In post 293, Completly Trustworthy wrote:Here are the reasons I have been somewhat suspicious of Chardev throughout the game:
In
7,
9,
10,
12,
16 and
20, and
27, he talks about what his suspicions levels mean and has an argument about a minor point with me, there was little new content created during those posts.
NAI
In
44, Chardev says something is NAI, which does not lead to any conclusions.
NAI
In
65, Chardev gives advice to Demonic about what is right to do and merely says he is a little more suspicious.
NAI
Then in
68, he goes ahead and votes for Demonic despite his previous post, which seemed sudden, almost as if he was hopping onto a wagon.
eh, I see your point here, but he was also a noob
He unvotes in
85 defensively and posts reads which most people probably agreed on at that point.
sheep/=/ scum
96 is merely a repeat of his question in 85, which does not add more content.
NAI
120 features a question about Lefty's reason for suspecting Sunny even after Lefty said it was mostly gut and there was little logic involved. Also, he gives a FOS to me out of the blue which I have talked about in my previous posts.
questioning gut reads is towny
In
146, Chardev indicates he believes that Demon and Lefty were misunderstanding earlier when they made reads and are new players.
NAI
In
168, he goes ahead and votes Lefty despite his previous post indicating his opinion was changing for the better.
minds can change. NAI
214 is merely a prelude to post 216
NAI
216 may seem like it adds to the game, but my post by post analysis of Ugly Duck and Zito's comments on it probably supplied much of the information he used there. Also, this came after a two day absence, why did he return only to give an intent to hammer Ugly Duck, a town player? I think that Chardev could have supplied much more content than he has based on his early posts and is only posting to put town players under suspicion.
