just because muffina said its true doesn't mean it actually is.
it really is interesting to note that in your mind that he agreed with you makes it have value rather than what insight into muffina's alignment you gleaned from the exchange.
it seems like if you were town you wld actually be spending more time trying to figure out what muffina agreeing with you means, rather than trying to use it as a platform to validate your own position that it doesn't make feysal scummy in the first place.
does anybody else see where I am going with this?[/quote]
In post 262, Dunnstral wrote:No, because I said something then muffin expanded on it and said it in a way better than I did, I don't need to say the same thing he said in my own words but feysal can 100% have that opinion as town, wheras the argument is that no he basically can't
In post 265, zMuffinMan wrote:
you're reading something that isn't there
ill be sitting over here until you figure out im town
also, the following is a blatant lie:
I respond, one person is in clear disagreement, 4 or so players completely ignore you, AnonymousGhost has no idea what you're talking about
In post 300, thepixiecollective wrote: In post 284, AnonymousGhost wrote:Off topic but I wonder where the word 'heartstrings' came from... huh...
oh! btw!
I'm lost. Could you explain please?
I don't even remember where I was going with this, it was a thought I had at the time.
are you reading the game through isos or are you reading consecutive posts in thread time?
cos that will totally effect how I read you. for realz.
Not even you know what you're talking about anymore
In post 304, thepixiecollective wrote: In post 284, AnonymousGhost wrote:Off topic but I wonder where the word 'heartstrings' came from... huh...
oh! btw!
I'm lost. Could you explain please?
so! I went back. and then lost it again.
but it has returned.
dunnstral is using muffina to validate the argument that what feysal said was not cog-dis. or something. I am kind of confused how they all wound up at the same place tho.
what do you think?
ok, you got it again
In post 307, Dunnstral wrote: In post 304, thepixiecollective wrote:dunnstral is using muffina to validate the argument that what feysal said was not cog-dis. or something. I am kind of confused how they all wound up at the same place tho.
The rest of us are all in the same place because we all got the right answer
You should be more concerned with yourself being the only person seeing what you're seeing - it's because you're wrong and it's harder to replicate that thought process
I respond to you again. You've painted this picture of events that has happened that clearly hasn't, literally not one person has ever agreed with this point. Not even Kuribo, who has it out for me. He talked past you.
In post 475, thepixiecollective wrote: In post 452, Nachomamma8 wrote:DGB is another "pretty much lock town" read in this game; she doesn't have anywhere the same amount of bite whether scum or town and, while I can find that playing with scumpartners she likes can elevate her play, I don't think that it would be elevated to this level.
I understand where LLD's coming from this game (it's an extremely awkward and uncomfortable place to come from), but DGB's just being DGB at this point and there's no reason for continued interactions here - you're just making yourself angrier and this game will continue to grate and be unfun until you manage to let go/disconnect from that particular piece. I have no problems with her reads so far, like the Kuribo/Maria observation in particular.
I initially didn't understand it, but there was a similar and different dynamic with RC and Kuribo and believe that both Maria and Kuribo have the type of pride in their scumgames that can lead to an interaction like that.
I can't parse the bold at all. cld you unpack this for me?
is your muffina vote a srs vote? I hope it is a srs vote. but I wld like to lynch dunnstral first.
In post 498, thepixiecollective wrote: In post 476, Espeonage wrote:mollie, talk to me about why you have reads, but are prioritising them, especially when they are done in an order of leaving the better scum player alive longer.
Because the logic there is lost on me.
I am not sure what you are asking here? I have reads but they aren't in any particular order yet cos I am not fully done obtaining them. are you talking about me wanting to lynch dunns over muffina? its cos dunns is the stronger scumread. my townreads are...well, my townreads.
In post 502, thepixiecollective wrote: In post 484, MariaR wrote:I have my Dunnstral read but I'll keep it to myself for now and see how others play on it cause I expect others to sheep my Dunn read once I say it.
you might want to lower your expectations there cos I for 1 am only going to listen to my own read. I have hydras with 5 players in this game, are you going to sheep my reads on all 5 of those players?
In post 512, thepixiecollective wrote: In post 509, MariaR wrote: In post 502, thepixiecollective wrote: In post 484, MariaR wrote:I have my Dunnstral read but I'll keep it to myself for now and see how others play on it cause I expect others to sheep my Dunn read once I say it.
you might want to lower your expectations there cos I for 1 am only going to listen to my own read. I have hydras with 5 players in this game, are you going to sheep my reads on all 5 of those players?
