Kidney Mafia (Game Over)

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

i think town will be the winning faction of this game whom agrees

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

I don't tr pork, but Game actually can't be town.

i think this is a good actually

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

yeah i believe the word order is different in those two phrases

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

"actually can't be town" feels more like reminding oneself than making a claim

like "i'm thinking but that there are all these scum people whereas gr is the one who actually can't be town"

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

uzi why do you hate intimacy

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

Spoiler:

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

lycanfire is

B

E

Y

O

N

D

O

K

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

i hate the fact that this game won't break any post records because we are going to lynch all the scum too quickly

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

i dont entirely understand why we're not lynching GR with the cc going on now

also sorry @grapes and @myself for conking out as soon as i got home lmao - definitely going to post an rb/vedith case when im home tho

probably will move my vote then arcade pals otherwise is a gr9 lynch

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

i'm not sold on arcade scum and this wagon seems shifty af

discredit discredit discredit

hey, look.

no

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

nvm ill vote arcade lol

(extremely emperor voice) goooooood

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

We were a fucking 2 shot ninja pt checker zzzz w/e
~Maria

wwwwwat

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

hahahahahahahahah

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

uhh I already claimed vt appendix

sk?

Why is there another counterwagon to Arcade Pals[...]

i don't get how posts like this can happen and then people go on to not lynch that person

Spoiler:

sorry i think i need someone to interpret this 4 me

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

multiple balls would make a lot of sense actually, bins is talking truthy words

i feel like if the flavor suggests the body is male that would be meaningful

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

i'm okay with zachary being town of late

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

Spoiler:

yeah seriously why

narna's claim wasnt sus

i mean could be lying, but still would be a town move
narnas reaction to the claim was like "im ok with this and you should be too! ..nvm conf scum"
so yeah

baby with the bathwater i think

Spoiler:

decently town:

peregrine

, narna, torgonitoh

PeregrineV - too active for D1 for townPerV,

yet his frequency is resonating at OBVTOWN

PeregrineV- town

he's like a lovable buffoon

can i request a zoom in and enhance on the colory cobwebby block thing

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

Spoiler:

yeah seriously why

narna's claim wasnt sus

i mean could be lying, but still would be a town move
narnas reaction to the claim was like "im ok with this and you should be too! ..nvm conf scum"
so yeah

baby with the bathwater i think

or wait bathwater with the baby, or something

i thought "haha i just called bins a baby" but then i realized that it didn't make sense

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

oic it's a stack of player ISOs

you're saying they randomly included something from their partner because partner?

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

you do sr both p5 and the pig, yes?

also i am talking to hiplop rn, yes?

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

where r u getting bath water

the faucet in my bath

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

wait fock i mixed up the hydras

chamber

there are two different art styles i think and chamber is the one that is talking about porkens

is that suggesting that porkens and pv5 are different balls of scum?

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

except cheeto is the one talking rn

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

multiball

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

different balls for different pauls

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

Why aren't you worried that they're speculating that they're on different teams without flips?

because i am also doing that a little bit

We caught u lol

Hang on. I know exactly how to deal with this.

Spoiler:

+

that's my favorite snoop dog song

Why aren't you worried that they're speculating that they're on different teams without flips?

you read them as different teams?

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

you read them as different teams?

o

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

Don't bring up the claim.

the claim,

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

I GOT IT CHEETO IT MADE SENSE TO MEEEeeeeEEEEeee

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

i strongly desire cheeto to stay in this game because i think it's fun

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

fucking hieroglyphs

that reminds me i should clear my history at some point

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

hey transnecd i have a meta townerad on you

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

mmm tasty tasty year old meta

i miss cheeto this new guy is weird and angry and i want to do him a favor and Wizards of the Coast him

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

meme

gig is somewhat out of commission but will be back later

i have sorta been reading, from what i can tell it seems like we have walked in circles a lot and little uzi vert has climbed to almost the top of the post count ometer

this has summarily stopped being interesting

cordially,

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

i personally think that referring to things that aren't abortions as abortions is something one ought strive not to do

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

you are also telling me to vote either you or the dude with the most votes

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

yikes

i wonder if this is the first time 2 people from the same game get b&

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

yikes

i wonder if this is the first time 2 people from the same game get b&

s

they were both doc claims lel

Another obvious example of scum theatre.

u wot

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

meeeehh VOTE: game replacement

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

@tipfkipf personality changes over the course of a game have always been from scum in my experience so

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

I said I'm gonna hammer anyone but Game lol

because fuck me if i'm gonna go back and find it, why was that?

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

Town read rb and doc claim

meh

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

do people think arcade pals is town now?

