I told you, we're the same kinda person, we view mafia games as a chance to finally be an anime protagonist and save the world etc, so it wouldn't surprise me if we also shared the same insecurities about guys finding us batshit insane if they ever actually sat down and read anything I post on this site lmao
Post
Post #1210 (isolation #214) » Thu May 30, 2019 12:18 pm
Postby nomnomnom »
In post 1142, MaryJoLisa wrote:@Nomnom, what pronouns do you use? I'm seeing people use both.
In post 3, nomnomnom wrote:[...]you can use either he or she with me, and consider me like a girl or a guy, I don't really care. [...]Only thing I ask is that I'd rather you don't use "they" to refer to me, I frankly don't like it
Post
Post #1216 (isolation #215) » Thu May 30, 2019 12:25 pm
Postby nomnomnom »
If he is scum and that you actually are masons, implying this townread reduces the PoE quite substantially and puts the bottleneck on him. So why would he do that?
If we consider 3 scum teams... Skitter + Cheeky + TDC is a possibility and that would explain SOME things, but not some others.
Post
Post #1219 (isolation #216) » Thu May 30, 2019 12:26 pm
Postby nomnomnom »
No, here's the thing. The game should be progressing with 2 masons claimed and a miller yet we are at a stalemate and this isn't somehow auto, so I am a bit confused here.
In post 1216, nomnomnom wrote:If he is scum and that you actually are masons, implying this townread reduces the PoE quite substantially and puts the bottleneck on him. So why would he do that?
If we consider 3 scum teams... Skitter + Cheeky + TDC is a possibility and that would explain SOME things, but not some others.
and you're complaining about me not seeing that the game is on auto
i'd bet the game on there not being 3 scum in a micro
(micro normal no less!)
In post 1219, nomnomnom wrote:No, here's the thing. The game should be progressing with 2 masons claimed and a miller yet we are at a stalemate and this isn't somehow auto, so I am a bit confused here.
i don't think it's *auto* - from my pov there's 2 scum in 7 people
incidentally i'm strongly townreading two of these people, so 2 scum in 5 people
that's not auto for day1 in a micro
TDC and MJL are your townreads, right?
Is the rest really that muddled?
Post
Post #1230 (isolation #220) » Thu May 30, 2019 12:34 pm
Postby nomnomnom »
Like, again, unless I'm really fucking dumb, scums should never win here. If you guys are masons they are restricted to horrendous night kill options and they have to bank on town collectively fucking up.
Post
Post #1234 (isolation #221) » Thu May 30, 2019 12:37 pm
Postby nomnomnom »
In post 1232, skitter30 wrote:well the reason why i didn't care about claiming either way is because in this pl i'm a p good nk option for scum even without the claim; i don't think i make lylo here either way
If you are a claimed mason you are virtually un-killable though? Especially in the context of a micro?
Post
Post #1242 (isolation #224) » Thu May 30, 2019 12:41 pm
Postby nomnomnom »
I doubt scum!blake goes forward and goes out of her way to clear me through meta in a situation like this either, so I believe it's as simple as going Saud/LUV/Creature/TDC
Post
Post #1247 (isolation #226) » Thu May 30, 2019 12:46 pm
Postby nomnomnom »
If you don't make it to endgame we can safely go forward without this mason paranoia. That's pretty good.
Also the logical part is to see that scum!blake reducing the lynchpool by townreading me and giving you a strong reason to do is highly unlikely. I think she's town and that at this point paranoia and lack of sleep got in the way.
That, or again, you guys fucked up massively. Lying masons will come apparent later down the road if this is what's happening, but for now? This is pretty much auto.
Post
Post #1254 (isolation #230) » Thu May 30, 2019 12:53 pm
Postby nomnomnom »
In post 1251, skitter30 wrote:like i'd want nomnom/blake (and cheeky while she's around) to keep things on track but i'm slightly nervous i'm getting duped somewhere
The only scenario where that is happening is if Blake and me are SvS. The moment you see this is impossible is the moment you realize this game is literally auto, and that's why I've been confused for a while.
Post
Post #1259 (isolation #232) » Thu May 30, 2019 1:00 pm
Postby nomnomnom »
In post 1257, skitter30 wrote:i guess i'm imagining a universe where it's like ... idk nom/saudade
and the game goes down as follows:
today we lynch creature
i die
day2 we lynch luv
cheeky dies
day3 we lynch saudade
i guess blake dies?
and then it's 3way tdc/nom/mjl which makes me nervous because while *i* think 2/3 of those people are town, i'm nervous that the people in lylo won't see it
but i guess that's a worst-case scenario
What's the worst case scenario if we lynch Saud first?
Post
Post #1262 (isolation #233) » Thu May 30, 2019 1:06 pm
Postby nomnomnom »
Also something to keep in mind is that if MJL actually reached F3 she's probably scum and we'll have a good conversation postgame about why you guys were so adamant to townread that slot
Post
Post #1266 (isolation #236) » Thu May 30, 2019 1:11 pm
Postby nomnomnom »
I just have a feeling that there's one thing missing from this puzzle and that's why we're still somewhat scared of going forward. Otherwise this is a formality.
In post 1257, skitter30 wrote:i guess i'm imagining a universe where it's like ... idk nom/saudade
and the game goes down as follows:
today we lynch creature
i die
day2 we lynch luv
cheeky dies
day3 we lynch saudade
i guess blake dies?
and then it's 3way tdc/nom/mjl which makes me nervous because while *i* think 2/3 of those people are town, i'm nervous that the people in lylo won't see it
but i guess that's a worst-case scenario
What's the worst case scenario if we lynch Saud first?
well the fact that i'm scumreading other people (creature) more
Why does it matter since this is literally auto???
The order doesn't matter unless you are paranoid about one slot in particular. In that case it's actually better to lynch that slot first unless the worst case scenario is more catastrophic than the one where we lynch creature first.
Post
Post #1305 (isolation #252) » Thu May 30, 2019 2:02 pm
Postby nomnomnom »
In post 1304, Blake Belladonna wrote:I don't see how a massclaim would help me narrow down my reads more since I'm pretty sure it's just Creature + Lil Uzi Vert with maybe Saudade or MJL as a very low probability substitute.
But.
I CAN see scenarios where scum pull some bullshit out of their ass and people get fooled into shifting their reads again and suddenly the game isn't solved anymore.
Post
Post #1334 (isolation #260) » Sat Jun 01, 2019 5:13 pm
Postby nomnomnom »
Alright, they went with the masons.
Didn't want to lynch creature yesterday but I realized the town stubborness and was willing to take the compromise to get a better push today. I felt guilty for giving in when I knew that slot had low chances to be scum but eh, what can you do.
I want to lynch between Saudade and Blake today. Really should have lynched saud yesterday but what can you do.