Large Normal 211: Scientific Mafia

[Egg]

Page 7:
Pine, what exactly did TwoInAMillion and Inferno do that is hard to fake that makes them both town?

It's funny to see a few people believe a fake daykill. I like inferno for town now though. Gamma's reaction kind of sucked.

Page 8:
Firebringer why is Pine town? I wanna know why I'm dumb.

Page 9:
I agree with gamma that assuming scum in the neighborhood is bad play and we should be reading based on play instead.

Ah, Archwing ruined the reactions to the number of scum team speculation thing we had going here. I have inferno and theta as town from that.

Page 10:
Inferno, have you played well that's Flavorleaf/Boon before?

But I don't even know why it matters, since we've already confirmed one scum team. Seems odd to bring it up.

Yeah, I was aware that Assemble confirmed that, but hadn't seen archwings post. I was still trying to guage your thoughts on it.

Gamma, when did you decide on the change and is it just this game or do you plan on doing it in the future? What made you decide to do it? What did you get out of it?

Vote TwoInAMillion

[Gamma Emerald]

I will answer those questions later but I want some other people to come back and comment on things before I do. I intend for it to be a consistent thing if I like what I get out of it though.

[Theta Alpine]

oh so it is just you changing your meta
i though you were just trying a gambit with the rest of your neighborhood
but yeah a shift in meta could also explain it
either way i would have likely given it nai
it would be the reactions to what you are doing that i would look at more

[Egg]

I will answer those questions later but I want some other people to come back and comment on things before I do. I intend for it to be a consistent thing if I like what I get out of it though.

Works for me as long as the answers do eventually come.

[Inferno390]

Inferno, have you played well that's Flavorleaf/Boon before?

No, I in particular have not. However, I have read a game that he was in with my brother James Brafin, so while I don't have a real meta of him, I do have a slight feel for his play.

Players I have played with before include:
UC
Beef
NSG
LUV
Profii
Gamma

And there are others that I have read games with became James was in them, or interacted with them in some way onsite. Obviously, my meta on them is not nearly as good (and all my metas are shaky to begin with) but I have formed some general reads based on that.

[Gamma Emerald]

I don't recall playing with you, only James

[Flavor Leaf]

@Gamma - Answering to the Flubber question, I can see Flubber doing that as town, and for some reason I always town read Flubber. He’s one of the players I misread the most on site. But yes, it is very similar to that game.

@Egg - that’s just what Two does. He votes me. I’ve never played with scumTwo, I might have once, and I was inactive the majority of that game and he died before I was in really, but this is the same townTwo I always want to lynch.

[Firebringer]

Firebringer why is Pine town? I wanna know why I'm dumb.

Pretend I said some thought provoking and insightful here.

Real answer he just feels Town to me buddy

[RedFlavor]

Players I have played with before include:
UC
Beef
NSG
LUV
Profii
Gamma

K

[Pine]

Yeah Imma pass on those Egg questions. Dude is in hardcore confirmation bias.

Protip: Don't make a snap judgment then view all new evidence through the lens of the old assumption.

[Inferno390]

I don't recall playing with you, only James

We were in a game that replaced out of. One that was going on forever.

Players I have played with before include:
UC
Beef
NSG
LUV
Profii
Gamma

K

Red too. Sorry Red, didn't mean to make you feel left out!

[Gamma Emerald]

Oh I think I know which one and that's ongoing

[TwoInAMillion]

@Gamma - Answering to the Flubber question, I can see Flubber doing that as town, and for some reason I always town read Flubber. He’s one of the players I misread the most on site. But yes, it is very similar to that game.

@Egg - that’s just what Two does. He votes me. I’ve never played with scumTwo, I might have once, and I was inactive the majority of that game and he died before I was in really, but this is the same townTwo I always want to lynch.

You're not scumhunting. And you're not giving me a good reason not to vote you.

[Gamma Emerald]

@Gamma - Answering to the Flubber question, I can see Flubber doing that as town, and for some reason I always town read Flubber. He’s one of the players I misread the most on site. But yes, it is very similar to that game.

@Egg - that’s just what Two does. He votes me. I’ve never played with scumTwo, I might have once, and I was inactive the majority of that game and he died before I was in really, but this is the same townTwo I always want to lynch.

You're not scumhunting. And you're not giving me a good reason not to vote you.

The content of the quoted post and 2iam's response pings me. 2iam should know why, he shouts about it any time he gets pushed

[TwoInAMillion]

@Gamma - Answering to the Flubber question, I can see Flubber doing that as town, and for some reason I always town read Flubber. He’s one of the players I misread the most on site. But yes, it is very similar to that game.

@Egg - that’s just what Two does. He votes me. I’ve never played with scumTwo, I might have once, and I was inactive the majority of that game and he died before I was in really, but this is the same townTwo I always want to lynch.

You're not scumhunting. And you're not giving me a good reason not to vote you.

Which of your neighbors do you think are most likely to be scum besides you?

[Inferno390]

Yeah, I'm still getting some forced vibes from TIAM. Still think his neighborhood push was bad too. Could SK hunting for scum be a possibility? Or perhaps the neighborhood is all town after all. Not sure either way, but it's something to think about.

[Nosferatu]

Vote TwoInAMillion

why

[Inferno390]

I'm getting some town feeling from Egg right now. His reads seem pretty genuine, and original too: They're completely his own, which I like.
Startingto lean town on Pine too a little bit. @Pine, talk to me about Egg. I know you don't like the questions aimed at you, but what about the rest of his reads?

[Nosferatu]

No way are there fewer than 5 scum. Math better.

there can be 4 scum if there's an sk

anti-town can be less than a 3rd of the town

[Pine]

I'm getting some town feeling from Egg right now. His reads seem pretty genuine, and original too: They're completely his own, which I like.
Startingto lean town on Pine too a little bit. @Pine, talk to me about Egg. I know you don't like the questions aimed at you, but what about the rest of his reads?

Nah, Egg's fine. He's hunting, he's just sucking at it.

I'm proceeding on a multiball assumption, so scumhunting is mostly null. In other words, Egg is doing genuine work that has merit, he's just tunneling me wrong.

[Pine]

No way are there fewer than 5 scum. Math better.

there can be 4 scum if there's an sk

anti-town can be less than a 3rd of the town

Traditionally not, and this cleared Normal review. 14:6, 12:4:4, 13:3:3:1, 14:5:1 with scum power would be traditional.

[TwoInAMillion]

14:6 would be scumsided, reviewers have been pushing for more town sided setups recently.

[Theta Alpine]

I'm getting some town feeling from Egg right now. His reads seem pretty genuine, and original too: They're completely his own, which I like.
Startingto lean town on Pine too a little bit. @Pine, talk to me about Egg. I know you don't like the questions aimed at you, but what about the rest of his reads?

Nah, Egg's fine. He's hunting, he's just sucking at it.

I'm proceeding on a multiball assumption, so scumhunting is mostly null. In other words, Egg is doing genuine work that has merit, he's just tunneling me wrong.

so i guess you missed the post where assemble said this game does not have multiple scumteams

[Firebringer]

The op says “scum teams”
I think we cracked this conspiracy right open


I’ll ignore that the rule set was stolen and could easily be typo or other things.


My theory is solid

[Firebringer]

Also I am legit claiming right now.

I am a cop.

I will investigate one of luv, nsg or flavor tonight