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

ooh luv doesn't i'm a fan

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

idk they claimed something that said ninja in it and didn't get hammered so i dunno if that's happening but i'm def up

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

VOTE: arcade pals

the nk and the GR wagon comp makes me feel like scum are in the dark so i'd much rather lynch off wagon despite the lack of a cw

schadd is also starting to lean towards carcalilly town so it's plausible it's a mostly town wagon - im not too sure myself

raybells vecna and trans are locktown, toro and lycan are close

more after work - sorry for dying for basically a week

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

i missed the post??

UNVOTE:

i kind of doubt it but fine lets hear it

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

hello folks i would like to announce a fake inno on a certain...

(checks fake slip of paper)

radiantcowbells. thank you everyone for your time

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

to apply please use the password. god bless

i think i know wot it is but my partner just did the opposite of it

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

is there some sort of stones lyric i could use instead? because meta clique is now my top priority since i announced my fake night result already

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

mr. cowb do u have any connections in this club?

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

game still sucks tbh

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

this game has had like 0 cuddling

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

Gonkbadoop policy shooting me is rude when I asked not to be shot

o sorry

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

oh right i forgot scum is supposed to tell the truth and town is supposed to lie

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

don't like

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

see i told u my inno was fake

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

idk about gig but i'm obvtown m8 sorry

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

how so

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

bork brork

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

no

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

i lack charisma?

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

i'm taking a different thing

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

elaborate

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

ok i keep thinking i have the mental fortitude for this but i really dont

btw i didnt realize trans outted the fact he roleswapped which ive been well aware of that since like d1 and wanted to take the bullet but thought the way i handled rb's claim kind of would have made it too obvious that i didnt have a cc so :/ - meaningless but as scum i would probably have shot there and the fact that i was well aware this was occurring should be obvious from my iso

i wanted to take a week long vla and have schadd man the hydra but i dont really want to do that without giving some stance of my own since i havent had the chance to compile my thoughts in a long time. but not having time for mafia also means not having time for real life and i really need to sort myself out rn. idk

i dont really see what was really terrible about the one post i made this dp tbh? im not really going to harp about it though

looking at the playerlist though i feel like we're working with a really tight POE right now - hebi, lycan, gerry, pv, hopkirk, toroginitoh, trans, raybells, vecna, and grapes all seem like really horrible lynches to me at the present so im trying to work from that but every time i read i just feel lost in things like the claims

like? claims alone slysly's role and AP's role dont really make sense to me. with the survivor claim and the masonry i think it makes perfect sense for scum to have some way of figuring out the masonry, and slysly's role cant do that as well as AP's. slysly, from an informed perspective, can basically only find survivors and gets false positives on the roles that scum would actually want to find (traitor, masons, ic i guess?), while ap is basically the opposite in that they can get an actual result on a mason (though it's the same as a survivor neighbor) and having the ninja passive lets them choose between not having to establish fake claims or getting towncred for claiming something unusual. i dont really understand why theres hesitancy to lynch here besides them being prs. i'd vote them rn but schadd thinks it's wasted effort and i guess i can respect that. the best compromise would probably to leash AP onto carcalilly or a future vt claim and work from there - maybe have slysly parity her against someone (not sure if the mechanical play here is to parity vs someone obvtown like transcend or vs someone who needs to be sorted)? i recognize i'm not really in a position to call any shots but im really not happy with where claims are and if im wrong and both ap and slysly are town then that means theres a lot we can get out of playing our cards right as a town.

anyway

VOTE: tpfkap

ive been looking through isos though and i think this is the right call - schadd hasnt gotten back to me though

i think it takes a very specific kind of... bad... to think that the transcend slot is still scum here or even insinuate that kraska/rb could be scum theatre. i dont know if it's me personally knowing the context of that drama but rb has a very strange and disgusting vendetta against kraska and has harassed her offsite - him thinking that kraska was "attacking" him or some shit is flat out wrong and the way he reacted to kraska's obvious counterclaim showed a very specific kind of scum detachment that doesnt make sense in theatre. had i had the chance to talk during d1 about this (irl not mafia reasons prevented me obv) this is what my GR case would have been - rb picking completely incorrect reasons people interact with him they way they have comes from not having the need to actually engage with the gamestate and understand people. this is besides the fact trans and kraska have both been playing to their town metas strongly and both are not very good at hiding their metas from me

tpfkap trying to reach ('doctor is a scum role in this setup') and keep trans in the lynchpool i feel is a scum thought process - most of her pushes as well seem like very obviously not-mafia slots to me. im also having a hard time following some of the reasoning behind the scumreads and how they actually translate to scumreads - like my slot's, for example.

