Oh I see, so specifically referencing a post that exemplifies what I consider active lurking is “picking and choosing” …In post 1140, insanity018 wrote:Magna
Is doing the exact same thing he is doing yesterday. Picking and choosing that posts that suits his point of view and ignoring anything else.
@Magna, in that post you linked as "active lurking", I literally stated that I currently don't know which claims I believe.
And actively saying you are drawing no conclusions in a post doesn’t make it not an active lurking post. Why you think that …
But for kicks and grins lets talk about all your posts from today and how little actual attempts to solve the game are contained their-in, shall we?
985 – Open the day with some softball comments to Gingie, Rofl and Kison after bemoaning the “wagon” on you. Looking ahead of these questions that were supposedly meant to assess the scumminess there is no direct followup when neither Rofl or Ginngie responds. I find this especially troublesome that if those questions were supposed to help you sort them why did you not even bother to press either of them about it?
Also the “oh a wagon on me” seems pretty empty to me given you posted this right before EOD1 –
986 – Let me summarize this post –In post 864, insanity018 wrote:Honestly, I'm so tired of dealing with this game that I wouldn't even complain if you decided you wanted to flash lynch me.
Kison is scum because he doesn’t scum read Rofl and you think he should.
Rofl is “still” scummy.
Lycan is a scum read but you have lots of posts that make you think he could be Town (aka Fence Sitting)
Gut Town reads on Eddie and Axel (but Pine is scum if Axel is)
Superficially that post has many words but when you distill it down you have basically 4.25 solid reads. I also want to address the following –
The bolded I think doesn’t pass the smell test since you faced minimal pressure Day 1. And the unbolded I don’t think makes any sense from coming from Town – buddying up to “weaker” players by scum is much more effective than trying to buddy stronger players. Strong Town players tend to die. But “weaker” Town players generally are left to be endgamed.In post 986, insanity018 wrote:I think I'm one of the easier mislynches in this playerlist, so I think it would be less likely that scum would try to buddy me early in the game.
1006 – This whole post is basically “I disagree with how Kison approaches the game re: Rofl so he’s scum”.
1095 – So I’ve already stated this is IIoA fluff but let’s address it – there is no point saying you can’t come to a conclusion because no Town player should be that sure. There is possibility space for pretty much all permutations of Scum and Town between Lycan and OldMan. And your Tammy comment is basically “I agree with Tammy, but OldMan’s response is reasonable” which is just empty posting and your comment that my post was “interesting” is also empty. What does interesting mean? The answer is nothing – it wants to look like it is saying something but it abdicating actually taking a position.
1096 – More soft back and forth with Kison. And the following –
You are supposedly already reading Kison as scum for his Rofl interactions so why does his prodding of Rofl for content now make his ISO concerning? It wasn’t already suspicious back at 986?In post 1096, insanity018 wrote:If the rofl stuff isn't intended to put pressure, I now think that your ISO is concerning because of the lack of alignment-indicative questioning.
1127 – Even more softball questioning, this time to Lycan. The part I find problematic is the following –
Why should Lycan having a hard time parsing whether to believe OldMan’s claim be an issue for you since you yourself just stated you have a hard time parsing the claims? Seems odd for you to not be able to solidly commit to a conclusion yet but to be dinging someone else for the exact same action.In post 1127, insanity018 wrote:What is currently your read of Old Man? This post above states both town and scum possibilities.
So in summary your posts today look to me like scum pretending to scum-hunt with soft questioning and little follow-through when players don’t respond to your questions.
--
Also would still vote here if that wagon was more active than Insanity’s BTWIn post 1141, Axelrod wrote:Still no time for this. Sorry. Maybe tonight, maybe tomorrow. I suppose I could do one of those V/LA things, but I'm not actually on vacation.