Newbie 1882 - Game Over

[Eragon]

meaning we have 3 people out of 6 who are confirmed town

[teacher]

Before outing analysis that scum can use later can we try to get consensus on no lynch/lynch? And I’m hard pushing the former.

The doc probably healed Duck. Scum parked their roleblock somewhere ineffective (Duck?)

[Eragon]

how about this

DOC,

if your target N1 was anyone other than Skygazer, Reck, or UD, claim now and claim your target

[teacher]

Agree there.

[Completly Trustworthy]

Eragon, you are once again being overly defensive by attacking me instead of explaining your feelings on HeWhoSwims. In addition, I do not claim that my case on Chardev is great, it just shows that my suspicion of his slot has been around for a while. I did not change my feelings on you suddenly. I townread your initial entrance to the game because of your unique opinions, but your behavior has been very scummy ever since.

[Completly Trustworthy]

Also, what would a no lynch accomplish Teacher? Wouldn't the scum just try to kill people who are not likely to be suspected like you and UglyDuck? That would just leave us with the same pool of suspects.

[Completly Trustworthy]

Finally, I am the doctor and protected Teacher night one, I will explain why I did that tomorrow since I'm sleepy.

[teacher]

Yay I’m townclear.

[Eragon]

Eragon, you are once again being overly defensive by attacking me instead of explaining your feelings on HeWhoSwims. In addition, I do not claim that my case on Chardev is great, it just shows that my suspicion of his slot has been around for a while. I did not change my feelings on you suddenly. I townread your initial entrance to the game because of your unique opinions, but your behavior has been very scummy ever since.

I am not attacking you. I am defending myself and my slot from your push. And your claim is not great at all, in fact, almost everything you wrote is entirely NAI, meaning it shouldn't be a reason to SR someone.

I haventexplained my feelings on HWS because AS IVE FUCKING TOLD YOU I DIDNT FINISH THE ISO and am not 100% sure about it. I have gone partway through the ISO, and of the 3 I have in my PoE, I feel he has the best chance of flipping scum so far

[Eragon]

ok cool.

it doesn't really help me clear teacher because I already had him as clear XD

but it does clear Ct, which in turn makes it so that the only possible Scumteam Is {HWS, papa Zito}

good job town

[teacher]

Also, what would a no lynch accomplish Teacher? Wouldn't the scum just try to kill people who are not likely to be suspected like you and UglyDuck? That would just leave us with the same pool of suspects.

Yes. I assumed that there was not another townclear. Your info changes it.

As a general matter, no lynch is best at mylo simply to increase the odds of hitting scum, especially when there is an unknown protective or investigative who could create a new clear. But since we have already mass claimed it is time to PoE it.

[teacher]

Actually I’m not townclear because of C2 and the wifom possibility of no night kill. And Lando isn’t clear either. Just adds a wrinkle.

UD who did you null-check?

Any other PRs want to claim?

[Eragon]

w 1 Town Cop and Town Neapolitan Town Cop and Town Tracker Town Cop and Vanilla Townie
Row 2 Town Jailkeeper and Town Doctor Town Jailkeeper and Town Tracker Town Jailkeeper and Vanilla Townie
Row 3 Town Cop and Town Doctor Town Neapolitan and Town Doctor Town Tracker and Town Doctor

hmmmm....

I claim copolitan keeper that tracks the doc?

is that a sweet enough PR claim for you

[teacher]

Lando - any crumbs at all?

[Eragon]

I can't wait for HWS and Papa start attacking me, the only person possible to mis-lynch LMAO

come at me hard m8s

[teacher]

Eragon,

While I remain town and am fairly convinced after a quick ISO that that is the team, I want to make sure we don’t clear Lando. Scum could very easily have decided to no nk N1 if they were townread enough in order to be able to claim doctor and guarantee a win at mylo/lylo. And Lando was universally townread.

[Eragon]

true...

but i dont know how we decipher that other than WIFOM

[Completly Trustworthy]

I'd expect the scum to cc at this point, me and Teacher becoming locktown would be bad for them since it would leave only one mislynch left. If I'm right about Eragon being scum, then Papa Zito would be the likeliest to do that since HWS is probably not his teammate.
I protected Teacher night one because I figured that it was the best thing to do in both possibilities. If Duck was lying and happened to be scum, I would not want to guard him. If he was telling the truth, the jailkeeper claim and roleblocker would ensure the scum knew about the doctor in the setup, making him unlikely to be targeted. I figured that since Teacher was universally townread and had participated in the game more than other player, the scum would likely go for him, I was correct and stopped the kill.
I also protected Teacher night 2 as well because I thought Teacher was the more valuable player(Duck was almost certainly roleblocked on both nights, so I thought of him as a vt) and didn't want someone I knew was town dying in place of a player like Reckoner who was formally a suspect.

[Completly Trustworthy]

Teacher, why do you think HWS and Zito are scum? Can you show what made you suspicious of them being together when going through ISO's?

[Completly Trustworthy]

However, I can agree on lynching Zito since both of us believe he is scum.
VOTE: Papa Zito

[teacher]

VOTE: unvote
Crazy busy day prepping for new job. Will respond to your question tonight. A lot of it is VCA.

[teacher]

But yea I’m going to need “more words” papito.

[Eragon]

im also willing to vote papa, because unless CT/UD makes some sort of god-like play, then we have the three previous stated as lock!town, and me, who I know is town, leaving ONLY papa zito and HeWhoSwims

[UglyDuck]

think about it this way


the doc claims.
they claim who they healed N1.

both people are mechanically lock-town

? How am I lock town, and Sky flipped VT, and you still need to know who the Doc healed N1?

[teacher]

Who did you nullvheck?