DafuqIn post 1973, MathBlade wrote:That is the crux of it.
IMHO if anyone is scum I would pick Creature over Stargazers. The last will mechanic would let Creature out his guilty. Instead he could have tunneled Nahdia and then saw who didn't want to vote her and see if his guilty was untampered with. However if it was the reads are lost because people are giving scum an out. (The paragraph assumes Nahdia town)
I think gut reaction based on how things went both are town or Creature is scum and Sly would be likely but not confirmed scum.
However I want to read and confirm. I also have a hard time believing Stargazers would crumb as scum.
Which is more likely, creature didn't think about waiting to out his guilty, or scum have a rolecop and scum!creature decided to sacrifice himself to lynch a non-consecutive roleblocker?