He manipulated you into claiming your flavor between day 1 and day 20 (a few hours?)
Gonk buddied up to you right away by following your vote on hebi.
Gonk jumped in to defend you against Arcade's meta case.
Gonk continued to defend you and sheeped.
After you had softclaimed twice, suddenly gonk starts praising Arcade.
Then, after you and hebi agreed to a Lycanfire wagon, gonk suggested you flavor claim.
Arcade agreed.
You said no.
Arcade says "dunn here",
and gonk votes for you and shoots smilies at Arcade.
gonk says there is no reason not to claim, and you do.

like im struggling to see how this warrants... any sort of read?

you could argue that my thought process was inconsistent or something (i dont really like the insinuation i defended zach but then attacked him?? i wanted dunn to substantiate his thought process because having played with zach i saw zero reason to make that sort of meta call on him, then zach started to act weird when i asked him to flavor claim so i scumread him...), but that sort of call is never made. instead the scumminess of my slot comes from me pressuring a miller to claim flavor which is???? not scummy? like it's one thing to randomly pressure someone to claim a role but it's fucking flavor - all it does is check the validity of a claim (and kidney didnt make sense to me as a miller). there isnt any follow through to actually substantiate why any of this is scummy. it's surface level thinking.

i dont really care about the pr claim. it's bullshit i've seen from scum plenty of times and have zero qualms pressuring there if the person is going to play like a scumfuck

if schadd disagrees with me then he's free to move my vote but this is where i'm at. PW/spiffeh could also use resolution at some point - i think schadd and i are at odds (i'm liking spiffeh less and have been ok with the last posts in PW's iso) so i'd rather have us converse about that first though.

anyway,

@mods giga head is going to be v/la for like the next week. again i just need to sort myself out and i really dont have the time for mafia anymore and worrying about getting prodded/not contributing enough is starting to affect my mental health. schadd will take over while i try to sort my shit out and get back on my feet again

if raybells or vecna or trans are on in the next half hour or so we can talk, i realize i havent been pulling the weight i know i can and i dont really mind you think i'm scum as a result because my head is not entirely in the game like it has been during all of my scum games on this site besides my first but that's a really shitty tell for me if that's what you're reading into.

pedit:

but carca is prob bad town. now if we could get more bin votes. that would be swell

i've been coming around on carca!town but i dont really have an issue with bins - can you like sparknotes her for me

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

Hi giggles <3

hi sorry i got sidetracked but im here

I'll stay off the kfap lynch tyvm

what am i missing about her then

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

I personally think they're just newbie town but they're dangerously bad

i dont get that impression at all

like what actual newbie signs up for a large normal before other games and actually seems like they know how to play mafia?

like shiqf kind of just died - tpfkap actually feels like they know what theyre doing and it's deliberate to me

so my perspective on recent claims revised

arcade pals' role makes less sense as a town role. it's a ninja which is negative utility, but their willingness to lynch their guilty is more or less proof that they can deliver some kind of result either as their action or through faction. i don't think this is a bus as the would be bussing slot is somehow still worse than the busee (hebichan slot= )

onto it and further it can check for the two claimed groups which are claiming to be anti mafia.

meanwhile slysly cannot tell the difference between mason, survivor, or what RC is floating around, traitors. this role makes less sense as a scum role as it cannot discern what is a threat or benefit to their faction. the only exception is if this were to be multiball, which the singular kill is suggesting against. there's a slim possibility that slysly, hebi and peregrine are all attempting to wear their pants as hats atm but i think three scum outing day 2 to save one shit slot is eternity-mocking level play so i'm going to run with other ideas for the time being.

back to RC. i don't see the need to lynch a survivor claim today and would prefer to grow consensus on the confscum arcade pals slot.

rosa seems to feel the same way but i find it curious that they say schadd is not on board when i feel like schadd has been a decent patron between the two days of the arcade pals within rope cause. the instant belief in the survivor aside, what gives?

he agrees that ap is scum but doesnt think it's going to get traction and fighting for it is probably not worthwhile when theres probably 3 other scum slots

Hi giggles <3

hi sorry i got sidetracked but im here

Clarify read on mariastral

doesnt feel like town dunn - i know i made this same mistake with the dance game but i feel fairly confident that dunn and maria are smart enough people to recognize a cc like trans/rb (esp considering mountainish mafia) and maria trying to push on trans felt like a really out of place move as a result. that and just... i'm not really sure what sorting dunn has done. it still feels like all posture and snippiness to me

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

es probably 3 other scum slots

*2 other scum slots, 3 total left

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

schadd is deliberately not telling me the password

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

also i see zero reason to doubt a survivor claim from the canit slot lmao?

i'm certain it's not scum (or scum with rb rather) so idrc if he's town fakeclaiming or telling the truth.

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

also i see zero reason to doubt a survivor claim from the canit slot lmao?

i'm certain it's not scum (or scum with rb rather) so idrc if he's town fakeclaiming or telling the truth.

okay fine i just wanted it on record that you super duper believe RC so i can lynch you if your slot ever utters the word multiball

why would it be multiball if gr's flip just said he was mafia

usually theres some indication (like X mafia or something unrelated to traditional mafia) that theres another team but the only possibility of like a werewolf team or something makes any sense but i have zero clue what that would have to do with flavor. singleball with survivors makes more sense to me atm

pedit: same gerry

also raybells if thats the case why are you still voting for me lmao

Lycan, here's what I'm going to do. I am going to keep giving my "shotty" reads and play the way I feel I should.

