Newbie 1747 (Game Over)
-
-
Hermie Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 751
- Joined: October 4, 2016
-
-
Creeps20 Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 720
- Joined: October 8, 2016
Hermie remember the latest game we played? The most unusual was town and the least was mafIn post 125, Hermie wrote:Creeps is acting unnatural. Currently rb is far more suspicious tho..-
-
Hermie Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 751
- Joined: October 4, 2016
-
-
Thor665 Papa Smurf
- Papa Smurf
- Papa Smurf
- Posts: 33454
- Joined: October 11, 2009
- Location: Venice, FL
So you're just saying things you don't understand/believe for the sake of conversation?-
-
Thor665 Papa Smurf
- Papa Smurf
- Papa Smurf
- Posts: 33454
- Joined: October 11, 2009
- Location: Venice, FL
-
-
Creeps20 Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 720
- Joined: October 8, 2016
Yup. I do that a lotIn post 128, Thor665 wrote:So you're just saying things you don't understand/believe for the sake of conversation?-
-
Zaicon
-
-
Thor665 Papa Smurf
- Papa Smurf
- Papa Smurf
- Posts: 33454
- Joined: October 11, 2009
- Location: Venice, FL
Why do you think it helps town to occlude your honest opinions?In post 130, Creeps20 wrote:
Yup. I do that a lotIn post 128, Thor665 wrote:So you're just saying things you don't understand/believe for the sake of conversation?-
-
MisaTange Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 378
- Joined: August 15, 2016
I think it's either 1. me badly rationalizing a town gutread or 2. feeling that persephone's overly cautious nature is newbtownThor665 wrote: There is literally nothing in her iso other than evidence she is a new player.
How do you justify getting a town read from that?
btw, I'm understanding the reasons on Hermie's fos on rb. rb's not giving reasons why he's townreading people. he's giving topic sentences, but not support sentences, in essence, and on posts he DOES give reasons on, it's only in response to posts he's been accused of.
Hermie, what's your stance/reads as of now? Note that townreads doesn't necessarily mean "confirmed town" (in my previous game, I early-townread a person that ended up being scum, and I admitted I was wrong in the early stages of day 2). Who's been giving off townvibes? Who's been giving off scumvibes? It's okay to have nullreads btw, and it's okay to scumread the most protown people.
P-Edit: Also, Hermie, creeps: What tone do you think newbscum/newbtown will come off as? "Unusual" or "natural"? Are your latest games even a good comparison to this environment? (with a very very small town, newbies-majority with a couple of people who've played games on the same site before, and one that's supposed to be teaching the newbies)"Tell me what you see, tell me. Is it scary? I hope it is, in fact, I hope it scares you to pieces."-
-
Creeps20 Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 720
- Joined: October 8, 2016
At this point anyone is a suspect. I always hate D1. For all we know we could have you and hermie as maf. Or aelin and me ect. We only have scum hunting at this point. No votes to go off or anything. We have a lack of information. Anyways my honest opinion is basically not to lynch D1. When I do I always hit jailor or doc.In post 132, Thor665 wrote:
Why do you think it helps town to occlude your honest opinions?In post 130, Creeps20 wrote:
Yup. I do that a lotIn post 128, Thor665 wrote:So you're just saying things you don't understand/believe for the sake of conversation?-
-
Creeps20 Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 720
- Joined: October 8, 2016
I actually have good comparison! It really depends on the personality of the player. Some players intentionally make themselves look scummy when they are a doc to save them from the deaths at night. One thing is for certain. Only 4 days worth of lynching. And this is never good I can tell youIn post 133, MisaTange wrote:
I think it's either 1. me badly rationalizing a town gutread or 2. feeling that persephone's overly cautious nature is newbtownThor665 wrote: There is literally nothing in her iso other than evidence she is a new player.
How do you justify getting a town read from that?
btw, I'm understanding the reasons on Her
mie's fos on rb. rb's not giving reasons why he's townreading people. he's giving topic sentences, but not support sentences, in essence, and on posts he DOES give reasons on, it's only in response to posts he's been accused of.
Hermie, what's your stance/reads as of now? Note that townreads doesn't necessarily mean "confirmed town" (in my previous game, I early-townread a person that ended up being scum, and I admitted I was wrong in the early stages of day 2). Who's been giving off townvibes? Who's been giving off scumvibes? It's okay to have nullreads btw, and it's okay to scumread the most protown people.
P-Edit: Also, Hermie, creeps: What tone do you think newbscum/newbtown will come off as? "Unusual" or "natural"? Are your latest games even a good comparison to this environment? (with a very very small town, newbies-majority with a couple of people who've played games on the same site before, and one that's supposed to be teaching the newbies)-
-
MisaTange Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 378
- Joined: August 15, 2016
That's a good point, but...
