In post 2138, Ellie wrote:Do you think ika absolutely follows Normal Guidelines?
Don't all Normal games have to follow the guidelines?
In post 2138, Ellie wrote:Do you think ika absolutely follows Normal Guidelines?
In post 2141, Wake1 wrote:In post 2135, SilverWolf wrote:In post 2133, Wake1 wrote:OK.
So if we have a Cop it's still alive.
It should investigate vikingfan.
Does anyone know if someone claimed Cop already?
If so, judging by the fact that person isn't dead, maybe the dead Doc protected that Cop player, and could mean we're looking at 3 killing factions. The unique part of vf's claim rings a bit with that sentiment.
vf claimed he was told he was attacked and protected, ever heard of this before?
He's the only one who claimed cop so far. He said he got no result last night.
Those unique slots can also include mechanics.
This includes original ones not in the wiki.
Let's think on this for a minute. Why would VF, if Scum, go through the trouble of making an incredibly dubious-sounding claim when he could go the easy route? Do you remember when I claimed Sensor and how everyone reacted in spite of my honesty? Let's not forget the lessons of the past so quickly (I often tell this to myself).
The guy who claimed Doc, sans the RB and our Doc, may be killed Day 2. That much is obvious.
In post 2157, Ellie wrote:So why in the world wouldn't we force the scum to shoot him tonight. No RB, no doc.
In post 2165, MathBlade wrote:In post 2162, SilverWolf wrote:mathblade-don't ever change, you have no idea how badly I need to smile right now
Your wish is my command
Comedy? Romance?
In post 2167, MathBlade wrote:Alrighty
Here's a free comedic wedding from your "videographer"
http://homestarrunner.com/sbemail205.html
In post 2169, elusive wrote:I meant to catch up with this today but too much going on elsewhere.
Just leaving a note for myself (ISO pisskop for interactions, ISO NakedJogger, ISO FA_Q2, look back at who else was on which wagons)
SW, what kind of music do you like? This makes me feel pumped up-> https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NdLEz4OklXU
In post 2173, MathBlade wrote:Too bad not optional. Opinions now.
In post 2175, MathBlade wrote:Guts are awesome. I hear every person has one. They help with digestion. Think in the thread.
In post 2182, MathBlade wrote:
Noted. Thank you for your opinion. However I think not lynching in these two is a mistake.
I need a big stick to make people say opinions yo. Troll stick.
In post 2187, MathBlade wrote:I think at this point we need to lynch Viking Fan.
Reason being if they are town they aren't likely to live very much longer to provide needed results. I also have significant doubts about their claim.
Secondly a doctor is dead. While possible there may be two docs I don't want to bet on us getting results from VF tomorrow. That bet is just bad.
Thirdly I have seen an assocation in D1 between NJ and VF. If VF is scum then we may be able to get NJ afterward pretty damn quick.
Now let's look at the converse and assume VF is town. Then ABR's play with the fake claim and how he immediately entered suggested a strategy of wanting to lynch VF out of the gate. His entire posting isn't really talking about anyone else and it suggests a certain confidence. One I'd expect him to put his own life behind. Therefore if VF is town then ABR very likely scum.
Therefore lynching VF from my POV will net us 1 scum or 2 in two rounds. It's protown to do as we can't put off lynching VF for results that may never be true or that we may never see.
Yay big sticks are awesome
So logically my head says VikingFan. My gut says ABR. Hence I'm down for both.
In post 2197, Shinobi wrote:@SW: I'm still "meh" on the whole "lynch VF" train. I'm only considering lynching him because it seems like a necessity to get people to stop stuffing their heads up their asses.
I accept the fact that he could be scum, but I think the way we're going about this is completely wrong and I think the lynch is kind of lame based on the circumstances.
In post 2562, Nobody Special wrote:
In post 2518, Ozgin wrote:
Well, I've just decided to give VF one more night because I don't think it's fair that someone be lynched for poor circumstance.
You're one of them TouchyFeely LIBERALS who thinks everyone should get a trophy just for showing up, aren't you?
In post 2775, Albert B. Rampage wrote:I breadcrumbed shinobi town in case I died already.
In post 2799, elusive wrote:Yes, let's have all of town out their roles while ABR fake claims over fake claims over fake claims.
In post 2805, vikingfan wrote:In post 2800, SilverWolf wrote:In post 2775, Albert B. Rampage wrote:I breadcrumbed shinobi town in case I died already.
I found this. ISO ABR and look for Shinobi.
So? We've only had one night since we started with day. He says he has a guilty on ellie and an innocent on Ellie but we've only had one night. That's impossible.
In post 2829, Kitz wrote:What. The. Fuck.
Are you sure that ABR isn't a jester / fool or whatever?
At this point he just threw the game in all sense of directions.
In post 2938, goodmorning wrote:
FTFY
In post 2951, goodmorning wrote:Was thinking more the one where the bottle hits the cameraman if we're talking soda disaster feels, BUT YES
In post 2975, Ellie wrote:You're not the cop. If you are gambiting town, my role is evidence that VF is town and you should adjust accordingly.
In post 3001, vikingfan wrote:In post 2999, SilverWolf wrote:I see ABR fighting harder than VF. He just feels more like town believing he's caught scum than VF does with his lack of any conviction or emotion behind his posts on this. If I were him, and the cop, I'd be screaming my head off right now to lynch ABR. He's not doing that. It seems off the way he's letting others fight his battle while ABR is right out there in front fighting his.
I've been fighting for ages and screaming my head off about ABR being scum. What else are people wanting? I'm not going to post walls of posts like ABR has.
