Open 724 - Pick Your Power X/Y [Endgame]

[Katyusha]

ircher walk me through your thought process in that vote step by step

[Taly]

would anyone be shocked if ico+janitor were both scum

I will drop this though, from what I've looked into so far I'm pretty sure the scum team is Janitor, Saske slot and either Taly OR Ausuka. I will explain this and back up such a claim later during this day (day 3, nor irl) but if you want to discuss that instead of getting bored and complaining about the day not being over then feel free to do so :3

I'll discuss this during the night I guess when I get a chance.

@Katy
VOTE: Katy
So you think the scum team COULD be Ircher/Ausuka/Taly?

Um... am I misreading? Where's the post where you think

Katy

thinks this?

[Ircher]

look if you asked me to explain the inner machinations of simyk's mind i would die before i had the chance to utter a single word

that slot's never rb

But what about Goon? I could totally see that.....

[Katyusha]

yeah the team is probably ico/janitor/davesaz but why is your vote on me

[Ircher]

but yeah i dont really want to put in effort until we get a flip unless someone has a specific question for me

close-reading 100 or so pages when i know that there's one scum in janitor/ico and it's like janitor 70% of the time makes trifling between which of eddie/davesaz/ico/janitor/mutant seems pointless until i have that flip for certain

This isn't gonna fly by me.

[Katyusha]

ok? where do you want me to begin

i know the general events of the game but like i almost never read on replace in since i usually skim games live

[Ircher]

if you're scum you absolutely can and should lie about things like that lol

plus with a jk there's plausible deniability that you were actually rb'd by a doc/rb slot, at worst you bait out the only threatening slot besides jk/tracker to your team. plus if the rolecop investigated you that makes the 1v1 vs the doc claim 100% easier to win

@Taly, though they may have been responding to my first post but that isn't clear based on the content.

[Katyusha]

I was responding to your point on Iconeum

Iconeum, if scum!cop, should always claim roleblocked. Not doing so is stupid lmao

[Katyusha]

like i think it's fairly clear i'm talking about ico there?? you weren't jailkept

[Katyusha]

nor do you have reason to claim you were

[Ircher]

Well, it sounds like you are refuting something I made rather than agreeing.

My vote isn't moving for the time being for vc purposes, but while I don't have a concrete case for you being scum, it makes the most sense imo between PoE and the way SIMYK played the game.

[Katyusha]

OK, why do you think Simyk played the game like scum? I townread them before replacing in so I'd like to hear your reasoning

[Ircher]

ok? where do you want me to begin

i know the general events of the game but like i almost never read on replace in since i usually skim games live

I'm just saying you must read the game and provide those reads for everyone to know. Include some details as well, that always helps.

Pedit: Deep!wolfing basically. Trying to get in town's good graces by looking *too townie*. PoE plays the bigger role in my read, and I meant I didn't really have a concrete case for your slot being scum atm; it is about 70% PoE, 25% Gut, and 5% Facts/Ideas.

[Katyusha]

i mean what reads do you want me to expand on

you're mechanically town
ausuka is comedically out of her scumrange
taly's ate is extremely genuine and i dont think he's the type of scum player to fake that

it doesn't matter what i think of ico/janitor since literally one of them has to be scum here

i think eddie is within his scumrange but he's not a top pick for scum. i liked simyk's case on a50 early on in the game and do believe that's a legit reason to scumread someone and kind of sympathized with her bc the same thing happened to me with Alban in 675 basically (scumread someone for same reasons, literally no one wanted to lynch them despite being obvious scum. i dont really have the same strength simyk did/does but yeah), i think mutant trying to solve the game mechanically is probably coming from a genuine perspective

lynch order theoretically is probably janitor > ico > davesaz > eddie > mutant. no one else is worth considering

deepwolfing isnt really a real reason to suspect someone but poe does mean something. why are you clearing davesaz?

[Ircher]

Davesaz isn't vindicated by Almost50 whom he replaced.

Thoughts on davesaz, mutant, taly, and ausuka is what I want.

[Ircher]

*is not isnt

[mutantdevle]

mutant, any opinion on puppies?

I like puppies :3

[mutantdevle]

I will drop this though, from what I've looked into so far I'm pretty sure the scum team is Janitor, Saske slot and either Taly OR Ausuka. I will explain this and back up such a claim later during this day (day 3, nor irl) but if you want to discuss that instead of getting bored and complaining about the day not being over then feel free to do so :3

I'll discuss this during the night I guess when I get a chance.

Yeah, interrogate those 2 for me :3

Make 'em slip.

[mutantdevle]

I'm glad we have this replacement so that y'all have something to talk about.

It's midnight and I've just finished the programming side of my coursework (though still testing for bugs). So I'm going to sleep now which means sadly I haven't got anything new done towards this game.

However, I will make progress here before I resume my coursework tomorrow to make up for it.

[Katyusha]

Davesaz is vindicated by Almost50 whom he replaced.

Thoughts on davesaz, mutant, taly, and ausuka is what I want.

davesaz is lacking some of his inquisitiveness i usually see from town him, I used to have a pretty good handle of his meta and could read him off of even like 2 posts. i'm getting a mixed read from his posts alone since i'm not sure how much of it is rl impacting him but lack of townieness in this gamestate is enough for a scumread on my part. I don't think A50's blowup was at all genuine, like I think he legitimately dislikes and blacklisted whoever he thinks simyk is and would replace out either way, but nothing about their exchange made any sense and i wouldn't townread a50 from it ever. the lolclaim is something scum!A50 would definitely do, i don't think that's clearing whatsoever

mutant is like poe town i guess, his mechanical approach is already giving him an incorrect read (regardless of his read on me ausuka/taly are 100% never scum here lmfao...) so i shouldn't discount him just hiding behind it but he's been fairly open with his thought process when asked w his simyk interactions so i dont think this is the case. not locktown but >randtown

taly's mathdino interactions lock him as clear. sorry but this isn't moving

i know ausuka's meta pretty well since lycanfire and i have discussed it over discord several times, ausuka is just... never scum here. she's like one of the most obvious scum players and she's 100% town here

pedit: i should probably get back to my coding too i have like nothing in my portfolio and my sister has been nagging me about wanting to make a game with her. im trying to teach myself C# rn and use unity since that's probably the fastest way to get something passable going

[Eddie Cane]

why did you rep in giga? I thought you were taking a break from mafia and busy irl

[Katyusha]

unable to stop my mafia addiction and have been like physically ill from not logging in on this site probably

ive been following this game for simyk and you so i figured repping in would be quick and painless lol

[Katyusha]

game is basically solved so it's a zero effort game on my part as well

[Eddie Cane]

last time there was a zero effort win town managed to lose

-fakegod

[Katyusha]

town lost because i depression flaked

im not in a depressive episode so!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!