However, I acknowledge that I may be unable to read this game because of all the lying. The only thing I can see right now is narna slot is trying really Fucking hard to protect hebi, while RC and Trans are striking a scum/ind deal.

Ignoring all that, the scummiest player to me would be grapes.


Now that I've got the shit reads out, here's what I'm gonna do, campfire. I'm gonna sheep you until you decide it's time for me to swing or you turn out scum. I think you are town, though, and I need someone to lean on.

I'll full claim if you want me to, but my opinion is it would be better to not.

Vote: arcade pals

how about instead of lazily sheeping people you supposedly scumread you actually substantiate your controversial reads

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

can you sparknotes bins for me gerry i dont really see anything wrong with her and iirc schadd thinks shes town

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

Not sure why Giga scum reads me? Lol

?

i dont have a read on you like whatsoever

where did you get this

Bins is also mega scum imo.

not sure if i would go that far but bins has refused to town up all game and is very much a bad man.

yeah i agree shes a bad man

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

You seem to imply to Gerry that you don't get Bins but get me.

Gerry scum reads me.

ah ok that makes sense - not the case though

he's pushing bins harder though and i already asked for bins first. if he ignores me the first time why ask for more

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

Giggles persuade me

on what

What's your bins read and your confidence in it

who is this referring to btw

this too??

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

Luv is a bad man.
This is known.
Another shit read of mine.

can you stop this

i want follow through from you. "whys". i'm seeing the big picture but i'm not seeing the details that make me think you have a thought process or even understand what it is to be scummy despite the fact you seem to know how to actually play mafia

PS GONK so far I'm batting 1000 on the doctor is mafia foolproof shush?

i think this is how statistics work

can you sparknotes bins for me gerry i dont really see anything wrong with her and iirc schadd thinks shes town

for one she hard protected mafia doc for little to no reason.

so did arcade pals - why is she different or worse?

pedit: do i have to make a charisma roll or something

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

pedit: do i have to make a charisma roll or something

whats my CHA mod

pedit: i love you raybells..................

......

................../

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

Don't forget Radient and Spiffeh are scum together.

/shitreads

are you just calling everyone scum at this point

Also I been randomly screaming "Hebi!" since the claim.

Help..

Hebi

also the claim ~was believable~ the way rb claimed made it like 99.9% certain he was really a doctor


like he wasn't not going to flip doc

i mean i thought the softcc was extremely obvious but i think townreading him is a completely understandable position since i was there so?

pedit: do i have to make a charisma roll or something

whats my CHA mod

pedit: i love you raybells..................

......

................../

!!!!!!!!!

Who can I vote for you?

im on tpfkap so like naturally thats what im going to ask for but if you look at my list from my wall im fine voting anyone thats not there (although im not really crazy about carcalilly or bins votes off the top of my head - or pw but ~dissonance~). id prefer it if you didnt just aimlessly sheep me though unless you're trying to see where im going with my vote

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

i feel like i actively cannot post LMFAO or my brain is just moving at 20% of its normal speed rn

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

No I'm not calling everyone in the game dummy. No, I'm not calling only the people who call me crummy crummy.

I am finding it hard to believe that you have understood what I have written, either willfully or as a deficit in reading comprehension.

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

people who think it's multiball: show your work

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

nice quote tags raybells

/slammed

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

Why should I fight for your love when others give it freely

are you calling me cheap?

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

rosa seems to feel the same way but i find it curious that they say schadd is not on board when i feel like schadd has been a decent patron between the two days of the arcade pals within rope cause. the instant belief in the survivor aside, what gives?

they misunderstood something i said. arcade pals is a pretty vote i think

Spoiler:

ok i keep thinking i have the mental fortitude for this but i really dont

btw i didnt realize trans outted the fact he roleswapped which ive been well aware of that since like d1 and wanted to take the bullet but thought the way i handled rb's claim kind of would have made it too obvious that i didnt have a cc so :/ - meaningless but as scum i would probably have shot there and the fact that i was well aware this was occurring should be obvious from my iso

i wanted to take a week long vla and have schadd man the hydra but i dont really want to do that without giving some stance of my own since i havent had the chance to compile my thoughts in a long time. but not having time for mafia also means not having time for real life and i really need to sort myself out rn. idk

i dont really see what was really terrible about the one post i made this dp tbh? im not really going to harp about it though

looking at the playerlist though i feel like we're working with a really tight POE right now - hebi, lycan, gerry, pv, hopkirk, toroginitoh, trans, raybells, vecna, and grapes all seem like really horrible lynches to me at the present so im trying to work from that but every time i read i just feel lost in things like the claims

