The Thing Mafia - Game over!

[drealmerz7]

crazy statistics:

this was the first game I started on MS (aside from a newb flake-out right from the beginning)

since this game started I have completed ELEVEN other games:

9 Town games and
2 Scum games

there were also:

2 games that got cancelled

holyfuck

[Andrius]

Yeah, when I sent in my choices I aid something like watch I've just made a neighborhood with half the scum team :/

Magna saved that exact quote for Postgame in the event we won.
I'm sure you'll see it in the THING PT.

Seal of Approval to Release the THING PT.

I said everything knowing it would be released. They deserve the full experience.

[Untrod Tripod]

You really don't have any reason to beat yourself up about having wrong reads. You played fine.

[drealmerz7]

I should have had my focus on EP instead of wraith

my theory was sound, the subject was wrong

[SirCakez]

Also something to apologize for - the scum 1-shot commute was basically completely useless. I overlooked that during setup creation, so sorry about that scum. Not that you needed it

[Spiffeh]

It sucks that we thought of the "Maria protects EP" thing, which gave EP a good excuse to still be alive.

EP you played really well too gj

PEdit: I think I played fine overall but I really need to stop tunneling and start reevaluating

[Spiffeh]

Did scum ever use their other abilities?

[SirCakez]

Did scum ever use their other abilities?

Scum actually didn't use any of the abilities.

[Tammy]

This is why I need someone I trust unconditionally like Tammy alive to keep me in check

I thought MoI could play that role but OBVIOUSLY NOT

Sorry.

[Tammy]

I should have had my focus on EP instead of wraith

my theory was sound, the subject was wrong

Heh well I wrote ep off as town for a confusing post he wrote I didn't really understand while I was drunk and never went back to figure out why I town read him.

[drealmerz7]

don't be sorry, somegames (most games, in my case) you're just off (that is the General Yu)

hard to get as good a feel very fast at all with a large playerlist too

drunkmaf ftl! but, yeah, it's all good

sorry I wasn't more enjoyable to play with, I often am (and often enough am not...)

[Spiffeh]

From the Dead Thread

I'm gonna be blunt here, while I certainly got

ridiculously

cocky and self-absorbed after D2 (dear god I'm still slapping myself over not protecting Creature from the start) I don't feel I was particularly helped by quite a few other townies. MariaR was in Errant's pocket

hard

the entire game and has been (bluntly speaking again) a useful idiot for scum the entire game. Drealmerz was essentially spiteposting for a period spanning several game days. Firebringer and SpyreX were not particularly helpful the entire game and at one point literally joined forces with a scumbag who tipped his hand to overthrow the dictatorship of myself and Spiffeh (I can't emphasize this enough). And UT has arguably done even less, as if he's been cowed into silence by us scumreading him for so long.

I am completely with you Wraith. While I completely acknowledge my role in our loss I really don't think many other town players played well enough to warrant us taking most of the blame. I think it was a collective suck for the town after Day 2.

[Tammy]

I think I lost patience when you accused me of misrepping you.

You scum reading me in the particular way you did pretty much just reinforced my town read on you.

[SirCakez]

All the rooms have been released!

[Spiffeh]

I look forward to the Scum PT getting released.

Thanks for the game SirCakez I had fun overall even though I was very frustrated at points!

[Untrod Tripod]

I don't understand why you're bothering to apologize when literally no one thinks you played poorly, Spiff

[Spiffeh]

Idk I think my tunneling and OMGUSy nature contributed to our loss.

I'm just overly hard on myself.

I realize I played better than most townies though so it's cool.

[Spiffeh]

Apparently Don Corleone isn't a scummy category anymore so I couldn't nom MoI. That sucks.

[Firebringer]

From the Dead Thread

I'm gonna be blunt here, while I certainly got

ridiculously

cocky and self-absorbed after D2 (dear god I'm still slapping myself over not protecting Creature from the start) I don't feel I was particularly helped by quite a few other townies. MariaR was in Errant's pocket

hard

the entire game and has been (bluntly speaking again) a useful idiot for scum the entire game. Drealmerz was essentially spiteposting for a period spanning several game days. Firebringer and SpyreX were not particularly helpful the entire game and at one point literally joined forces with a scumbag who tipped his hand to overthrow the dictatorship of myself and Spiffeh (I can't emphasize this enough). And UT has arguably done even less, as if he's been cowed into silence by us scumreading him for so long.

I am completely with you Wraith. While I completely acknowledge my role in our loss I really don't think many other town players played well enough to warrant us taking most of the blame. I think it was a collective suck for the town after Day 2.

Ummm not to make this post game like toxic.

I agree with you that you don't shelter all the blame. Hell my overreaction to you refusing to work with me was less than appropriate

But if you claim you lead all the lynches (which you claimed to have led every lynch but dreals)
You probably should shoulder most of the blame.

But then I disagree that you actually lead all the scum lynches.
Like I scumread both toog and goat regardless of anything you posted

But anyway, everyone here is right that you didn't play like entire shit. You got fooled and that's part of game.

[Untrod Tripod]

you can nominate just MoI for just this game

[Andrius]

In hindsight, Magna orchestrated EVERYTHING.
We agreed to pick the same number, we agreed to bus me about mid-game, he orchestrated the little plays and gave input for night actions and helped Ranmaru and EP out when they needed a push. He got me to make the ballsy play and kill Tammy. He got me to not fear the connections. Magna was the Most Cunning Manipulator, even if that award doesn't exist anymore.

[Spiffeh]

I don't think I ever claimed to lead every scum lynch or that I did it all on my own. Just that I was most responsible for the Goatmeal and Andrius lynches.

Which I still stand behind tbh

[Firebringer]

I don't think I ever claimed to lead every scum lynch or that I did it all on my own. Just that I was most responsible for the Goatmeal and Andrius lynches.

Which I still stand behind tbh

Andrius yes.
Goatmeal no.

[Spiffeh]

And the only reason I mentioned them was because I was incredulous that people were scum reading me so hard at that point. Not to be cocky. So I hope that's not how it came across.

[Untrod Tripod]

well this game was super fun for a time, and that makes it worth it

plus, the Princess Spiffeh invitational will be legendary