Sorry. Due to recent things that happened in Mini 836, all other games went down in my priority list. Now it's time to catch up, and I did a short analysis of every player.
Afatchic - One of the least active players around. His posts however are IMO decent 'catching up' posts, that brings a lot to the table. I can only hope, he'll be more active in the future.
I have one complain though. You still didn't answer Vi's survey. I know that hectic schedule is troublesome, and there's not enough time sometimes, but answering those question is the work for 5-10 minutes. IMO it should be done by now, and it's weird it isn't yet, especially if you declared, you're going to do it..
Also, one little nitpick from me.
Afatchic wrote:Seriously guys, im gone three days and already have a policy lynch wagon forming?
5 days actually
![Wink ;)](./images/smilies/icon_wink.gif)
EDIT by preview - Ok, no complains
Cruciare - Hard to tell at the moment. His rebellious behavior toward Vi's survey was pretty weird, but his later case on Y.C is pretty decent, and he don't seem to forget about other players and their actions. I don't really like his playstyle, but I doubt he's playing differently as a scum or town, so I cannot suspect him for it.
DeathRowKitty - What I don't like any single bit, is the fact, that you were attacking Y.C and Y.C only, almost ignoring anyone else in the thread. I don't get this whole 'let's wait some times before questioning Jammer'. If someone acts suspicious, then he should be investigated immediately. Now I can see identical thing, after pops claimed. Since you don't want to lynch claimed PR, you turned into Jammer direction, and I wouldn't be surprised if you would ignore everything else yet again. Appealing for a quickhammer for Y.C/pops is not helping either.
In worst case scenario, I see your actions as: 'Y.C is an easy D1 lynch, let's push it as hard as possible.' When this turned to be impossible, you turned in Jammer's direction, because several other people are suspicious of him, so he looks like another easy lynch target. There's also TMJ here, but since when you were pursuing Y.C, you said you seem his a newbie townie, so now going after him would be too dangerous.
Of course, I'm not convinced, this is true, but it's certainly a possibility.
Imaginality - Well, as I said, I didn't liked any single bit his and DRK's posts that were screaming 'speedlynch' to me. Other than that, he's not very active, and now we have this doc thingy, that may look like a rolefishing. To be honest, I don't know yet, what to think of it. I'll wait for his response to Vi's case, and then decide.
James.Denholm - Again, I'm puzzled. Not much content, this weird paranoia about Vi's survey, and finally 'scum reads on Y.C/pops, and yet I don't think he's scum'. I just don't get it. And I don't like it. I would like to hear some more from him about other players as well.
Jammer - So... We have this weird vote hopping. It's especially weird, when he says all the time that Y.C is scummy, but votes others (My guess - to make not active players talk), and when Y.C is going to be replaced, and cannot answer any more questions, he votes. It all looks scummy, but my gut says otherwise. Possibly, because I already participated in one game when Jammer was a scum, and he behaved differently. We'll see in the future, but for now neutral read.
Porkens - Well, after playing one game with him, I think I can easily guess (and I think, that Jammer can back me up with this) that Porkens is not a cop this time
![Razz :P](./images/smilies/icon_razz.gif)
Also his weird ploy (or maybe should I say - trap) with Vi's survey is a thing, that I should expect from him, after seeing his playstyle, really. He seems to be concerned with Y.C/pops only, until his last post, which is not good however. His post are also very short, but usually to the point. I guess that's just his playstyle. Slight town read. Also, as someone pointed out - Still observing 'that thing'?
Sigma - More like enigma... Only 9 posts so far, but his case on Y.C and reactions about possible quicklynch, are giving me town read. I'm very interested, how his posts will look like in later game.
Tjoe Min Ja - Ah, TMJ... His start was IMO incredibly terrible. Sheeping, answers are simply far from truth (like when he said that Y.C was the only one not to answer Vi's survey). Now, his posts are somewhat better, but still short, and there's not much of them. My suspicions are not as big as previously, but he's definitely far from going to 'obv town' basket.
Vi - Main engine of every discussion. Lots of scumhunting, very active. I like his approach, and cannot see him as scum in any way. Town read.
Y.C/Pops - I already stated what i think about Y.C. Last time when I spoke about Pops, I said my read on him is somewhere near 'Banana!' on the scale, but now it's going into 'not helping the town' region which of course is closer to 'obv scum' rather than 'obv town'. I really want to see some real scumhunt from him.
That's everyone, I guess... My conclusion?
My vote stays for now on TMJ. His later content is still not enough to cover up, what he did earlier. But if he's posting will get better, I'll probably unvote him.
If not him, then who?
Huge FoS: DeathRowKitty
, for reasons stated above. Even more so, if Pops and/or Jammer will turn out to be town.
[b]Mini 934[/b] is [b]over![/b] Thanks to everyone participating.
[i]What the hell? That Colonel guy was awesome.[/i] - Fate