the worst Idea Mafia - Game Over!

[Almost50]

1. Where's the whole idea that there may be a cult coming from?

S_S suggested it when I questioned his 2 anti-Town factions in light of having only 1 NK per night so far.

[Almost50]

2. Is it stated anywhere that being recruited to a cult also vanillises them?

It is the way cults work.

[Almost50]

My lynch pool atm is bnl a50 carca sv.

Alright, Lynch me already.

I'm also going to preemptively claim: I'm effectively a named Townie. My Role is GODFATHER, but I have no special abilities. I investigate as Town to Cops, but Godfather to Role Cops.

This is what I got (or rather NicoRobin did): Town Godfather + Town Regretful Vigilante + Survivor 1-Shot Miller

So, there were 5 combinations for her choose from (all of them suck if you ask me):

Town Godfather
Town Regretful Vigilante
Town 1-Shot Miller
Survivor Regretful Vigilante
Survivor Godsfather

Obviously the Regretful Vigilante role sucks. Why would anyone want to die with their NK target as any alignment?
Town Miller also isn't a viable option, so I guess Nico had to pick GF for her role, and then choose between Town and Survivor for her alignment. *Shrug*

That's probably why she replaced out because it's quite boring, but then this is Nico and she would have probably replaced out anyway.

[Almost50]

@Gamma: Your modding is sub-par (yours and your comod's ). I had to ISO you to remember whom Chara replaced. PLEASE UPDATE THE OP.

[Chara]

Actually, can someone with experience with A50 tell me if he always makes these weird tinfoil hat theory posts, especially in a theme game?

*raises hand*

[Chara]

You're in her slot. From what I've gathered, it seems to be for the lols
Even though shes a bit more serious than that from whatever I know about her

i know i'm in her slot. that doesn't mean i know her thought process.

BnL: i feel as though i've just said?
pirate traitor, post streamer, and town friendly neighbour.
post streamer's alignment was listed as vanilla.

Because I still don't understand how the alignment and role from the same card would have been discarded @xtoxm.

because the card you took neither the alignment nor the role from is what was discarded. what's confusing, yours was like thay too wasn't it?

[Chara]

Eh I want to scumread Xtoxm based on VCA but I'm townreading his play here

VCA is pretty trash in likely multiball GIM anyway

Btw I voted A50 over Carca because his posts are painful to read

Although there may be something I'm missing out

i'm not worrying about multiball until there's evidence of it in kills.
if there's a cult i feel like we may be screwed anyway, as was just said.
i'm townreading most of the recent discussion.

if anyone is townreading SS could they yell at me as to why?

pedit: hi Almost! thanks for towntelling.

Soulreading now. I don't really have a good reason to townread SS, I just believe him when he said he would pick town given the chance, and I generally like his posts, not even in the "I think this is town" way but in the "It pleases me reading this" way.

Maybe I should put him out of my town pool, I just don't know.

VOTE: BnL
lots of "buts", lots of ways out of his stances. scum does this to seem like unsure town and to pretend to care.

not to mention he has two scumreads and i'm one of them, so why does he react to my prodding about SS with "maybe i shouldn't be townreading him after all"?

[Chara]

When you receive your Role PMs, you must select an alignment and role from 2/3 of the cards. You may not select both from the same card. The card you do not take either from will be discarded, and will show up in the playerlist as well as a special post I will make when the setup is finalized. Your discard will have your name connected to it.

was your discard one of the things you picked?

[Chara]

Carca gets a small gut-town read, it seems reasonable based on her personality.

[RCEnigma]

Yeah but the discarded role is from the same card. I assume it is vanilla/ post streamer that was discarded. But idk there are other similar discards.

My alignments we're Town Town SK so it wasn't the same I guess.

[Gamma Emerald]

@Gamma: Your modding is sub-par (yours and your comod's ). I had to ISO you to remember whom Chara replaced. PLEASE UPDATE THE OP.

I updated the table start of D3, including replacements during D2. Maybe look harder next time.

[Chara]

Yeah but the discarded role is from the same card. I assume it is vanilla/ post streamer that was discarded. But idk there are other similar discards.

My alignments we're Town Town SK so it wasn't the same I guess.

i'm still not getting where your confusion lies. the discarded role is supposed to be from the same card as the discarded alignment.

[Chara]

Cheeky took Traitor from one card, and Town from another. thus Post Streamer was discarded because nothing was taken from it.

[Xtoxm]

My lynch pool atm is bnl a50 carca sv.

Alright, Lynch me already.

Ok

VOTE: A50

[RCEnigma]

Oooooh your right. I'm losing my mind.

[Shock Value]

My lynch pool atm is bnl a50 carca sv.

Alright, Lynch me already.

Ok

VOTE: A50

Dammit, you stole my post! XD

As for whether A50 is regularly tinfoily, well yes. But I don't thjnk to this degree. It's more like he has a narrative to push here than something to figure out. That's the difference.

[Shock Value]

Also,

@Gamma: Your modding is sub-par (yours and your comod's ). I had to ISO you to remember whom Chara replaced. PLEASE UPDATE THE OP.

I updated the table start of D3, including replacements during D2. Maybe look harder next time.

Buuuuurn! XD

[Chara]

As for whether A50 is regularly tinfoily, well yes. But I don't thjnk to this degree. It's more like he has a narrative to push here than something to figure out. That's the difference.

what's the tinfoily narrative he's pushing?

[Gamma Emerald]

RESERVED HEHEHEHE ♪

[Eragon]

RIP i can barely get into this game again

ill try to make a townblock soon :/

[Something_Smart]

Isn't the much simpler answer "Why wouldn't he kill/action if he could?"

I mean, they could be goon/odd-night/anything passive (probably double lyncher, since Xtoxm confirmed that's their role) on a team with someone else who made the kill.

[BNL]

Eh I want to scumread Xtoxm based on VCA but I'm townreading his play here

VCA is pretty trash in likely multiball GIM anyway

Btw I voted A50 over Carca because his posts are painful to read

Although there may be something I'm missing out

i'm not worrying about multiball until there's evidence of it in kills.
if there's a cult i feel like we may be screwed anyway, as was just said.
i'm townreading most of the recent discussion.

if anyone is townreading SS could they yell at me as to why?

pedit: hi Almost! thanks for towntelling.

Soulreading now. I don't really have a good reason to townread SS, I just believe him when he said he would pick town given the chance, and I generally like his posts, not even in the "I think this is town" way but in the "It pleases me reading this" way.

Maybe I should put him out of my town pool, I just don't know.

VOTE: BnL
lots of "buts", lots of ways out of his stances. scum does this to seem like unsure town and to pretend to care.

not to mention he has two scumreads and i'm one of them, so why does he react to my prodding about SS with "maybe i shouldn't be townreading him after all"?

Because a lot of my townreads are very weak and I am not very confident in them, and I feel I'm bound to be wrong somewhere. Also, it's just answering your question, and I don't ignore questions from people I don't townread, in fact you just did didn't you?

Actually, can someone with experience with A50 tell me if he always makes these weird tinfoil hat theory posts, especially in a theme game?

*raises hand*

[BNL]

In fact, I am going to have to remake my townblock because both A50 and Chara are have done things on this page I consider towny, which means I feel I'm letting people into my townblock too easily.

Come to think of it I have really been only picking up things I consider town and hardly gotten any scumpings this game.

[BNL]

So Eragon is still likely town based on role

Which means Shock Value is likely town or at least non harmful

And on reread I think I want to lock SS as town too

[BNL]

Tbh role aside I actually feel like Xtoxm has been acting kinda scummy