I have this odd, odd feeling that Creeps (assuming he is scum) will be like "oh! but im a pr trying to act scummy to avoid being nightkilled!". or use that to defend his scumpartner, but that's probably just me being paranoid."Tell me what you see, tell me. Is it scary? I hope it is, in fact, I hope it scares you to pieces."-
-
Hermie Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 751
- Joined: October 4, 2016
In post 133, MisaTange wrote:
I think it's either 1. me badly rationalizing a town gutread or 2. feeling that persephone's overly cautious nature is newbtownThor665 wrote: There is literally nothing in her iso other than evidence she is a new player.
How do you justify getting a town read from that?
btw, I'm understanding the reasons on Hermie's fos on rb. rb's not giving reasons why he's townreading people. he's giving topic sentences, but not support sentences, in essence, and on posts he DOES give reasons on, it's only in response to posts he's been accused of.
Hermie, what's your stance/reads as of now? Note that townreads doesn't necessarily mean "confirmed town" (in my previous game, I early-townread a person that ended up being scum, and I admitted I was wrong in the early stages of day 2). Who's been giving off townvibes? Who's been giving off scumvibes? It's okay to have nullreads btw, and it's okay to scumread the most protown people.
P-Edit: Also, Hermie, creeps: What tone do you think newbscum/newbtown will come off as? "Unusual" or "natural"? Are your latest games even a good comparison to this environment? (with a very very small town, newbies-majority with a couple of people who've played games on the same site before, and one that's supposed to be teaching the newbies)
I would say Thor is likely town... If he is scum he is giving unnecessary weight to a day 1 Lynch of scum...(at this point I am certain rb is scum so I will just write this post from that pov) and day 1 bussing is a very bad idea for scum
Creeps I would say is suspicious... He is not acting naturally scum or town... I don't know where to put him but I would leave it as suspicious
Aelin and Persephone are refusing to answer questions... Scummy but they both appear to be fairly noobish... I will leave them at null I guess
Mistange I originally thought was kinda scummy but most of my reasoning was OMGUS... I need to see more to guess... I'd leave that at null..
Penguin power I would have called town earlier but he isn't very active lately..... Null to slightly suspicious
And I request a prod of sinkongoreng
Rb is scum-
-
Creeps20 Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 720
- Joined: October 8, 2016
I shouldn't have said that. Now scum are going to be using it too get out of scumvilleIn post 136, MisaTange wrote:That's a good point, but...
I have this odd, odd feeling that Creeps (assuming he is scum) will be like "oh! but im a pr trying to act scummy to avoid being nightkilled!". or use that to defend his scumpartner, but that's probably just me being paranoid.-
-
MisaTange Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 378
- Joined: August 15, 2016
Hmm, okay.
VOTE: Aelin
I want to see more from her. Start accusing, point out flaws. Give yourself 30 minutes/an hour to read the six pages and point out flaws in reasoning. Who do you disagree with? Why? Who do you agree with? Why? This applies to persephone as well (gut reads only last so long), and sink (assuming he comes on) too. Not posting is antitown. We can't be overly dependent on our PRs and expect them to do all of our work for us.
P-Edit: You're still null, and now I've pointed it out, assuming that defense is used, people here will notice it more and call them out. Pointing out that defense will probably prevent that defense from being used... probably."Tell me what you see, tell me. Is it scary? I hope it is, in fact, I hope it scares you to pieces."-
-
Thor665 Papa Smurf
- Papa Smurf
- Papa Smurf
- Posts: 33454
- Joined: October 11, 2009
- Location: Venice, FL
The bolded is not an answer to the question, though I agree with it.In post 134, Creeps20 wrote:In post 132, Thor665 wrote:In post 130, Creeps20 wrote:
Yup. I do that a lotIn post 128, Thor665 wrote:So you're just saying things you don't understand/believe for the sake of conversation?Why do you think it helps town to occlude your honest opinions?At this point anyone is a suspect. I always hate D1. For all we know we could have you and hermie as maf. Or aelin and me ect. We only have scum hunting at this point. No votes to go off or anything. We have a lack of information.Anyways my honest opinion is basically not to lynch D1. When I do I always hit jailor or doc.
The italics are *also* not an answer to the question, and I disagree with them.
The question I put in Blue to help you find it.
Could you answer the question?
Requests to the mod should be put in bold to help them notice it, and usually prefacing with @Mod is a good idea also.In post 137, Hermie wrote:And I request a prod of sinkongoreng
Currently we still have about four and a half hours until he hits prod range per the mods posted rules.