like? claims alone slysly's role and AP's role dont really make sense to me. with the survivor claim and the masonry i think it makes perfect sense for scum to have some way of figuring out the masonry, and slysly's role cant do that as well as AP's. slysly, from an informed perspective, can basically only find survivors and gets false positives on the roles that scum would actually want to find (traitor, masons, ic i guess?), while ap is basically the opposite in that they can get an actual result on a mason (though it's the same as a survivor neighbor) and having the ninja passive lets them choose between not having to establish fake claims or getting towncred for claiming something unusual. i dont really understand why theres hesitancy to lynch here besides them being prs. i'd vote them rn but schadd thinks it's wasted effort and i guess i can respect that. the best compromise would probably to leash AP onto carcalilly or a future vt claim and work from there - maybe have slysly parity her against someone (not sure if the mechanical play here is to parity vs someone obvtown like transcend or vs someone who needs to be sorted)? i recognize i'm not really in a position to call any shots but im really not happy with where claims are and if im wrong and both ap and slysly are town then that means theres a lot we can get out of playing our cards right as a town.

anyway

VOTE: tpfkap

ive been looking through isos though and i think this is the right call - schadd hasnt gotten back to me though

i think it takes a very specific kind of... bad... to think that the transcend slot is still scum here or even insinuate that kraska/rb could be scum theatre. i dont know if it's me personally knowing the context of that drama but rb has a very strange and disgusting vendetta against kraska and has harassed her offsite - him thinking that kraska was "attacking" him or some shit is flat out wrong and the way he reacted to kraska's obvious counterclaim showed a very specific kind of scum detachment that doesnt make sense in theatre. had i had the chance to talk during d1 about this (irl not mafia reasons prevented me obv) this is what my GR case would have been - rb picking completely incorrect reasons people interact with him they way they have comes from not having the need to actually engage with the gamestate and understand people. this is besides the fact trans and kraska have both been playing to their town metas strongly and both are not very good at hiding their metas from me

tpfkap trying to reach ('doctor is a scum role in this setup') and keep trans in the lynchpool i feel is a scum thought process - most of her pushes as well seem like very obviously not-mafia slots to me. im also having a hard time following some of the reasoning behind the scumreads and how they actually translate to scumreads - like my slot's, for example.

He manipulated you into claiming your flavor between day 1 and day 20 (a few hours?)
Gonk buddied up to you right away by following your vote on hebi.
Gonk jumped in to defend you against Arcade's meta case.
Gonk continued to defend you and sheeped.
After you had softclaimed twice, suddenly gonk starts praising Arcade.
Then, after you and hebi agreed to a Lycanfire wagon, gonk suggested you flavor claim.
Arcade agreed.
You said no.
Arcade says "dunn here",
and gonk votes for you and shoots smilies at Arcade.
gonk says there is no reason not to claim, and you do.

like im struggling to see how this warrants... any sort of read?

you could argue that my thought process was inconsistent or something (i dont really like the insinuation i defended zach but then attacked him?? i wanted dunn to substantiate his thought process because having played with zach i saw zero reason to make that sort of meta call on him, then zach started to act weird when i asked him to flavor claim so i scumread him...), but that sort of call is never made. instead the scumminess of my slot comes from me pressuring a miller to claim flavor which is???? not scummy? like it's one thing to randomly pressure someone to claim a role but it's fucking flavor - all it does is check the validity of a claim (and kidney didnt make sense to me as a miller). there isnt any follow through to actually substantiate why any of this is scummy. it's surface level thinking.

i dont really care about the pr claim. it's bullshit i've seen from scum plenty of times and have zero qualms pressuring there if the person is going to play like a scumfuck

if schadd disagrees with me then he's free to move my vote but this is where i'm at. PW/spiffeh could also use resolution at some point - i think schadd and i are at odds (i'm liking spiffeh less and have been ok with the last posts in PW's iso) so i'd rather have us converse about that first though.

anyway,

@mods giga head is going to be v/la for like the next week. again i just need to sort myself out and i really dont have the time for mafia anymore and worrying about getting prodded/not contributing enough is starting to affect my mental health. schadd will take over while i try to sort my shit out and get back on my feet again

if raybells or vecna or trans are on in the next half hour or so we can talk, i realize i havent been pulling the weight i know i can and i dont really mind you think i'm scum as a result because my head is not entirely in the game like it has been during all of my scum games on this site besides my first but that's a really shitty tell for me if that's what you're reading into.

pedit:

but carca is prob bad town. now if we could get more bin votes. that would be swell

i've been coming around on carca!town but i dont really have an issue with bins - can you like sparknotes her for me

tl;dr

yea same

Say you love me

look't this fuckin

schaddbait

over here

https://youtu.be/2PNCgxrh3L4?t=15s

https://youtu.be/4zLQ4ukqMec?t=52s

take u pick boy

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

Why should I believe the other doc claim?

