RM and I have played enough games together that he knows my playstyle. He even hints at it in his post below "and IAI should [k]no[w] better than to go after that"

He doesn't mention other players that "should [k]no[w] better than to go after that" hinting he knows my play better than the other players that went "after that"

Having read up to page 9, don't like IAI. What Hark did was objectively scummy, but more likely just came from being new, and IAI should no better than to go after that

Then you're stretching about how every townie has to vote their suspicion as if there aren't people who don't vote

I have come across players that have annoyed me in the past how they won't vote until they're ready to lynch....RM is not one of them from my memory. When RM has 1 suspicion, who he knows is me, and yet does not vote that suspicion, I get very suspicious. Scum RM would know how hard it is to lynch me and wouldn't want to be the one leading that effort.

Then being aware of votes somehow is a towntell

Who pays more attention ON AVERAGE, town or scum? Yeah I thought so...

all of your posts this page are awful

You are of course entitled to you're wrong opinion...

all of your posts this page are awful

...and ditto

[Wisdom]

I have come across players that have annoyed me in the past how they won't vote until they're ready to lynch....RM is not one of them from my memory.

Yet that's not the argument you made. You didn't say "town-random instantly votes", you generalized about town instantly voting, which is bullshit

[Wisdom]

Who pays more attention ON AVERAGE, town or scum? Yeah I thought so..

Alignment has nothing to do with paying attention, it depends on the player

[SirCakez]

I'm also fully aware that if Hark is town then scum were sheeping me, hell if Hark is scum, scum would prob be bussing him, but at the same time him kinda sorta sheeping me makes me want to lean town at the same time.

I also kinda dislike Gamma's post about leaving Cakes alone till day 3. What is your take on it Cakes?

In the meantime, lets get more votes on a lurking Obba whose sum total of scum hunting has been "I find all these guys scummy...on second though I changed my mind."

I read it as null, could see either side making that argument.

VOTE: Hark

Came upon this while rereading the last few pages. WTF dude. You dont post anything in the entire game and then pop in to drop an outdated unexplained vote? Scumsuspicion points through the motherfucking roof

It's Not_Mafia though.
Don't expect too much.

Hi hark thank you for dropping content.
Mewtaph is dropping crazy newbtells everywhere. Nothing scummy though.

IaI's RM vote stinks

[Wisdom]

i like when cakez repeats what im thinking