Newbie 1747 (Game Over)

[MisaTange]

@Mod: Can we request sink to be prodded?

We need people contributing.

[MisaTange]

Since we have no questions to answer and everything we can has been brought up i thought I would mention that in my first ever game I was accused of playing here. Well yeah that is self explanatory

I actually kind of find this post weird, but probably because I believe town should talk talk talk.

[persephone325]

1) Aelin
2) Creeps20
3) Hermie
4) MisaTange
5) PenguinPower [SE]
6) rb [SE]
7) sinkongoreng
8) Thor665 [IC]

Original Roll String: 1d8

1 8-Sided Dice: (1) = 1

[persephone325]

VOTE: Thor665

[Hermie]

Aelin if you had to pick 2 town, who would it be?
If you had to pick 2 scum, who would it be?

If you're unsure it's fine, just answer the question as if you had a gun to your head or something. It's fine to be wrong, but it's not fine to be a non-contributor.

And added to the list of rbs town constructions! He asked aelin 2 questions after Thor has asked a whole list and got no response

Big lists can be intimidating. Two very easy questions can help new players contribute and get into the flow of the game. The goal is to get everyone contributing. I couldn't care less if someone made a whole list and got no response - I intend to keep encouraging other slots to contribute.

If you were town, why would you not like this?

I like it. But it's not much and it's late.. keep it up!

[Hermie]

I'm actually pretty comfortable with my win record right now. Thx.

You keep talking like lynches are going to happen immediately. Why is that?

@penguinpower.. I don't care when the Lynch's happen just that they happen and I am not used to a 14 day game day so I like to get the game moving...

[MisaTange]

1) Aelin
2) Creeps20
3) Hermie
4) MisaTange
5) PenguinPower [SE]
6) rb [SE]
7) sinkongoreng
8) Thor665 [IC]

Original Roll String: 1d8 (STATIC)

1 8-Sided Dice: (8) = 8

Oh, ffs...

Back to my nullreads you go.

[rb]

Since we have no questions to answer and everything we can has been brought up i thought I would mention that in my first ever game I was accused of playing here. Well yeah that is self explanatory

I actually kind of find this post weird, but probably because I believe town should talk talk talk.

Yes it's a bad post.

[rb]

1) Aelin
2) Creeps20
3) Hermie
4) MisaTange
5) PenguinPower [SE]
6) rb [SE]
7) sinkongoreng
8) Thor665 [IC]

Original Roll String: 1d8 (STATIC)

1 8-Sided Dice: (8) = 8

Lol, the list is the exact same order as the one in the OP. Dice fail.

Also, what's the point of this? :/

[Thor665]

So you're just saying things you don't understand/believe for the sake of conversation?

Yup. I do that a lot

Why do you think it helps town to occlude your honest opinions?

Most of the time they are wrong. There has been cases where I have lynched power roles due to my opinion being valued too strongly. I actually have a game on a different forum starting soon. I will be able to have much more useful opinions soon.

If you think your play will do nothing but lead to lynching PRs - what are you doing to improve your play?
Because lying about your opinions is (crazy hint) probably not good play.

Well can't afford a mislynch. If we must mislynch do it today. But we need full on scum hunting in order to preform such a task. No instant "oh you are scum" play yet.

We can afford multiple mislynches.
Statistically a mislynch Day 1 leads to more town wins than a no lynch.
So...

You are contributing absolutely nothing of value. If you are town, stop it.

I would suggest the same could be said of you.
Like I noted when asked about my issues with you (issues you didn't seem to care about - for now the second time demanding a case on you and then ignoring it) you're doing nothing but defending - even while claiming your defense is ignoring.
I'm also kind of miffed you ducked my questions to you.

VOTE: Hermie

This is pretty good for right now.

I find that a particularly bad vote right now.
Care to justify it so I can understand why it's good?
Hermie is probably my strongest town read at this moment. He's really the only person expressing a clear opinion on much of anything.

VOTE: Thor665

What sort of advantage do you expect to get by utterly random voting me?
Also, why did you not answer my other questions to you?

[Thor665]

@Mod: Can we request sink to be prodded?

We need people contributing.

@Mod - 2nded with fire.

[Zaicon]

Vote Count 1.3

rb (2):

Thor665, Hermie

Hermie (2):

rb, PenguinPower

Aelin (1):

MisaTange

Thor665 (1):

persephone325

No Vote (3):

Aelin, Creeps20, sinkongoreng

With 9 alive, it takes 5 to lynch!

Deadline is Tuesday, October 25, at 4:00 PM CST, which is in (expired on 2016-10-25 16:00:00).

Prodding sinkongoreng.

[Hermie]

This here is why I wish we would end days alittle sooner..m we are losing momentum... It's been 5 hours since a player posted so noone has new info to go off of... And the info we have is sufficient imo..

[Creeps20]

I don't think we will have sufficient data.

But I think i will, closer to the deadline, VTL alein

[Hermie]

Use VOTE: player name[/vote*]

[Creeps20]

I know hermie. I done it before

[Hermie]

Okay... Just saying that VTL isn't gonna get. Counted...

[Aelin]

Ok RB let me answer the two town two mafia question.
I'm really not 100% sure. To be brutally honest, you were at first suspicious to me, but now I'd say you were null.
Ok
Town- PenguinPower
MisaTange
Mafia???- ( for now I'll go for anyone who sticks out)
Creeps
Thor
I'll try and answer any more questions from now onwards.

[MisaTange]

Ooh, something substantial.

What do you mean by "sticks out"?

[persephone325]

Everyone said to randomly vote, so I randomly voted.

[MisaTange]

Nobody said that. In fact, people actually said 'vote who you think is mafia according to the thread, even if it's a weak read.' We wouldn't have this discussion had there been some reason behind the voting.

[Thor665]

Everyone said to randomly vote, so I randomly voted.

You are lying to us or to yourself, methinks.

[PenguinPower]

@mod: V/LA until 10/17

[Thor665]

I find that a particularly bad vote right now.
Care to justify it so I can understand why it's good?
Hermie is probably my strongest town read at this moment. He's really the only person expressing a clear opinion on much of anything.

@Penguin - before you go?

[PenguinPower]

I find that a particularly bad vote right now.
Care to justify it so I can understand why it's good?
Hermie is probably my strongest town read at this moment. He's really the only person expressing a clear opinion on much of anything.

@Penguin - before you go?

It's a weak read at best right now and mostly meta based, but his posting gives me bad vibes. I don't like his interactions with creeps - bringing way too much offsite meta into this thread. I also have a gut feel rb is town at this moment, and I don't mind sheeping him for the time being. I feel good about my vote right now, but will reassess once we hear more from others.

Should be able to check back in briefly in about 7 hours or so.