more pertinent question is why does an alt!scum!doc cc or out when game replacement claims

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

over here

https://youtu.be/2PNCgxrh3L4?t=15s

https://youtu.be/4zLQ4ukqMec?t=52s

take u pick boy

fleetwood mac is more traditional schadd content imo

also in that case

VOTE: ap

people who think it's multiball: show your work

Just look at all the obvious clusters of scum players, they can't all be in the same group.

no

and we absolutely can and should lynch ap unless we're going to leash them to like cop carcalilly or something and then parity cop them and carca or something

people who think it's multiball: show your work

just seems like that type of game to me. plus RC already claimed 3rd party already, even tho the claim is prob BS. i still think there is a 3p or 2nd mafia team

what im concerned about tho is like flavor

why go through the effort of not saying red or blue mafia? why are there werewolves in this game? it feels unflavored but idk it's just not adding up to me

i would think that the closest we have to multiball is in fact 3p

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

weird multiball fetish

isn't this just called liking boys

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

weird multiball fetish

isn't this just called liking boys

s

ok i feel personally attacked i'll have you know that i

pedit: is that @me or what

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

fleetwood mac is more traditional schadd content imo

yes but soul is better for RC bonding

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

maybe raybells blitzed his chakras bins

honestly i agree the zach kill makes zero sense given the very obvious softcc so... there probably is shenanigans involved but raybells bsing wouldnt shock me either

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

get a room

no you

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

get a room

do we have another PT checker on our hands

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

stop looking for crumbs or i'll mathblade meme you

kraska was literally getting frustrated i didn't pick up on it at first LMFAO so..........

also it's getting late and i need to wake up early so if theres anything u need from me it has to ~wait~

toodles

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

hey RC have u been listening to that one KC and the sunshine band song called "hey baby let's screw passionately for a very long time"

because i have winky face

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

ok i want to share this sentence i just composed to gig on skype because i'm pleased with it

"so roody coopy decided luvvie is scuvvie"

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

seems p reasonable at a glance

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

THIS JUST IN: ROWDY COWBOY FINDS COOPY GROUPIE

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

what puts vecna in the not-uppest tier?

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

i.e. not town? narna roleswapped transcend to get rb/gr lynched which i think is preedy gud

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

narna was the one who primarily did that (before he got uhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh banned)

also yes i wouldn't wish having to read d1 of this game on anybody

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

e d d i e c a n e

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

just had a light blitz of chakras.

nothing worth mentioning

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

little susie voozie

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

They don't lol

As Bins said, you're the only player who can fake claim and then claim 3p and not be lynched immediately

i'm ninja ascetic simultaneous dayvig-and-neighborizer

wait nvm i'm sk

get at me booois

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

greetings compatriots

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

Sifting through hundreds of posts in a single iso sure is fun.

@Gonkadoop

let's talk about something. I've numbered this to keep things straight.

this feels like town!rb? i dont really get why he's the leading wagon atp and i also dont really like canit....

~giggles

1. You initially had a town read on rb.

yup. i (schadd) (not gig) did as well i believe

hey

i blitzed my chakras for a moment and realized i was an idiot

VOTE: rb

canit is town

thanks perev for enlightening me

2. You swap, sheeping PV.

dunno what exactly this is. i know that at some point later gig interprets transcend to be ccing rb but that hasn't happened yet here. in skype gig just said "i figured it out" and i assume it's just that they realize some artifact of rb faking his town self

i didnt connect the dots until perev posted that lol

3. Just including this to support why you swapped.

Alternately, rb is trying to appear as town, but it is a crude effort to do so.

it's this one

4. (ditto)

was about to unvote you from general reaction but ok

UNVOTE:

i think i want arcade pals but schadd needs to talk to me bc we disagree

5. Now an unvote but not really an explanation why. Why did you unvote here?

"unvote from general reaction" is part of the explanation: gig thought his reaction to his wagon was towny, see around 839 up to the claim. also, they townread the doc claim.

rb

i think you're town and that kraskas meta is objectively wrong here at least wrt your claiming and ate.

6. So it's not just an unvote but you've swapped to a town read. You've basically done a 180 on your read here, why?

see above. incidentally at this point, in skype, i said something along the lines of "angry rb is town rb afaik" (which is a perception rb would uhhhhh express some frustrations with later) "but he maybe shouldn't be angry here" and gig said there was some sort of context thing which made it seem town.

he's a pr claim and i townread him thats stupid

literally any other vote is better

7. Not just a townread but your top townread? Why?

i believe "any other vote is better" isn't the same as "top townread." they continued to townread him for the same reasons as earlier, and him being claimed doctor meant there is bigger risk associated with mislynching.