I can read Dunnstral better than any player and that's not even a joke. I'm his bestie for over a year I think my case trumps yours but sure do as you wish it's up to you to believe me when I say it or not
I gotcha and we are about even in that respect
I will take it in consideration and ty for the intel. I think dunns looks scummy scummy scummy but you have something to counter that I am all ears cos I don't want to wind up in a needless deathtunnel.
In post 513, thepixiecollective wrote:
kuribo
ag
maria
lld
dgb
espy
feysal
cupcake
nacho
kokichi
muffina
dunnes
staeg
likely wrong somewhere but this is where we are at.
In post 577, thepixiecollective wrote: In post 576, zMuffinMan wrote:what did you think of nacho's entrance btw?
don't really like the staeg defense - i wouldn't classify anything staeg's posted as "snarky" but even if i squint and look at his posts sideways, i can't see what he's referring to. nacho's reasoning for voting me feels pretty weak. don't really like the fact he put a lot more effort into talking about things other than his primary scum read, especially since he should know it's going to take a lot more than that to actually get me lynched (i get that he's time-constrained but he had enough time to post the rest of what he posted so yeah)
I am not thrilled with nacho's posts. they seem very hollow and they lack the verve that I am used to seeing from him. however I had misread him often enough to give him more time and wait to see what else he comes up with.
what is your read on dunns? you said you were fine with lynching him but what is your actual read on him?
In post 582, thepixiecollective wrote: In post 580, zMuffinMan wrote:i didnt like his entrance; it felt flat and uninspired? something like that. actually a lot of his posting feels flat but i don't have as much of an issue with it as i did initially
i guess if you want an example of a small thing i'm talking about, i think the way he's handling LLD looks townish (i.e. i like that he's not trying to fan the flames between her and DGB). like i said, nothing special here
I don't see that as alignment indicative, anybody with a passing familiarity with lld and dgb (and me for that matter) knows how combustible the situ can get and any sane person wld want to prevent that. just cos he is sane doesn't make him town.
I have played against scum!dunns before and he is the type to just kind of sit back and let things play out and let town eat its own, which is what I see him doing here. I also don't believe that he doesn't read kuribo as town at this point.
OK, you have actual reasoning here. Ironically, it's pretty much a gut read. I don't remember this game where I've played against you and sat back and let town eat it's own - can you link it to back up your argument?
In post 613, thepixiecollective wrote:Phone posting, so plz forgive me for autocorrect mistakes.
@Maria - do you have Dunns as town or no cos I am confused
In post 623, thepixiecollective wrote:
I wanted to get back to this post cos I tried to respond to this, this morning and I got cut off.
those are 2 big differences considering I think dunns is scum and that is who I am pushing.
who do you want lynched besides the cupcake? I can tell you rn you aren't going to get that lynch past dgb and kuribo. I have tried.
In post 639, thepixiecollective wrote: In post 631, camntsuki wrote: In post 622, kuribo wrote: In post 619, Dunnstral wrote: In post 618, Feysal wrote:But as scum, why would he bother, when the whole point of the crumb is that he should not know what the town is called, and he does? Him doing that as scum would practically require cognitive dissonance.
He was selling the idea that scum didn't know this knowledge, and everyone else was either lapping it up or too disconnected from the game to do anything about it. If he's scum he's trying to make himself look like town, that's a motivation
How bout you put your vote where your mouth is and we see who gets roped first
Then after I string you, I'm coming for your buddies
THIS DUNNSTRAL WAGON RESISTANCE IS UNREAL
^^^
In post 642, thepixiecollective wrote: In post 641, DrippingGoofball wrote: In post 639, thepixiecollective wrote: In post 631, camntsuki wrote: In post 622, kuribo wrote: In post 619, Dunnstral wrote: In post 618, Feysal wrote:But as scum, why would he bother, when the whole point of the crumb is that he should not know what the town is called, and he does? Him doing that as scum would practically require cognitive dissonance.
He was selling the idea that scum didn't know this knowledge, and everyone else was either lapping it up or too disconnected from the game to do anything about it. If he's scum he's trying to make himself look like town, that's a motivation
How bout you put your vote where your mouth is and we see who gets roped first
Then after I string you, I'm coming for your buddies
THIS DUNNSTRAL WAGON RESISTANCE IS UNREAL
^^^
I don't fund Dunnstral scummy at all, but maybe the scum is bus'ing. They know things I don't.
:neutral:
if scum are bussing then why is town not helping them
Lots of empty pushing on me without anyone ever agreeing with your reasons to do so.
You never cared about your initial point past when you pushed it.
A literal gut read in the middle of it.
