Hi all, especially hi Claim!
I've had a read through things. I still need to think some things through, and take a good look at my notes, essentially I will be back in a few hours with better fleshed out ideas but I shall throw some preliminary thoughts out.
Leaning town on:
Mack
- His activity levels are good. In the first pages he game me the impression of reading every post carefully, almost "hanging onto" the thread waiting for someone to post. It just seems like it would be hard to imitate as scum on their first game. And it sounds like he's mostly just been saying what's on him mind. Yeah the vote on cyrus could be opportunistic but it doesn't seem like enough evidence to counteract the rest.
emps
- I agree with most of his posts. Especially around posts
152-159 his thoughts seemed to echo mine. Some of his more recent posts are nullish.
Null:
Dyrenz/
Sera Masumi
- just not much content yet.
eekveek/
Claim
- similar, not much content. I will say I just finished a game with Claim in which he was scum. He doesn't really post much in general, but compared to that game he seems bolder and more engaged which are good signs. Curious about this whole PT affair.
Leaning scum:
Rob
- I disagree with emps, his progression didn't seem especially town. I am going to look at a couple of his past games to see how they compare.
Doc
- reasons people have mentioned. Hasn't posted much but what he has posted could easily be opportunistic. Has not pushed anyone or made much of an effort D1.
Questions!
@MOD: can people get a pt if they PM you?
Anyone: is there a way to get a notes PT besides the mod making one for you?
@Rob: I get that tunnelling people is something you do as both town or scum. Why do you do it as town? It hasn't really served you well in this game.
@Doc: How did Mack's experience with Mafia inform your read? Why are you voting Mack now - weren't you reading him as "solidly town" yesterday? Could you generally be more forthcoming in sharing why you're doing what you're doing?