I didn't think you believed it, and I already indicated that I didn't either.In post 138, Creeps20 wrote:I shouldn't have said that. Now scum are going to be using it too get out of scumville
Who is going to try to use something no one believes in to justify scummy play?-
-
Creeps20 Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 720
- Joined: October 8, 2016
I do believe it. I have done it as jailer, Vigilante ect.In post 140, Thor665 wrote:
The bolded is not an answer to the question, though I agree with it.In post 134, Creeps20 wrote:In post 132, Thor665 wrote:In post 130, Creeps20 wrote:
Yup. I do that a lotIn post 128, Thor665 wrote:So you're just saying things you don't understand/believe for the sake of conversation?Why do you think it helps town to occlude your honest opinions?At this point anyone is a suspect. I always hate D1. For all we know we could have you and hermie as maf. Or aelin and me ect. We only have scum hunting at this point. No votes to go off or anything. We have a lack of information.Anyways my honest opinion is basically not to lynch D1. When I do I always hit jailor or doc.
The italics are *also* not an answer to the question, and I disagree with them.
The question I put in Blue to help you find it.
Could you answer the question?
Requests to the mod should be put in bold to help them notice it, and usually prefacing with @Mod is a good idea also.In post 137, Hermie wrote:And I request a prod of sinkongoreng
Currently we still have about four and a half hours until he hits prod range per the mods posted rules.
I didn't think you believed it, and I already indicated that I didn't either.In post 138, Creeps20 wrote:I shouldn't have said that. Now scum are going to be using it too get out of scumville
Who is going to try to use something no one believes in to justify scummy play?
What does occlude mean?-
-
Creeps20 Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 720
- Joined: October 8, 2016
I do believe it. I have done it as jailer, Vigilante ect.In post 140, Thor665 wrote:
The bolded is not an answer to the question, though I agree with it.In post 134, Creeps20 wrote:In post 132, Thor665 wrote:In post 130, Creeps20 wrote:
Yup. I do that a lotIn post 128, Thor665 wrote:So you're just saying things you don't understand/believe for the sake of conversation?Why do you think it helps town to occlude your honest opinions?At this point anyone is a suspect. I always hate D1. For all we know we could have you and hermie as maf. Or aelin and me ect. We only have scum hunting at this point. No votes to go off or anything. We have a lack of information.Anyways my honest opinion is basically not to lynch D1. When I do I always hit jailor or doc.
The italics are *also* not an answer to the question, and I disagree with them.
The question I put in Blue to help you find it.
Could you answer the question?
Requests to the mod should be put in bold to help them notice it, and usually prefacing with @Mod is a good idea also.In post 137, Hermie wrote:And I request a prod of sinkongoreng
Currently we still have about four and a half hours until he hits prod range per the mods posted rules.
I didn't think you believed it, and I already indicated that I didn't either.In post 138, Creeps20 wrote:I shouldn't have said that. Now scum are going to be using it too get out of scumville
Who is going to try to use something no one believes in to justify scummy play?
What does occlude mean?-
-
MisaTange Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 378
- Joined: August 15, 2016
-
-
Creeps20 Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 720
- Joined: October 8, 2016
God damm stupid Google thingies!In post 143, MisaTange wrote:Google says: stop, close up, or obstruct (an opening, orifice, or passage). @Creeps
So it means that then? Okay let me try to answer that question.
And STUPID DOUBLE POSTING-
-
Creeps20 Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 720
- Joined: October 8, 2016
Most of the time they are wrong. There has been cases where I have lynched power roles due to my opinion being valued too strongly. I actually have a game on a different forum starting soon. I will be able to have much more useful opinions soon.In post 132, Thor665 wrote:
Why do you think it helps town to occlude your honest opinions?In post 130, Creeps20 wrote:
Yup. I do that a lotIn post 128, Thor665 wrote:So you're just saying things you don't understand/believe for the sake of conversation?-
-
MisaTange Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 378
- Joined: August 15, 2016
-
-
Creeps20 Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 720
- Joined: October 8, 2016
1)AelinInactive but new. Null at the moment
2)Creeps20Town
3)Hermie
4)MisaTangeFeels like he is trying to help but is heTooprotown?
5)PenguinPower[SE] Haven't seen much of him.
6)persephone325Same as alein
7)rb[SE] Scummy to say the least
8)sinkongorengInactive
9)Thor665[IC] No clear read. Nul
Here ya go-
-
Hermie Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 751
- Joined: October 4, 2016
I reaaally wonder about creeps... He is not voting even tho if he believes his reads list he has enough of a reason too.. As I have said this is not his normal play but I feel like a scum creeps would be in the thick of this.. accusing everyone.. but if he is town he is fairly useless at the moment. I list him as a likely scum I guess. I would like more content from him... If he doesn't pipe up soon I would really lean towards scum but rb is still far more suspicious in my opinion-
-
Hermie Goon
- Goon
- Goon
- Posts: 751
- Joined: October 4, 2016
Copyright © MafiaScum. All rights reserved.
-