VOTE: rb

yeah ok

8. Um??

yea this is the point where gig figured out lasagne were ccing, they said as much in skype. 1016 is kraska trying to communicate it. note that we had lasagne locktown as of 689

i will VOTE: arcade pals with u but my bartner may prefer game replacement

s

9. Off of rb again because ???

this is me and not gig. i wasn't scumreading rb/gr as much, i think ap wagon had more potential at this point and i also wanted to commence an elaborate courtship ritual with lycan. hey i was right, also.

incidentally the fact that arcade being scum helps our case here is definitely not why we lurked for 3 day phases. nope, nosirree.

meeeehh VOTE: game replacement

10. Help

i believe this is me as well. gr wagon was about to ejaculate, we (still) scumread it, i voted, good job me!

it felt kinda weird to me that gr ended up being the widespread wagon of choice. uzi said at some point that d1s with an absurdly large post count rarely go well, it seemed like we had collectively vacillated between a few possible lynches and i figured that as soon as one stuck, it would probably be on town. but there was also compelling reason to suppose gr was scum.

You were all over the place on rb and were largely absent when GR came in. Can you talk about how your read changed on that slot over the course of day 1?

sure!

we were kind of all over the place but there were a lot of different informations and we are also two people.

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

so that's taken care of.

was there anything else we were supposed to do?

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

hopkirk is eh. pushed rb/gr and ap a bunch during d1 but then cooled off later.

do people townread vecna for a reason? narna was good but vecna's iso was limply defending gr => buncha ugly votes: hebi, uzi, spiffeh (who i still think is town), rc, pw, us, the gonkbadoop, all the while memeing/otherwise faux game content

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

VOTE: gonk

Red flip

thanks purple flip

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

Why did you imply Carca is an SK

there probably is one as far as i understand. i read her as sk d1 because she was stumbly wumbly as hell but there were a bunch of bad wagons on her

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

ya i guess i'm just a master of deduction

what else is new

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

faster*

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

waaah i wanted spiff to be town

but on looking back he has the same icky history as vecna

VOTE: spiffo l-2

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

What is that icky history?

selected works:

Transcend's handling of rb during his meltdown is scummy af

bzzt, distraction

Can someone explain what Arcade Pals did that was worthy of so many votes?

bzzt

VOTE: RadiantCowbells

lmao

see also his whole saga about trying to push him/get him to out lycan

My "people I could be convinced to lynch" pool is

{POWERFUL WARRIOR, grapes, Papa Zito (though I'd prefer not to rn given his situation), Hopkirk, gonkbadoop taskmaster, TPFKAP}

:= {bzzt, bzzt, i think bzzt, i think bzzt, bzzt, i think bzzt}

vote: arcade pals

Why?

You were calling for my head all Day yesterday, what makes you vote for AP instead?

another distraction

Why did you want Spiffeh to be town?

i was smitten with him early on because i also scumread hebi and also he was a lovable curmudgeon that cared about stuff (however very much of this stuff has proven to be unrelated to finding reddos)

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

Spoiler:

What is that icky history?

selected works:

Transcend's handling of rb during his meltdown is scummy af

bzzt, distraction

Can someone explain what Arcade Pals did that was worthy of so many votes?

bzzt

VOTE: RadiantCowbells

lmao

see also his whole saga about trying to push him/get him to out lycan

My "people I could be convinced to lynch" pool is

{POWERFUL WARRIOR, grapes, Papa Zito (though I'd prefer not to rn given his situation), Hopkirk, gonkbadoop taskmaster, TPFKAP}

:= {bzzt, bzzt, i think bzzt, i think bzzt, bzzt, i think bzzt}

vote: arcade pals

Why?

You were calling for my head all Day yesterday, what makes you vote for AP instead?

another distraction

Why did you want Spiffeh to be town?

i was smitten with him early on because i also scumread hebi and also he was a lovable curmudgeon that cared about stuff (however very much of this stuff has proven to be unrelated to finding reddos)

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

Spoiler:

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

hey can u vote spiffeh for a second i want 2 try something

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

rando realization

narna was good

uhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh don't take this the wrong way

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

georgie floats

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

prob almost as much as raybie wants his bus

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

https://youtu.be/vAHBWXlVL88?t=1m25s

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

get a room

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

i think people being in the same "faction" but having a different wincon is bastard

i mean i've seen it a time and that was a bastard game

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

It is more than bastard yes.

it was mini theme 1916 where one of the four scum out of 13 was also a jester i.e. he had to be lynched and scum had to win for him to win

which now that i think about it just sucked for that guy

s

i think people being in the same "faction" but having a different wincon is bastard

i mean i've seen it a time and that was a bastard game

s

I don't think they were in the same faction.

read this

Lycanfire died on Night 3!
It was:

Spoiler: Lycanfire

Welcome to Kidney Mafia, Lycanfire!

