In post 9097, MathBlade wrote: In post 9095, Almost50 wrote:@Jae:
Knowing Math I can see them disregarding their own result on you and keeping the push, yes. However, if you are really willing to die, why not give them the opportunity to entertain us with a result on you? I can tell you what WILL happen beforehand, right here and right now, but I don't want to look like I'm giving you/them ideas, so let's just give them this one night to come up with the promised salvation.
@Gio:
Do us all a favour and check ME tonight. Scum can't kill both you AND Jae on the same night, so if you die I'm willing to eat the rope with Jae confirmed, and if Jae dies (thus Math having no result) I'd be confirmed.
Narna should probably pick someone outside of this pool of 4 to check.
Or we could make a chain, like Narna checking Gio (or vise versa) and the other checking Math while Math checks Jae. This way if Jae dies we still have results on both Math and Gio. If Gio/Narna die we have a result on Rae still with a possible result on Math (depending on which of Gio/Narna is dead).
I think the latter works better because while I'm not going to be NK'd with my claim anyway, the idea of Gio getting NK'd with me still not confirmed is not ideal in my own eyes.
Nahdia can still jail me if they want to, if we walk down the chain route that is.
Gio is claimed weak that is horrible as you are a scumread of mine.
Once again, if Gio dies I'd be lynched, but Rae will be alive and you will have a result on him, so that's good. You either caught two scum or caught one and confirmed a player as Town.
Now if BOTH Gio AND rae die there's no question about my alignment. I'd be conf!Scum all the way to the moon.
If Gio is alive I'm conf!town regardless, and we still ave your result on Rae.
And this was the first proposition. You haven' even addressed the alternative coarse I proposed in the same post.. the very post you have quoted in full to express concern over something trivial that has also been explained within the post.
GDI, yes we all know Gio is weak. So? We have him visiting CONFIRMED townies until he dies? WHAT is the use of his role then? A weak role is specifically used to scum hunt by visiting questionable slots and announcing it beforehand (or at least crumbing it in a way tha can easily be interpreted if they die at night). That way if they live their target is confirmed Town, and if they die it could be that their target is scum (if there's another NK that would be confirmed scum).