Newbie 1838: Pirates vs Ninjas: GAME OVER!

[Jodaxq]

Oh, no, I'm really sorry. I meant am I not supposed to join another game before finishing this one?
Obviously you can reference posts. Sorry for the ambiguity.

Oh I see. I'm sorry for the misinterpretation. I think you can play in as many games as you can handle.

[TheGoldenParadox]

Thank you.

[Jodaxq]

Back to the game:

Are you ready to give up yet TGP? I kind of want to see if the others pick up on my posts

[fferyllt]

Oh, no, I'm really sorry. I meant am I not supposed to join another game before finishing this one?
Obviously you can reference posts. Sorry for the ambiguity.

Newbies can join other queues while playing their first MS Newbie game, but can't join another newbie game while they are alive in their first one.

[TheGoldenParadox]

Thank you!

[TheGoldenParadox]

Back to the game:

Are you ready to give up yet TGP? I kind of want to see if the others pick up on my posts

Again, I am not mafia. Why would I say that I am mafia when I am town?

[Jodaxq]

Back to the game:

Are you ready to give up yet TGP? I kind of want to see if the others pick up on my posts

Again, I am not mafia. Why would I say that I am mafia when I am town?

Well I know we can't really move on until others get on and vote to lynch you, but I don't really want to drag this out forever and I thought maybe you'd feel the same since you're in a hopeless situation.

[TheGoldenParadox]

"A hopeless situation"
You are really the only one actively attacking me. I am not in a hopeless situation because I am town. Why can't you understand that I am town?
Are you expecting me to vote myself? That would just help the mafia by killing a town player.
If I am killed, when I flip town, the mafia would kill wilky. Smiles and you(the other town read players) would be clueless. The game would quickly collapse, and mafia would win.
I suggest you avoid a mislynch.

[Jodaxq]

"A hopeless situation"
You are really the only one actively attacking me. I am not in a hopeless situation because I am town. Why can't you understand that I am town?
Are you expecting me to vote myself? That would just help the mafia by killing a town player.
If I am killed, when I flip town, the mafia would kill wilky. Smiles and you(the other town read players) would be clueless. The game would quickly collapse, and mafia would win.
I suggest you avoid a mislynch.

I'm the only one actively attacking you because no one else is online. Once the others get on and read my posts they'll pick up on them and vote you.
I can't understand that you're town because you're not. You are, quite literally, the strongest scum read I've had in my entire mafia career.
At some point I do expect you to self-vote, yes.
Haha that's funny. Smiles has had great reads all game and I was the first to case Acid yesterday and I've caught you. I was anything but clueless in this game.

[Jodaxq]

Each time I post I'll try to make it more and more obvious. This has been fun but I'm kind of afraid that I'm starting to feel bad about wasting everyone's time.

[smilefires]

Here.

I think I get it.

[smilefires]

I mean, I have to get around to believing it because that'd be amazing.

[smilefires]

Okay, I'm not hammering or anything (I got confused by how many times Jo voted )

VOTE: TheGoldenParadox
putting him at 2.

I believe you.

[TheGoldenParadox]

"A hopeless situation"
You are really the only one actively attacking me. I am not in a hopeless situation because I am town. Why can't you understand that I am town?
Are you expecting me to vote myself? That would just help the mafia by killing a town player.
If I am killed, when I flip town, the mafia would kill wilky. Smiles and you(the other town read players) would be clueless. The game would quickly collapse, and mafia would win.
I suggest you avoid a mislynch.

I'm the only one actively attacking you because no one else is online. Once the others get on and read my posts they'll pick up on them and vote you.
I can't understand that you're town because you're not. You are, quite literally, the strongest scum read I've had in my entire mafia career.
At some point I do expect you to self-vote, yes.
Haha that's funny. Smiles has had great reads all game and I was the first to case Acid yesterday and I've caught you. I was anything but clueless in this game.

Sure, but I'm your only scum read. Who will you vote for when I flip town?

[TheGoldenParadox]

Okay, I'm not hammering or anything (I got confused by how many times Jo voted )

VOTE: TheGoldenParadox
putting him at 2.

I believe you.

Smiles;
What makes you change your mind that quickly? Can you please quote specific posts that show that I am guilty?

[TheGoldenParadox]

Two wagons, both at L-2
Alonzo (TGD, Wilky)
TGD (Jodaxq, Smiles)
Not Voting (Bella, Nauci, Alonzo)

[TheGoldenParadox]

Dead (Moz, Acid)

[smilefires]

Okay, I'm not hammering or anything (I got confused by how many times Jo voted )

VOTE: TheGoldenParadox
putting him at 2.

I believe you.

Smiles;
What makes you change your mind that quickly? Can you please quote specific posts that show that I am guilty?

It's not really about what

you've

posted. But I might as well run down the player list.

You're voting Alonzo; see, I think he's town because a flipped wolf wanted him to die for most of yesterday after moving to you for a bit.