You are MarioManiac4, a KIDNEY Ascetic Tracker, aligned with the

KIDNEY.

You have the ability to use your vote and voice during the Day.
During the Night phase, you may track a player. You will learn who, if anyone, that player visited that Night.
You are also Ascetic; any non-killing actions that target you will fail.

You are aligned with the KIDNEY, and know [redacted] to also be aligned with the KIDNEY. The [redacted] of you may communicate here at any time; [redacted]

You win when another faction has reached its win condition and at least one member of the KIDNEY is alive.

lycan had at least 1 partner, presumably exactly 1. lycan said "my partner is radiantcowbells." rc knew the exact specifications of the faction well before lycan claimed this. you are supposing that lycan lied, that another unclaimed partner exists and that somehow rc was able to communicate with them? and that there is otherwise reason to believe he is sk?

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

Does that wording guarantee a partner?

it would be weird if there weren't a partner. first of all, survivor is typically balanced (well. ""balanced"") in a 13ish player game, since you can expect somewhere around half of the people in it to die. in larger games, like 22p, maybe like 2/3 to 3/4 of the people will die (super rough, but it's definitely a larger proportion) and so having 2 people sorta offsets that (and by the same token i wouldn't expect it to be more than 2)

also, like, the mod doesn't put "you know 0 other people are also in this faction"

Why were lycan and zach both "kidney" ? Why was zach miller AND IC?

Maybe not sk, maybe a two person ind. team with a nightkill.

that doesn't make rc a serial killer, like, at all. SK wants everyone to be dead and we need to lynch them to win, survivor with a shot just wants to be alive at endgame, and doesn't have considerably much motive to shoot people.

fwiw rc as survivor with a shot would have shot the pig at some point. i would put fat stacks on that

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

thread lock, light of my life, fire of my loins. my sin, my soul.

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

between the lions, between the covers of a book, it's time to look between the lions. behold the tales behind the tails, behind the door, become, explore

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

can that be on spotify please

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

oh fuck me. they never are

i had to wait a million fucking years for the starcraft 1 soundtrack

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

hey, hello. greetings. i'm schadd, a bitch ass white boy that will probably do my laundry at 3am because i don't want anyone to be within 100 feet of me when i struggle to figure it out and fuck everything up.

nice to meet you.

Lycan is fine as fuck.

same

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

MUFFY CROSSWIRE

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

bins can you tell me what specifically made you tr narna

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

I'm ngl

wowee i guess i have to lynch obvtown over u in endgame then

Gonk I townread narna slot bc of their d1 play with the doc claim + transcend


Tbh that's not a strong reason I realize
Narna could probably pull that off as scum
More from Vecna

But hey that haven't jumped on my wagon yet so pts

narna noticed transcend ccing rb and pushed rb for it
we also did that (narna did in a somewhat more extreme way but still)
vecna hasn't joined your wagon
we also haven't (i've been townreading you since d1 infact )

what gives my dude

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

i was okay at reading zachary n=1

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

hey, hello. greetings. i'm schadd, a bitch ass white boy that will probably do my laundry at 3am because i don't want anyone to be within 100 feet of me when i struggle to figure it out and fuck everything up.

nice to meet you.

i finally did it, compatriots

no one else was there

there was a guy leaving right when i got there. i looked at his eyes but he didn't look at my eyes. he didn't need to, his job was done

VOTE: vecna

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

Ooooh wait gigabyte is part of this slot! Giga, can you reign in your puppy, he's clawing and biting at my toes. While adorable, id prefer to keep my slippers drool-free

they ain't been around since 4632 and they ain't comin back soon

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

rawr teehee X3

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

honestly just lynch me if hop / gonk arent' scum

no

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

like can you please explain to me how you can shrug off vecna because narna pushed gr d1 but you're confident that two people that pushed gr and ap are scum

you seemed interested in sorting me at the beginning of the game and now you're calling me scum and ignoring me and it's making me sadd

we're not miller, i uh don't suppose we have anything else that could otherwise give an incriminating impression

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

in other news here is a scumgame of mine that just ended wherein i have 48 posts over the course of 7 days in a large viewtopic.php?f=3&t=72727

this game was the first after a streak of 4 (1 offsite) where i rolled town and in my imo opinion it kind of shows

vecna's play doesn't read as scum who replaced into this game in narnas slot

what would you expect from scum there? his first thing was defending gr and he has since such claimed was insincere

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

he has since claimed such was insincere

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

cowbie, just out of curiosity, did u scumread me for suggesting it was multiball

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

if i were more confident of a boi i would be calling bins obvtown supreme rn

s

[gonkbadoop taskmaster]

i was her partner in a micro one time

she lurked through a big chunk of it and was otherwise not really an actor

suffice to say that weaving an elaborate lie in real time and arguing about it seems like not her thing to me

s