And this just seems too shifty - "And if you don't think Toto is scum, then who do you think is? Coming in and retracting your vote without making any new cases doesn't help town or get us closer to finding scum."
Spoiler:
In post 35, krylea wrote:In post 30, Srceenplay wrote:Both of Krylea and Mlmooney, why switch your votes over to Toto.
Someone getting 3 votes on page 1. What warrants that?
Toto, just because you changed avatar doesn't make you less scum. From what I have read a scum play is to avoid conflict. Is that what you are doing by changing it? Avoiding conflict?The way you find scum is by scumhunting and active pressure. Wagons in RVS help get you out of RVS which is always to the benefit of town. The only situation an early wagon is bad is if it leads to a speedlynch, which is generally unlikely unless someone is really stupid or careless. It isn't about an early kill. It's about information.Srceenplay wrote:Lots of people out for the early kill.
Can we not let everyone check in first?
Toto seemed, as you pointed out, to react defensively to pressure. This can be a scumtell, but also indicates that pressure on that person can lead to responses which might give additional information. Thus, I would definitely like to see more pressure on Toto. That being said, I didn't like mooney's vote at all either, and so my vote is staying parked on them for now.
In post 47, krylea wrote:In post 44, Toto wrote:I have thoughts.In post 45, Toto wrote:Don't have anything to say yet.Care to share with the class?
Come on folks, we need more people actively trying to find scum. I like that Toto at least seems to be trying to do something, even if I don't understand quite where it is coming from. Src, a few of your early posts were good, any thoughts on recent developments? Who are your scumreads now?
mooney, shannon, elhabe, I'd like to hear more from all of you (anything at all from shannon would be nice). Especially you, mooney, I'd like to hear more from you besides a naked vote please.
In post 66, krylea wrote:Then do it! Your vote is on Toto right now. Do you suspect he is scum? If so, push him for further info or apply additional pressure. If not, who do you suspect?In post 64, Elhabe21 wrote:I believe that we just need to keep pushing people for information
In post 67, krylea wrote:Oy, mooney, lets hear some more from you. I still don't like your page 1 very much. Get in the thread.
Has Arrowscum posted at all yet?
In post 108, krylea wrote:Scum can be just as active as town and take just as many risks as town. I don't think that is at all alignment indicative. I am not 100% sold on the Toto case, but I don't think this is a good reason to jump ship.In post 107, Elhabe21 wrote: [snipped for length]
My thoughts on the thread right now are: First I think that maybe Toto might not be scum since he's been taking so many risks with arguing and saying what's on his mind because scum wouldn't try to stand out and take so many risks with being noticed or judged. And because of this I'll
UNVOTE: Toto
However, I won't just ignore Toto and totally decide that he's innocent. I still want to keep an eye out for anything he reveals and I'll keep an open mind about others
And if you don't think Toto is scum, then who do you think is? Coming in and retracting your vote without making any new cases doesn't help town or get us closer to finding scum.