In post 3018, elusive wrote:SilverWolf, I have seen very passionate and convincing scum weasel their way out of a sure lynch and get townies killed. Is there anything else that belies you to believe that?
In post 3119, elusive wrote:
If we did have a town day or night vig, here you are - any of these are not only fair game but will die if I don't die first (hey town I'm a claimed PR, why not lynch me next):
Dragonspawn, FA_Q2, silverwolf, Naked jogger, ABR, mathblade, ozgin shinobi, wake88
In post 3147, elusive wrote:
However, I suggest that you move the game forward instead of engaging in theatrics at this point.
In post 3154, elusive wrote:SW, I don't see you fulfilling your town meta in this game SilverWolf and also your annoyance has no worth to me since there is no reason for it. Nonsensical nonsense.
GM, don't get involved with SW's nonsense. It's become on par for the course.
In post 3154, elusive wrote:Kitz is fucking off limits because Ellie was sure on her and at this point in the game I trust Ellie's reads above anyone else's.
In post 3216, Albert B. Rampage wrote:Anyway, lynch me if you have to. I tracked Mathblade to Ellie last night.
In post 3266, Albert B. Rampage wrote:Mathblade is a bulletproof SK.
In post 3270, elusive wrote:As for Ozgin, its the going with the crowd that annoys me.
Can ALL OF TOWN please give a reads list. Take the players name from the OP, put it in spoilers and a short thing of what your current feelings are. Thanks.
In post 3272, MathBlade wrote:In post 3268, SilverWolf wrote:In post 3266, Albert B. Rampage wrote:Mathblade is a bulletproof SK.
I think this is possible. I can't think of any town roles where someone can only be killed by lynching and are immune to scum Nk's.
Can anyone else?
....Called X-shot bullet proof townie...My X just happens to be missing and I have a stupid post restriction
In post 3282, estival wrote:Wait house replaced out? No? What?
In post 3352, MathBlade wrote:Hint: It is protown to lynch me. Please do so now.
In post 3356, MathBlade wrote:In post 3353, SilverWolf wrote:In post 3352, MathBlade wrote:Hint: It is protown to lynch me. Please do so now.
OK, mathblade is officially weird this game.
Nooooooooo I'm not weird....not at all. Oh and ABR is town and I'm town. But I promise that things will make sense. I'd probably be your best lynch today as then I can explain why certain people are conf town. Please lynch the MathBlade
In post 3345, goodmorning wrote:
In post 3343, SilverWolf wrote:Why is almost everyone on your list a scumread?
He's got like 5.5 out of what, 17? 18?
That's about how many Scum there are likely to be.
In post 3359, MathBlade wrote:In post 3358, SilverWolf wrote:In post 3356, MathBlade wrote:In post 3353, SilverWolf wrote:In post 3352, MathBlade wrote:Hint: It is protown to lynch me. Please do so now.
OK, mathblade is officially weird this game.
Nooooooooo I'm not weird....not at all. Oh and ABR is town and I'm town. But I promise that things will make sense. I'd probably be your best lynch today as then I can explain why certain people are conf town. Please lynch the MathBlade
Really?
Really. Lynch me.
In post 3361, Kitz wrote:In post 3358, SilverWolf wrote:Really?
... Focus on someone else than MethBlade.
In post 3370, Kitz wrote:In post 3365, MathBlade wrote:Kitz I'm MathBlade not MethBlade.
I don't see a calculative person.
I see a person high on meth.
Figured MethBlade was more appropriate to your play.
In post 3365, MathBlade wrote:UNVOTE: I reserve the right to hammer myself
Kitz I'm MathBlade not MethBlade.
@SilverWolf -- It will help all town Scum would hate me.
In post 3374, goodmorning wrote:
In post 3343, SilverWolf wrote:Why is almost everyone on your list a scumread?
He's got like 5.5 out of what, 17? 18?
That's about how many Scum there are likely to be.
In post 3369, MathBlade wrote:If this town can't lynch claimed scum it deserves to lose.
I CLAIM I AM A SCUMFUCK!
In post 3379, goodmorning wrote:In post 3375, SilverWolf wrote:But I may actually of had a reason for asking Aero that question......................................how do you know it was non-essential and odd to me.
I knew it was non-essential because it was based on a false premise, and I felt that it was odd because it was based on a false premise.
I might of wanted further clarification on his reads since just about everyone is null or scum and his FA townread/considering he says FA is under the radar seemed weird to me.
Then surely you would ask him to clarify his reads, rather than asking why he had so many scumreads, since the answer to the latter would surely be "I don't."
In post 3380, Aeronaut wrote:In post 3378, SilverWolf wrote:Aero-I asked the question for the reason I stated in my quote.
Yea, I'm not satisfied with that answer, really. Why wouldn't you just ask me to clarify my reads instead of asking me a different question altogether, one that was based on a false statement?
And, to be honest, no, not everyone is null or scum in that pile. I also have 4-5 town reads there. So you'restillmaking things up.
P-edit: yea, that.
In post 3383, Aeronaut wrote:
What answers have you gotten?
Because I did not elaborate on FA, yet. And that's what you asked me. So in reality, you've gotten no answers, you just sort of want to end this before you make too much of a scene?
In post 3384, Aeronaut wrote:.how do you know it was non-essential and odd to me. I might of wanted further clarification on his reads since just about everyone is null or scum and his FA townread/considering he says FA is under the radar seemed weird to me.
But, to answer this.
The part about everyone being either null or scum is false, so I don't really know what to tell you. It says town next to like five people's names.