Jo had been suspecting the more experienced players in the game from near the moment she replaced in and got caught up, and lynching acidphoenix is consistent with that:

Coincidentally all the experienced slots in this game are the most concerning so far.

Bellaphant is probably the weakest scum read of them, but I really feel like a town IC should have way more to comment on and should be way more engaging than she has currently been. The fact that I feel like a scum IC should also have more to comment on makes me think that she could be having RL obstacles.

Mozamis whole game has felt a little bit strange. I really don't like his pushing for a "rushed" lynch as well as asking for a claim and then being impatient about receiving it. I also don't like how he defends his tunneling or post 35 where it feels like he's trying to garner early town reads.

AcidPhoenix has been the worst though and I have a bad feeling about him. He's generated basically no content except for post 101 which I don't like at all. It seems like very low-hanging fruit to comment on a list of names with no reads. I also don't like that he jumped on Nauci's slip with a vote for Alonzo, especially after he somewhat admitted that Alonzo could be lynch bait in post 89.
VOTE: acidphoenix

Bella endorsed an acid lynch as well before we went through with it:

Acid still didn't really back up his readslist with anything concrete, like Jo said. There's been a ton of content from jo, wilky is obv!town, and there isn't any pressure towardss moz from this slot at all: in fact, I had no idea acid was scum reading moz, as previously they seemed to be agreeing. i'd Like to hear a bit more from paradox and smiles, but I'd be happy to vote here.

acid, you need to claim.

p-edit,

ugh.

I hate that you can't back up your townreads, and as much as i don't wanna rush the day, I'm kinda okay with this.

and wilky came in with the hammer. If either wilky or Nauci happened to be busing with their posts toward the end of the day to acid, I'd probably still give them a day pass. Especially for wilky - the interactions that produced these posts:

I strongly don't give a shit about whether you want to hammer if it's based on, mostly, pedantic wording, especially in a world where

the same post

clearly indicates the order within the tier

I can't tell whether that's an actual intent to hammer or a i-want-your-reaction, if it's the former please repeat it and I'll claim

fucking I switched to phone and forgot this account was on an alt

obviously this is acidphoenix

zzz

would be serious scum theater if that's the world we live in, so I don't consider it a very likely world.

So that leaves you.

Jo, are you having fun?

[fferyllt]

Vote Count 1-2

Alonzo

(2): wilky, TheGoldenParadox

TheGoldenParadox

(2): Jodaxq, smilefires

Not Voting

(3): Bellaphant, Nauci, Alonzo

With 7 alive, it takes 4 to lynch.

Deadline: December 29, Midnight US Eastern Time.

Countdown: (expired on 2017-12-28 21:00:00)

Mod Notes:

-

[Jodaxq]

Jo, are you having fun?

I did have a lot of fun. I really did get a few good laughs out of his posts.

[Jodaxq]

"A hopeless situation"
You are really the only one actively attacking me. I am not in a hopeless situation because I am town. Why can't you understand that I am town?
Are you expecting me to vote myself? That would just help the mafia by killing a town player.
If I am killed, when I flip town, the mafia would kill wilky. Smiles and you(the other town read players) would be clueless. The game would quickly collapse, and mafia would win.
I suggest you avoid a mislynch.

I'm the only one actively attacking you because no one else is online. Once the others get on and read my posts they'll pick up on them and vote you.
I can't understand that you're town because you're not. You are, quite literally, the strongest scum read I've had in my entire mafia career.
At some point I do expect you to self-vote, yes.
Haha that's funny. Smiles has had great reads all game and I was the first to case Acid yesterday and I've caught you. I was anything but clueless in this game.

Sure, but I'm your only scum read. Who will you vote for when I flip town?

I'd probably be done playing mafia on this site for good so nobody. Maybe I'd vote Fferyllt

[Jodaxq]

It's probably time to give up some reads since I haven't done anything except tunnel on

TheGoldenParadox

I'm having a bit of trouble deciding on who the doctor could be in this game. Bellaphant and Alonzo claimed VT so I doubt they are it. I think Smilefires was legitimately worried about being the NK so I don't think he's it because he likely would have protected himself. It's between Nauci and Wilky but I really can't get a read on either of them. Maybe there's no doctor and everyone's vanilla townie?

[Jodaxq]

Sorry guys I'm a little intoxicated so I've decided to share a story. It's about a dream I had last night. I dreamt I was out on patrol when a hot hipster chick with purple hair and red eyes appeared in front of me. She had these little bat wings sticking out of her head and she flew over to me. She whispered into my ear that

TheGoldenParadox

was mafia.

[Jodaxq]

What a crazy dream right?

[Jodaxq]

(Going by the player list in the OP):

Smilefires -

Vanilla Townie

Alonzo -

Vanilla Townie

TheGoldenParadox -

Mafia Goon

Nauci -

Vanilla Townie

Wilky -

Vanilla Townie

Acidphoenix -

Mafia Goon

Mozamis -

Vanilla Townie

Bellaphant -

Vanilla Townie

Did I get anyone wrong?