Umm... you're mistaken. B.S. is a very good mod. If he made an error with the list, he would know that the correct move is to say nothing and limit the damage. A mod announcement that an error was made basically clears Math. Uncertainty vs. making a player IC. It's obvious which is the correct choice for a mod.In post 11709, Toranaga wrote:alternatively, scum can have a saying in what goes or doesn't go as abilities the next day
if there was mod error, there would be a mod announcement. you can't assume mod error to clear math for this.
What I KNOW is that Math nailed a new power in the right spot. I also know that Math ended up leader in a situation where that's not possible without 3 votes for Math. I know there's 3 scum left. Therefore Math cannot be scum.
That leaves me having to assume either a mod error or a scum ability are the most likely explanations for Math having a partially correct list.