In post 5370, Firebringer wrote: In post 5367, Reasonably Rational wrote:Why would town KNOW the details of how a scum ability worked? The only scenario I can envision is one where Mastin has a private PT of some sort with someone who is scum, and who used that power on you, and that individual explained how it would work to mastin...
HOWEVER.
MASTIN SAID SHE WOULD ASK VARSOON TO EXPLAIN SOMETHING ABOUT IT TO HER.
That means that whatever power was used, is directly related to her role in some way, because otherwise she would have no expectation of being able to receive an answer.
Therefore...it was a town power.
Barking up the wrong tree(actually, I'm not sure what tree you're barking up, so it might be the right tree...but that reason is wrong).
Maybe you shouldn't post "Full stop" before reading the rest of my post.
Like my posts are like 10% what you post. Its not hard to read.
When I said "I think she is just making shit up" I think she is pretending like she knows more than she does because REASONS. You can say thats stupid or w/e but thats what I think.
she is lying and she has backtracked on her lies at least two times. I think she is town, but she is worthless as someone who has "info" as far as I am concerned.
She knows nothing.
In post 5368, Reasonably Rational wrote:If you come back and say you think she was "making" that "shit up" I'm going to be very disappointed in you FB.
-Cerb
Disappointed.
Fuck. I was about to go off on my theory thing, and then realized it would tell scum shit they don't need to know if I'm wrong, and ugh.
*sigh*
How about this. I'm not going to give you guys ANY of my reasoning behind this theory, other than the fact that Varsoon, after the first SU, while we were discussing the game, mentioned that this was something he had wanted to do with the game but the balance wouldn't have worked: What if the Crystal Gems are 3p? Perhaps with a win con that encompasses the town win con, or maybe supersedes it? I don't really know, designing win conditions for 3p isn't my thing, but...yeah. 3P crystal gems.
Just...think about that. I actually have sort of a laundry list of reasons to think that's super viable, but a lot of it involves certain other connections I've drawn that are, if I'm wrong, absolutely anti-town since they would identify a bunch of said crystal gems.
@NC: I'm now going to go away and not bother the game with theory talk. If anybody has any good questions related to the game to ask me, drop them here, I'll catch up when I wake up and try to deal with whatever it is you all care about before I go to work in the morning.
-Cerb
