#3: dva replacing scioness. this was brought up as maybe AI for scioness as she doesn't like to play scum, but it's been denied that this is AI because scioness was actually taking a break from all her games.
#5: this is already towny for alchemist, jumping on that replacement thing. I think it's very unlikely they're scum together at least.
#7: tommy sheeping this vote feels awkward. I think town would like to explore alchemist's statement instead of just sheeping it, so I'm suspicious of tommy's mindset. small thing.
#9: dva's entrance.
#11: from alchemist is a very strong point against dva. she got 3 votes and isn't commenting on people voting her. alchemist/dva are pointing to not being svs all the way. alchemist is towny.
#28 and #30: from saudade. I don't like this. saudade is definitely smart enough to be reading into the interactions from p1, and his response to alchemist reads like a fake excuse and not something saudade actually believes. saudade's reaction to alchemist saying dva is scum because scioness subbed out implies saudade didn't read anything before posting. I dislike his reaction too, it's a little over the top. #31 to #36 feel off.
#45 from tommy. I find it scummy to be arguing that things are NAI like he is doing here. there's no purpose for this post at all.
#47 from guerilla is a very good post with a very good vote given what happened so far.
#49 from gamma is strange. he is defending saudade but I don't think saudade was being towny to be defended, as he gave 0 thoughts on the game so far.
#51 from ezekel. scumreading people for reading into scioness replacement as scummy. this is yet another player reacting oddly to alchemist's suggestion. not sure what to make of it, but if scioness does replace out as scum a lot cause she hates it, what's scummy about suggesting the replace out is scummy? I don't understand this post. #54 is a bad follow up too.
#56 from guerilla. this is a good push on ezekel, and I agree with the reasoning. instead of voting players who he finds scummy, ezekel is just randomly pointing at no one in particular as scummy instead of just voting someone, as if he was asking the thread for permission to scumread people, as guerilla pointed out. this is good. guerilla very towny here, alongside alchemist. ezekel, saudade and gamma don't feel towny so far.
#59 from guerilla. ~always town IMO.
#60 from dva. bad vote, but it's understandable that she is defensive here. and voting tommy isn't bad.
up to #67 from saudade are awful posts. the ones calling dva's name ugly but not AI are awkward, and then the way he approaches ezekel on #67 is the scummiest post of the game so far. it's coming off as commentary on people's actions and behaviour without trying to draw a read on their alignment. it reads really weird to me. saying ezekel deserves to be voted for his presentation, when the idea behind it isn't scummy, is weird levels of treating ezekel as if he knows ezekel's alignment. why is saudade doing live coaching on ezekel's posts? does he think they're towny, or scummy, or what?
also a note on this: saudade is saying ezekel's idea isn't scummy, so is it towny? "not scum-like" implies the idea itself is NAI to saudade. if the idea is NAI, then ezekel is not excused for acting scummy around it, so why is saudade not phrasing this as a scumread? this is so scummy.