The Thing Mafia - Game over!

[Firebringer]

Honestly this game was pretty damn fun overall.

I kind of acted like a dick on day i was lynched, but beyond that it was fun.

Only thing I didn't like was just following plan. It started become A) Plan night B) Accuse anyone not following plan as scum
i wish we did more scum hunting beyond those and had that as still in existence but less emphasis

[Andrius]

I dislike large games that have one death a night.
One death a night in 20+ players is torture.
Especially with 2 week deadlines.

[McMenno]

that's why you make it 21-faction multiball

[Wraith]

I admit the night planning created a serious problem in that it made defiance look scummy and obviously was backed by several scumbags.

But it did achieve one of my primary intended objectives which was to force the scum to nightkill within a specific pool of players.

There were two chief flaws to the whole thing:

1. Scum picked roles that would be key to town success specifically to deny them to the town. This meant several players were held "above suspicion" for a long time simply because of the strength of their role and that there weren't enough sincere townies with powerful roles to make any meaningful results.

2. I failed to realize the roles that were truly most powerful and critical to town success (Lockdowner, Tracker) until it was far too late. The scum prioritized killing those roles early, and I suspect deliberately.

[Andrius]

1. Scum picked roles that would be key to town success specifically to deny them to the town.

You'll read a lot about our draft choices in the THING PT but yeah, this was the driving factor behind our choices.

[Spiffeh]

SirCakez I have homework to do which means I need reading material to procrastinate which means you must open the scum PT immediately.

[SirCakez]

Scum PT: http://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.ph ... 3#p8402333

It's quite a trip

[Gamma Emerald]

I gaze upon the scum PT crystal ball...
...MoI is the true mastermind. He is officially on my watchlist for scum, ESPECIALLY in setups with public information.

[Andrius]

It's quite a trip

We laughed, you cried, most of us died.

In the end, it actually WAS a Shakespearian Tragedy.

[Wraith]

Subject: The Thing Mafia - Underground Tunnels (Scum Chat)

It's cool people will forget. I'm just trying to make it seem like we are un-aligned and I think it's working because Wraith sees us as TvS. I'll need you to produce a reason or say that you were just voting us for pressure after I respond to you.

Ouch fuck

[Spiffeh]

as soon as i saw spiffeh townleaning me i orgasmed and have been orgasming ever since

Also ew

[MariaR]

After waht happened in this game I think that's the last thing we should ew about

[Wraith]

Creature needs to die.
If Wraith keeps up the confirming people list we will have problems. Killing the Lockdowner will help assuage those fears.

Careful who you block, Magna. I might block you one night since your action resolves before mine and we need some confirmage help.

NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

[Wraith]

It's funny that y'all were talking about McMenno's death by Vig like it was a done deal. I was

this

close to letting my doubts take over and sparing him just to see how it played out. But in the end I decided it was too risky and would turn people against me.

[Wraith]

And during that crisis of faith I was also considering lying and claiming my shot was somehow blocked and then surprising a scumread with it later in the game, but deemed that

way

too risky a gambit.

[Andrius]

It's funny that y'all were talking about McMenno's death by Vig like it was a done deal.

I, at least, know you well enough to know you'd follow The Plan.

[Spiffeh]

I am vomming all over the love fest in the Scum PT

I hate that you guys won

I am salty

[Wraith]

Just reading that thread and I see that MoI is like a clone of me, only a better version.

Since I'm a huge sucker for people following similar lines of thought this is gonna have to be how I treat MoI if we're together in future games

[Wraith]

Only just now am I starting to think abandoning the Nightkill PoE lists post-Andrius flip was a mistake. It might have been able to clear some people in the lategame, I don't know.

[Wraith]

By the way, for post game:
That one room being CLOSED was not an intentional fluke in the plan.

Thanks for starting that, Magna.

hahahahahahaha

[Andrius]

I am vomming all over the love fest in the Scum PT

I hate that you guys won

I am salty

Only just now am I starting to think abandoning the Nightkill PoE lists post-Andrius flip was a mistake. It might have been able to clear some people in the lategame, I don't know.

One of many reasons why my bus was planned and inevitable.

By the way, for post game:
That one room being CLOSED was not an intentional fluke in the plan.

Thanks for starting that, Magna.

hahahahahahaha

Like, Magna warned me he'd start questioning me.
Not literally blowing holes in my plan.

[MariaR]

Only regret I have is that I couldn't crush enough dreams

[Spiffeh]

Too many damn PTs to keep track of.

Post 9 in the Lab was not intended to be there. I thought I was posting here.

Epic Face-palm for me. I've tried to cover in the Radio thread but ... god that was bad.

LOL it made perfect sense with what was being discussed in the Lab at the time so I thought nothing of it.

[Andrius]

Your refusal to vote me made my day, in case that wasn't obvious.
So that's CRUSHING DREAMS but MAKING DREAMS COME TRUE maybe.

[Andrius]

So that's not* CRUSHING DREAMS.